The Top Five 8-Bit NES Baseball Games

[green94]

Quote: Originally Posted by Mr5000

Baseball Stars should have been number one. And that NES Baseball game shouldn't have been anywhere near this list.

Baseball Stars >>>>>>>> everything else.

And it's not even close - franchise mode was top notch and leveling up by beating the Lovely Ladies was simply awesome.

[GAMEC0CK2002]

Nice list. My 1a and 1b are Baseball Stars and Bases Loaded. Back in the day, I remember my cousin bragging about how good he was a Bases Loaded. I bet him a Willie Mays card (which I didn't have) against his Pete Rose card. Mopped the floor with him and kept the card. My dad asked was I going to give it back to him. Not a chance.

[ShaneFu]

I loved the bench clearing brawls on Bases Loaded...classic!

[ABR173rd]

Played RBI baseball so much I got blisters on both of my thumbs, amazing game, bases loaded was awesome to.

[DaReapa]

Baseball Stars and the Japanese team in the all-black uni's......classic. Bases Loaded gets the nod, too. And almost forgot, even though it had robots, BaseWars was a funfest in and of itself.

[PlottyDawg]

Having played all these games at one point or another, I would have rated them:

5) RBI Baseball
4) Baseball
3) Baseball Simulator 1.000
2) Baseball Stars
1) Bases Loaded...and that isn't even close. I always thought this was the most realistic baseball game for NES. And Paste on the Jersey team is the REAL Albert Pujols. .450 BA, 60 homerun power. Anything he touched flew out of the park. And his protector Bay wasn't too shabby, either.

[peter77733]

I never played RBI Baseball or Baseball Simulator 1000 (but I did play Super BB 1000 on SNES) so I wont comment on them but I prefer Bases Loaded the most with Baseball Stars second. Played Baseball and MLB but didnt care for either game. And the only reason why I prefer Bases Loaded over Baseball stars is because its more of a simulation where as Baseball Stars is more arcadish but both are classics.

[sroz39]

Quote: Originally Posted by PlottyDawg

Having played all these games at one point or another, I would have rated them: 5) RBI Baseball 4) Baseball 3) Baseball Simulator 1.000 2) Baseball Stars 1) Bases Loaded...and that isn't even close. I always thought this was the most realistic baseball game for NES. And Paste on the Jersey team is the REAL Albert Pujols. .450 BA, 60 homerun power. Anything he touched flew out of the park. And his protector Bay wasn't too shabby, either.

I remember Paste. My dad and I used that team in the Season Mode. My dad didn't play many video games but he was a crazy good pitcher in that game.

Personal list:

1) Baseball Stars 1&2
2) Bases Loaded 1&2
3) Roger Clemens Baseball

That's my personal list. I liked RBI but personally thought it to be over-rated as the years have gone on.