FBGRatings Seeks to Recalibrate Madden Ratings, Change Game

[garret2]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

ALL ratings are not based off of stats, but are based off of scouting data via professional scouts for the NFL.

so if they aren't based off of stats or performance then why will player ratings change once in season? do scouting reports change during the season?

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by xblake16x

So what if any ratings are based on statistics?

No ratings are based on statistics.

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by garret2

so if they aren't based off of stats or performance then why will player ratings change once in season? do scouting reports change during the season?

Let's have a lesson in logic, shall we?

1. No FBG ratings are based on statistics.
2. Ratings change during the season.
3. Ratings are based upon scouting data.
___________________________________
4. ???

Is the answer to the logic above:
A. Stupid questions deserve stupid answers
B. People don't read the forums and thus CONTINUE to ask stupid questions
C. Scouting data changes throughout a season
D. Everybody is jealous of the GB Packers 13 NFL titles

Thoughts?

[mestevo]

You get so many "stupid questions" because this thread should be in the roster sub forum where only people genuinely interested in this work would see the updates for the most part.

Personally I'd start a new thread in the roster forum so that you've got control of the OP and can maintain a FAQ.

Continue to update this news thread with your progress here in the main Madden forum and you can expect plenty more "stupid questions" to come

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by mestevo

You get so many "stupid questions" because this thread should be in the roster sub forum where only people genuinely interested in this work would see the updates for the most part. Personally I'd start a new thread in the roster forum so that you've got control of the OP and can maintain a FAQ. Continue to update this news thread with your progress here in the main Madden forum and you can expect plenty more "stupid questions" to come

I had no control where the moderator placed the thread. They can move it if they wish though.

[mestevo]

Glancing at the OP, this is a thread about an interview, not about the running progress of the project, like I said you could always start a new thread or continue to update this one (if they won't move it). Either way that's why you are getting Some of the questions you are getting, and it will only get worse as release approaches, traffic spikes, and the thread continues to get longer.


---
I am here: http://maps.google.com/maps?ll=35.991738,-115.142075

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by mestevo

Glancing at the OP, this is a thread about an interview, not about the running progress of the project, like I said you could always start a new thread or continue to update this one (if they won't move it). Either way that's why you are getting Some of the questions you are getting, and it will only get worse as release approaches, traffic spikes, and the thread continues to get longer. --- I am here: http://maps.google.com/maps?ll=35.991738,-115.142075

Technically though, this is not a roster thread. I don't produce rosters. It is about the website in general. The thread was regarding the interview about the site and to peak interest and answer questions. What causes an inconvenience is when many, many questions have already been answered and keep coming up. I feel like I have been good enough to answer them when they come up, but it gets old to keep hearing the same old thing.

[micahmcd10]

so in your honest opinion, nate washington is a better receiver than reggie wayne, hakeem nicks, miles austin, vincent jackson, brandon marshall, sidney rice, dwayne bowe, etc.?