MLB 11 The Show Rosters - Operation Sports Full Minors (Opening Day Set)

[BDKiiing]

Quote: Originally Posted by mpbaseball22

If Bryce came up and played in the MLB today hed get torched. Its just not normal for an 18 year old to be better than most guys in the league even if there named Bryce Harper

I really do not agree with this statement.

[rudywong]

I have downloaded the file on the first page for this roster update.How do I transfer the file from a usb to the ps3? When I hook up the usb to the ps3, it says no saved data.

[Jason_19]

Quote: Originally Posted by bdolski

I really do not agree with this statement.

Same here. Bryce's ability right now is far superior to the majority of major league players. Of course he would have to adjust, but his ability to do so is seemingly greater than anyone who has played the game in close to a half century.

Quote: Originally Posted by mpbaseball22

Its just not normal for an 18 year old to be better than most guys in the league

That's correct. A player like Harper only comes along every few decades, if that.

[mpbaseball22]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jason_19

Same here. Bryce's ability right now is far superior to the majority of major league players. Of course he would have to adjust, but his ability to do so is seemingly greater than anyone who has played the game in close to a half century. That's correct. A player like Harper only comes along every few decades, if that.

True he is excellent for an 18 year old.. but at the same time I like to keep my fantasy realistic and not have 18 year olds playing in the majors. I still think he should be just a little better than Mike Trout but good enough that he'll be the best in 2-3-4 years

[The Legend MM]

I've been looking thru the search and saw the threads about OSFM variations but I can't find the answer to this so if Knight or someone could help me out..

I was wondering what the best (or final) 40-man roster version of OSFM was. I know in the first few OSFM there were L/R issues and I know a bunch of people took Knights template and did stances etc.. but which was the most complete 40-man set of OSFM.

Thank you.

-Mitch

[hawks223]

Quote: Originally Posted by bdolski

I really do not agree with this statement.

I'm not even a Bryce Harper fan, but the kid is unreal. Sorry, but 18 year olds just don't hit .331 11hrs an drive in 36rbis in a month an a half without being legit.

[BDKiiing]

Quote: Originally Posted by hawks223

I'm not even a Bryce Harper fan, but the kid is unreal. Sorry, but 18 year olds just don't hit .331 11hrs an drive in 36rbis in a month an a half without being legit.

Exactly...I mean it's not like you can generalize him to an 18 year old, he is just that dang good, where his skill level IS better than a lot of major leaguers.

Quote: Originally Posted by mpbaseball22

True he is excellent for an 18 year old.. but at the same time I like to keep my fantasy realistic and not have 18 year olds playing in the majors. I still think he should be just a little better than Mike Trout but good enough that he'll be the best in 2-3-4 years

Im not sure how to put this in the nicest way, but you clearly know absolutely nothing about Bryce if that's what you think...Trout is great and all, but Bryce is miles ahead.

[mpbaseball22]

Quote: Originally Posted by bdolski

Exactly...I mean it's not like you can generalize him to an 18 year old, he is just that dang good, where his skill level IS better than a lot of major leaguers. Im not sure how to put this in the nicest way, but you clearly know absolutely nothing about Bryce if that's what you think...Trout is great and all, but Bryce is miles ahead.

Bryce is 18 playing in A ball. Hitting .346 thru 200 AB's with 13 HR. Thats great.

Mike Trout wasnt much off last year when he too was only 18. There is a pretty big difference between single A and AA. Im not saying Bryce sucks at all. But to have him step in as an 18 year old and perform better than half the league makes it unrealistic, and its off