Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 6 Wide Receivers

[Broncos86]

Quote: Originally Posted by ANDROMADA 1

One word. Kitna. Breaking 1,000 yards with all the team went through last year is in itself amazing. He will be right back to playing at an elite level with the return of Romo.

In that case, Brandon Lloyd should be #1, considering what he did last year and the numbers he put up. But I'm not advocating that, because one year does not make a player. He needs to put a couple years together and prove he's the kind of WR that other teams fear. Yeah, I get that he had Kitna. Kitna had a better QB rating than Kyle Orton, Jay Cutler, Eli Manning, and more. Kitna did just fine.

[bingo911]

They rate players on how they preformed last year. THERE ARE NO VARIABLES, like having an injured Qb. If that was the case Larry Fitz would be 100 ovr, since he had like 4 different qbs last year.

[ANDROMADA 1]

Quote: Originally Posted by Broncos86

In that case, Brandon Lloyd should be #1, considering what he did last year and the numbers he put up. But I'm not advocating that, because one year does not make a player. He needs to put a couple years together and prove he's the kind of WR that other teams fear. Yeah, I get that he had Kitna. Kitna had a better QB rating than Kyle Orton, Jay Cutler, Eli Manning, and more. Kitna did just fine.

No. Kitna did NOT do fine. He along with the rest of the team were hot garbage last year.

[Broncos86]

Quote: Originally Posted by bingo911

They rate players on how they preformed last year. THERE ARE NO VARIABLES, like having an injured Qb. If that was the case Larry Fitz would be 100 ovr, since he had like 4 different qbs last year.

Eh, not quite. They don't just look at last year. Donny Moore takes more than that into the equation. Like I said, Brandon Lloyd would be a 99 otherwise. He's an 88, I believe. You don't suddenly proclaim a guy is amazing because he had one good year.

[TheKingOfVa]

Quote: Originally Posted by ANDROMADA 1

Calvin seems a little low in route running. Andre should be a 99. Roddy lost a step already??? M11 93 peed, M12 92 Fitzgerald should be bumped up to 99. 87 speed is laughable.

Andro you would say Andre should be a 99

Larry's speed should be at least a 90, he isn't that slow.

[TWOSILK]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheKingOfVa

Andro you would say Andre should be a 99 Larry's speed should be at least a 90, he isn't that slow.

LMAO!!!!!!! i missed that the first time I read that

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by ANDROMADA 1

One word. Kitna. Breaking 1,000 yards with all the team went through last year is in itself amazing. He will be right back to playing at an elite level with the return of Romo.

It's great you are saying that. But let's see it. He wouldn't be the first player who had one good year who Dallas fans hyped up as an elite player only to find out they simply weren't that good.

[angels eclipse7]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

So based on one season, he's a top 6 player? As far as Desean, he's the ultimate home run hitter. He's a TD waiting to happen, but he's not a Top 6 WR. He's never gonna be a volume catcher. Now if it was top 6 most explosive WR's or Top 6 fastest WR's he's at the top of the list. But top 6 overall WR's. Just not his game.

I love you for your posts in this thread. Completely agree.