Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Green Bay Packers and Minnesota Vikings

[Reptar]

Quote: Originally Posted by PackerBacker123

Um.... are you kidding me. The only reason people think he is not that good is because he got injuried last season.

Vernon Davis had as many TD's last year as Finley has in his career with ALEX SMITH and TROY SMITH.Vernon is rated 91...

[PackerBacker123]

OVERRATED Barrnet, Colledge, and Quin Johnson.
UNDERRATED Starks, Shields, Zombo, Mcdonald, Masthay, and Neal.
JUST RIGHT Sitton, Bishop, Bulaga, Hawk, and Flynn.

[schnaidt1]

so mastay ( sp) should be higher, he punted well all year.
on nfl.com crosby is 1. fantasy kicker. so his rating should be higher.

tho they arent packers anymore. barnett an jenkins should each be about 5 points lower.
i feel like sam shields got robbed. he madr some incredible play last year. watch by mid season he will be ranked in the low 80's.

finley is too high simply from being hurt. should be around 86.
with in season progression in franchise. he'll be up to 90 again soon enough

other than some speed and accel issues also. these are all right

[PackerBacker123]

Quote: Originally Posted by schnaidt1

so mastay ( sp) should be higher, he punted well all year. on nfl.com crosby is 1. fantasy kicker. so his rating should be higher. tho they arent packers anymore. barnett an jenkins should each be about 5 points lower. i feel like sam shields got robbed. he madr some incredible play last year. watch by mid season he will be ranked in the low 80's. finley is too high simply from being hurt. should be around 86. with in season progression in franchise. he'll be up to 90 again soon enough other than some speed and accel issues also. these are all right

I pretty much agree with you on everything here.

[aceoye]

Quote: Originally Posted by DeuceDouglas

Man they did Grant dirty for getting injured. An 82? I would bump him up a couple points. I'm a little hesitant to believe that Clay Matthews is one of the Packers top coverage linebackers.

lol I know right dont make any sense..I guess somehow they didnt want starks up there in the 80s since hes good and putting grant to an 82 makes it seem like starks is close to him without them both having mid-low 80s ratings..oh well and how did the give cobb that speed...thats off

[DeuceDouglas]

I gotta agree with Finley being too high. There are other TE out there who put up better season's than Finley's from two years ago. Cooley 87. Watson 83. Pettigrew 81. Miller 89. And you could argue that three of those guys didn't have the supporting cast and pass heavy offense that Finley was involved with.

[aceoye]

Quote: Originally Posted by schnaidt1

so mastay ( sp) should be higher, he punted well all year. on nfl.com crosby is 1. fantasy kicker. so his rating should be higher. tho they arent packers anymore. barnett an jenkins should each be about 5 points lower. i feel like sam shields got robbed. he madr some incredible play last year. watch by mid season he will be ranked in the low 80's. finley is too high simply from being hurt. should be around 86. with in season progression in franchise. he'll be up to 90 again soon enough other than some speed and accel issues also. these are all right

Yea there are unproven rookie cb's rated higher than sam shields.

[raggBAGG]

I gotta say I think the Packs linebacks need a bump. There is a reason they let Barnett walk and they are believed to have a fairly deep linebacker core. It looks as though one of their linebackers starting might be in the 60s? That makes no sense.