Major League Baseball 2K11 Mid-Review Update

[spit_bubble]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bumble14

...And yes, the Trop (and the Trop only) looks like a game of Bases Loaded from the default broadcast pitching department...

I just played my first game there, and I don't really understand what you are talking about. Do you mean just the camera angle or what? I myself didn't have any problem with it, and besides isn't it supposed to replicate the real life TV Broadcast for that stadium? Did they just get it wrong or something???

I don't know, just seems like a minute and relatively inconsequential thing to harp on.

[SoxFan01605]

Quote: Originally Posted by spit_bubble

I just played my first game there, and I don't really understand what you are talking about. Do you mean just the camera angle or what? I myself didn't have any problem with it, and besides isn't it supposed to replicate the real life TV Broadcast for that stadium? Did they just get it wrong or something??? I don't know, just seems like a minute and relatively inconsequential thing to harp on.

Yeah, pretty sure it's the camera angle. It's very similar.

I think that, because the Trop is so ugly by default and the view is so zoomed out and reminiscent of the view in bases loaded, it gives a bad impression when coupled with he game's hit and miss graphics.

I would agree that it is one of the ugliest looks (if not the ugliest) I've seen in the current crop of sports games, but I don't think it's a good idea for someone doing a review for OS (regardless of the stage) to be slinging around hyperbole like that. It's almost as if it's a concerted effort to tweak fans of the series...lol.

It's one thing for people in the forums to do it (I mean, what would a message board be without hyperbole...lol), but anything that is going to be a front page "article" should exercise a bit more reason IMO.

[swaldo]

Loving the defense so far. I was pitching against the CPU with a two run lead, one out with men on 1st & 3rd. Next batter grounds out to my shortstop towards 3rd base so he had to backhand it. I realized my only hope for a double play was to make two full-powered throws thus risking an error. No way! Instead I made medium powered, accurate throws sacrificing a run to keep their man on 1st base.

You always have to be on point and thinking - aware of each of your opponents batter & baserunner's speed, your fielders strengths & weaknesses etc. Whoever wins the millions bucks is going to have to put the best "D" possible on the field. Anyway, could it use some tweaking? Maybe, but it's so much better than what we've seen in past games so I hope they wont get slammed too hard on this area in the review.

[GrandMaster B]

I think the game looks great. I have "The Show" as well and there are a lot of jaggies in that game. The colors pop out more in 2K's game and the lighting and shadows I feel are better. The announcing for "The Show" is pretty bland. The scoreboards on "The Show" are fantastic though, but I think Sony's game took a step back and MLB took a step forward. Now if they could only fix the framerate outside the lines.

[TripleThreat1973]

I thought the ability to rent a video game made reviewers unnecessary?

The comments in the review read as being biased. To exaggerate so in a review is not very professional, and it makes the other comments hard to take seriously.

Now, if he had some something about the visuals, such as cletes and gloves that appear to made out of wax, or from 1922, that would be accurate.

So far, just a lot of blah blah.

How does it compare to 2k7/8/9?

Exaggeration and nit-picking is not reviewing.

[roadman]

As I said in the first impressions thread, it depends on your tolerance for graphics. I put up with a lot worse graphics on the PC with HH Baseball because it had great game play. It also had a ton of bugs, but it was the only baseball game I played.

This was a decade ago.

[spit_bubble]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

As I said in the first impressions thread, it depends on your tolerance for graphics...

I'm already starting to forget about the ugliness that exists in some of the player models, just because the game is getting better and better the more I play it. In fact this game is quickly rising up the list of my all time favorite baseball video games.

[DickDalewood]

Quote: Originally Posted by spit_bubble

I'm already starting to forget about the ugliness that exists in some of the player models, just because the game is getting better and better the more I play it. In fact this game is quickly rising up the list of my all time favorite baseball video games.

I'll probably finally pick this up today and have both games this year. I've read both good and bad, but I think my casual fandom will allow me to enjoy it... especially with how easily I can be won over by great presentation, lol. I'm excited though, it will be fun to own TWO good baseball games again.