Yeah it was 05, and it was crazy fun haha. I loved Tony Bruno and that music that would come on. I mean, they even had players call in for interviews if they won an award, or their team made the playoffs, and other stuff!
Just note that was the last-gen days. They had to scrap everything "extra" basically for the next-gen Madden 06 because of lack of memory, and what did get in was watered down. Basically, Madden has been recovering for about 3 years - up until about 09. After that, mediocrity got unacceptable. But they did make strides consistently. Don't believe me? Check every review for next-gen for Madden, from Madden 06, up until Madden 11.