MLB 11 The Show - Top Rated Teams, Hitter, Fielder, Pitcher, and Most Improved Player

[tommyjesus]

someone wanna tell me how the red sox pitching staff is better than the giants, especially if you count the bullpens?

i guess ratings don't matter that much in the long run, anyway, but i can't see it.

also, ubaldo is overrated. top 5, yes, but he needs to be bumped down a bit so he's below guys like halladay, lincecum, king felix, etc. instead of a few points above them.

[vln13]

Quote: Originally Posted by tommyjesus

someone wanna tell me how the red sox pitching staff is better than the giants, especially if you count the bullpens? i guess ratings don't matter that much in the long run, anyway, but i can't see it. also, ubaldo is overrated. top 5, yes, but he needs to be bumped down a bit so he's below guys like halladay, lincecum, king felix, etc. instead of a few points above them.

I agree, but I don't think that it matters that much.

[dude106]

I wonder where Josh Johnson is in the pitcher rankings. IMO, as a Marlins fan, he should probably be top-10 at least. I'm biased though.

[pittsburgher86]

I definitely don't like Ubaldo Jimenez being the Number 1 Pitcher in all baseball. Roy Halladay, Tim Lincecum, Felix Hernandez, Cliff Lee, Jon Lester, the list goes. Ubaldo is good but not that good. Yankees pitching is a joke too. This is just bad...

[Russell_SCEA]

The top 5 pitchers in the game have the same overall.

[Kearnzo]

Quote: Originally Posted by pittsburgher86

I definitely don't like Ubaldo Jimenez being the Number 1 Pitcher in all baseball. Roy Halladay, Tim Lincecum, Felix Hernandez, Cliff Lee, Jon Lester, the list goes. Ubaldo is good but not that good. Yankees pitching is a joke too. This is just bad...

Do we really have to go through this every year? If you don't like the ratings, then edit them.

We go through this supposed ratings "mess" every year too. By now i'd think people would remember that the top guys at each position usually have a maxed out overall, so whoever is rated at the top of the position may not technically be better overall than someone else with the same overall rating. They are just listed above them.

[tvman]

I'm thinking the reason Ubaldo is #1 has a lot to do with his stuff. Not sure if Scea factors in how a pitcher competes with runners in scoring position and such. That is what makes Halladay and Lincecum such great pitchers.

[Pistolero]

Good stuff there!