Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 6 Wide Receivers

[steinhauser34]

desean jackson isnt a top 10 wr. hes fast as hell and very explosive but you put a lockdown corner on him he wont get ****. hes not a great route runner and his hands arent fantastic. hes like devin hester, incredibly valuable to the team but that doesn't make him tops at his position

[bmj2k7]

Sorry i meant jordy nelson not shipley and nelson did make jennings dissapear which is why nfl players ranked 14 wide recievers ahead of jennings, let me repaet that, 14 Wrs were rated higher than jennings, bc nelson showed him up, if it wasn't for him they don't with the superbowl and jennings 2 tds dont matter, jennings is a good receiver but more on the 85 range than 93 range, i'd take megatron 93 over jennings 93 everyday of the year bc there no where near the same caliber of a player, megatron is leaps and bounds better than jennings, and the league showed that with there top 100!

[BlackJackRabbit]

Quote: Originally Posted by at23steelers

1. AJ 2. Fitzy 3. White 4. CJ 5. Wayne 6. Jennings 7. Brandon Marshall 8. Welker 9. Steve Smith (Car) 10. Holmes 11. Lloyd 12. Wallace 13. Desean Jackson 14. Bowe 15. Vincent Jackson

Welker is a system guy; he did nothing prior to being picked up by the Patriots. Steve Smith's tank is on E, and Brandon Lloyd had one good year.

[BlackJackRabbit]

Quote: Originally Posted by steinhauser34

desean jackson isnt a top 10 wr. hes fast as hell and very explosive but you put a lockdown corner on him he wont get ****. hes not a great route runner and his hands arent fantastic. hes like devin hester, incredibly valuable to the team but that doesn't make him tops at his position

That statement makes your opinion irrelevant.

[at23steelers]

Quote: Originally Posted by BlackJackRabbit

Welker is a system guy; he did nothing prior to being picked up by the Patriots. Steve Smith's tank is on E, and Brandon Lloyd had one good year.

That's why it's so hard to make a list like this. Steve Smith had horrendous QB play, but if he had a solid QB throwing to him, I think it would be different. What is your top 15 list then?

[ConnSKINS26]

Quote: Originally Posted by at23steelers

1. AJ 2. Fitzy 3. White 4. CJ 5. Wayne 6. Jennings 7. Brandon Marshall 8. Welker 9. Steve Smith (Car) 10. Holmes 11. Lloyd 12. Wallace 13. Desean Jackson 14. Bowe 15. Vincent Jackson

Hakeem Nicks??? Welker needs to be off this list, and Wallace needs to be higher.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheAlter95

Calvin Johnson is quite a bit faster than larry fitzgerald, calvin ran a 4.35 forty yard dash and larry fitzgerald ran a 4.63, i know some say its overated but that much of a difference is obvious whos faster. even without that its easy to tell calvin is faster thus why hes much faster in madden

Jerry Rice ran a 4.65 I never saw anyone catch him from behind with the ball in his hand. 40 times are useless.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by bmj2k7

Sorry i meant jordy nelson not shipley and nelson did make jennings dissapear which is why nfl players ranked 14 wide recievers ahead of jennings, let me repaet that, 14 Wrs were rated higher than jennings, bc nelson showed him up, if it wasn't for him they don't with the superbowl and jennings 2 tds dont matter, jennings is a good receiver but more on the 85 range than 93 range, i'd take megatron 93 over jennings 93 everyday of the year bc there no where near the same caliber of a player, megatron is leaps and bounds better than jennings, and the league showed that with there top 100!

Who can argue with this kind of logic. Lol.