NCAA Football 12 Blog - Coach Carousel

[fcboiler87]

Quote: Originally Posted by canes21

Okay, finally on my computer so I can type what I really want to say. So far what we have seen from EA's CC is that coaches have one dominant rating and that is it. That rating is prestige. What that affects is how much players progress under them, how well a team performs in simulated games, and one pitch in the recruiting phase. The thing is, we don't know how big of a difference players progress under an A+ coach and a C- coach. Do they always get at least 4 points improvement under the A+ coach or is there more of a possibility to see the "Max Improvement" that has been in the game for some time? Under the C- coach do they sometimes not progress, or only progress up to 3 points a year at the very best? We don't know how much impact they really have.

Instead of quoting your entire post, I'll only have part of it. But I'd like to say it was an excellent post as far as outlining what the CC should look like at some point. I don't know what to expect from the CC this year because like you mentioned, we don't know the details. It is the first year of it and as pointed out by others it took 2k a few years to get it right on college hoops. But I do wish there was more depth to the CC. I give EA plenty of credit and think it's an excellent start. But after this year I will expect it to be much more in depth, largely as described in your post. All in all, I'm looking forward to this game as even a base CC will provide significantly more depth than ever before.

[poopoop]

Quote: Originally Posted by ryanMcEZ

also, i read these forums EVERYDAY, never post, but i remember before any info about dynasty or even the game was out, evryone was saying, oh if there is no CC im not buying or it will be a great dissapointment now that we have the details about the CC and junk, everyone is b**ching anyways, it ridiculous, settle people, its a great addition

you're grouping two different sets of people together in order to point out a contradiction that isn't actually there.

Quote: Originally Posted by DR_Drake_Ramore

I guess it IS true. You can't fix stupid. ... I'm done with this thread. No no colonel Sanders Something's wrong with YOUR madula amblingata!

Sorry but I had to laugh at this.

[Da Hype Iz Real]

Anybody care to guess what happens when being a Coordinator and if you are watching the other side of the ball what sliders would be in effect User and CPU or CPU for both sides if sliders are even in effect at all.

[SlickRick11]

im so pumped about this game

[sparkdawg777]

Quote: Originally Posted by DR_Drake_Ramore

I guess it IS true. You can't fix stupid. Now your complaint is because they didn't give specifics on how much of a progression boost the coach has on the players, you're discounting that part of the CC feature alltogether, WTF. And because you THINK Coach prestige pitch was never high on recruits likes (which is flat wrong btw) you are discounting this part of the CC feature as well. And since you are so hard of hearing, let me reinterate that loyalty is the second pitch that CC has an effect on for recruiting. Maybe you should read your posts out loud to yourself before pressing the submit reply button. Here you are again discounting facts or minimizing them as if they don't matter to come up with your complaint. WEAK. I'm done with this thread. No no colonel Sanders Something's wrong with YOUR madula amblingata!

Ok have to admit that you are showing your immaturity right here. I didn't see one post where cane talked bad about you. He is just defending his thoughts on how CC should be. So there is no reason to get mad at him because you don't like his opinion.

Also to say that we can't compare CH2k8's CC to NCAA 12's just shows your ignorance of the CC in CH2k8. You kept saying how they shouldn't be compared because they are 2 different sports. Well if you have ever played the CC in CH2k8 you will see the coaches ratings are attributes like Scouting, Recruiting, Charisma, Offense, Defense, and a few others can't remember exactly but those can all be tied in to football. So the FACT is YOU are wrong.

On that note I still think CC will be fine but like some have said it could have been better and it WILL be. I'm still glad we have it over nothing at all.

[canes21]

Quote: Originally Posted by sparkdawg777

Ok have to admit that you are showing your immaturity right here. I didn't see one post where cane talked bad about you. He is just defending his thoughts on how CC should be. So there is no reason to get mad at him because you don't like his opinion. Also to say that we can't compare CH2k8's CC to NCAA 12's just shows your ignorance of the CC in CH2k8. You kept saying how they shouldn't be compared because they are 2 different sports. Well if you have ever played the CC in CH2k8 you will see the coaches ratings are attributes like Scouting, Recruiting, Charisma, Offense, Defense, and a few others can't remember exactly but those can all be tied in to football. So the FACT is YOU are wrong. On that note I still think CC will be fine but like some have said it could have been better and it WILL be. I'm still glad we have it over nothing at all.

Thanks for agreeing with me, but a few pages back we were told not to bring up 2k8 in this thread anymore. Just thought I would warn you.

[arobbi3]

Quote: Originally Posted by canes21

Okay, finally on my computer so I can type what I really want to say.

VERY nice post. NCAA with coaching carousel at that depth would be any dynasty player's dream. I see why you're frustrated with the CC implemented now. I am perfectly happy with what is in now, but if EA eventually had CC into that level....

Hopefully more details about the prestige rating's effect on players will come out Friday.

[PaperBoyx703]

How bout we let everyone have their opinions and assumptions. If people want to speculate and assume things based off selective viewing and hearing, let em. For those who want to turn a blind eye to facts already stated by impressions and the Devs themselves then let the game prove them wrong.

This isnt politics theres no need to debate this for this long, im pretty sure these trivial arguments, which are funny but get old quick, dont affect the games sales. I hope this is over because this indifference about CC has gone on too long.

Its in the game deal with it. The way it is is the way it is, take it or leave it. Its as simple as that