MLB 11 The Show - Top Rated Teams, Hitter, Fielder, Pitcher, and Most Improved Player

[etched Chaos]

Quote: Originally Posted by Shakedowncapo

Fellas, you have to remember the Phils have a very average bullpen. That might be factored into the overall.

Fair enough. But Ubaldo as the best pitcher, thats a joke. Even if we ignore Doc, you have Lincecum, Felix, Wainwright (pre-TJ), Cliff Lee, Jon Lester etc etc.

[vln13]

Quote: Originally Posted by Scott

Wow Yanks #1 offense? Definitely should be Red Sox, possibly even Rangers (but then again I'm biased.)

Don't worry, I think even Yankees fans agree with that

[HeyYoCraig]

I'm pretty surprised they chose jimenez as the best overall pitcher. There are probably at least 5 other pitchers who deserve this top spot. I don't really care though, I'm sure halladay, felix, etc are very close to jimenez in regards to player attributes

i can't wait for when they post the top 5 players at each position and show their attributes. I love that

[tvman]

Giants should be #1.... wait they are #1!!!!!!!!!!!

[Russell_SCEA]

The top 5 pitchers have identical overall ratings. Or they are separated by a single point. Ubaldo has better control ratings on his last three pitches than Doc, Feliz, and Timmy. That's why he's number one and its literally by a few points.

[Russell_SCEA]

The Phills have arguably the best 1-3 punch in baseball. But overall is overall doesn't mean your best 3 arms. It's the entire starting five, the entire bull pen and a closer.

[etched Chaos]

Quote: Originally Posted by Russell_SCEA

The top 5 pitchers have identical overall ratings. Or they are separated by a single point. Ubaldo has better control ratings on his last three pitches than Doc, Feliz, and Timmy. That's why he's number one and its literally by a few points.

Hmmmmm, still a bit puzzled how he has better control than Doc on any pitch. Doc had less walks than starts last year, thats is an incredibly rare feat and yet Ubaldo who had 62 more walks than Doc last year has better control on 3 pitches? I'd understand he has more velocity, but Doc is synonymous with pinpoint control. His K:BB ratio is always at the top.

[Giants4Natic]

Nice find. Screens look dope