Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Jacksonville Jaguars and Tennessee Titans

[Palo20]

Almost all of Gabbert's throwing accuracy ratings are better than Garrard's. I thought him and Locker are supposed to be projects? They should be day 1 starters in user franchises.

Motell Owens is an 84 OVR FB, same as Greg Jones. Jones is one of the best FBs in the league, Owens is a special teams ace who never plays FB. Interesting OVR formula there.

Marcedes Lewis should have 90+ SPC (for the special animations). He always makes amazing catches down the seam.

Everything else looks pretty solid for the Jags.

[illwill10]

Quote: Originally Posted by Palo20

Almost all of Gabbert's throwing accuracy ratings are better than Garrard's. I thought him and Locker are supposed to be projects? They should be day 1 starters in user franchises.

Mallet can also start in users franchises(he will in my franchise). He comes in with 98 THP, 83 TAS, 84 TAM and PAC. Only thing that makes him lowly rated is his 41 AWR. He will be my starting QB for my Phins Franchise

[Palo20]

Quote: Originally Posted by illwill10

Mallet can also start in users franchises(he will in my franchise). He comes in with 98 THP, 83 TAS, 84 TAM and PAC. Only thing that makes him lowly rated is his 41 AWR. He will be my starting QB for my Phins Franchise

NO! The Pats will not trade you Mallet!

Anyway, yeah, the rookie QBs seem fairly overrated in all of the ratings that matter when playing the game.

Although I know a lot of people claim that AWR does affect on field play for QBs so who knows?

[illwill10]

Quote: Originally Posted by Palo20

NO! The Pats will not trade you Mallet! Anyway, yeah, the rookie QBs seem fairly overrated in all of the ratings that matter when playing the game. Although I know a lot of people claim that AWR does affect on field play for QBs so who knows?

I will trade Henne for Mallet. Heck I might even trade him back after I get Andrew Luck in the draft.
They are overatted, but it is only really the top 3(including Mallet). Dalton only high rated is TAS, all other are low.
AWR is a big factor, but if you are controlling them it isnt a factor
Using Mallet as a Starter and simming the season, there is a good chance for top pick

[cha0ss0ldier]

Mike Thomas is better than a 79.

Montell Owens is a special teams beast but he is NOT as good as Greg Jones at FB.

[Smoke316]

Quote: Originally Posted by xpmar9x

Jason Jones needs to be switched to DE. Add Tommie Campbell (7th rd pick), likely to win #4 CB spot. 6'3 205, runs a 4.35. Hasselbeck should be around a low 80. Barrett Ruud should be a high 80. Shaun Smith roughly a 75. Graham a 72-75. What I like: CJ2K looks to be unstoppable (again). Britt, Washington, Gage, Mariani all 70+ WRs.. giving some decent tagets. Mariani finally has some speed at 92-92-93. Jared Cook is the unknown killer. 76 overall, 85 speed/89 acc. Should be a threat. Lockers ratings. 74 overall, 83 speed, 87 acc, 95 TP, 74 ACC. Then 75 Short Acc, 77 Mid, 83 Deep, with 90 Throw on Run. I'd say those are nearly perfect for Lock. Solid OL, 91 - 80 - 73- 83 - 91 Ringer. 88 speed, but 95 acc. Should be a decent #2 option for a couple carries a game. Overrated: --> Chris Hope. He's an 87, and is WAY to high. Should be about a 79, at best. AWR and every coverage stat should be decreased Hope always gets burned is coverage. --> Dave Ball. Currently at an 81. Ball is good, but not that high, maybe a 75ish. Underrated: --> Damian Williams. He's likely to be the starting slot WR for the Titans, but is a 67 overall. Also has a 82 acceleration? He doesn't have top end speed, but is very quick starting up. Shhould be about 88 speed, 92 acceleration. He'll get boosted when he gets more playing time. Lavelle Hawkins is rated higher. --> Gerald McRath. More specifically his speed. Ran the 2nd fastest LB 40 in his combine, behind Curry. But is only an 81 speed. Witherspoon is faster than him? No way. McRath should be a 85+ speed, 85+ acceleration. --> Rennie Curran. He doesn't get a lot of playing time, but he's a BIG HITTER. His Hit Power should be increased to 85+ easily. Just watch out for him this year in special teams. -> Fernado Velasco. Got some playing time last year, and did great. Only a 54? He's probably our BEST OL off the bench. Should be more in the 70 range.

nice to see Titans fan on here really go in depth like this. Great breakdown

[titans321]

How is Jamaal Charles's elusiveness rating a 99, but Chris Johnson's is an 88?

[xpmar9x]

Quote: Originally Posted by titans321

How is Jamaal Charles's elusiveness rating a 99, but Chris Johnson's is an 88?

I wonder that myself...