MLB 2K11 Player Ratings - Partial List (Pastapadre)

[tvman]

I don't understand all this online league stuff but are these guys somehow playing a beta 2k11 game?

[JayhawkerStL]

Quote: Originally Posted by tvman

I don't understand all this online league stuff but are these guys somehow playing a beta 2k11 game?

Yes. These are not released rosters and ratings. These are rosters found by someone not in the Beta (apparently), and leaked. Actually, it's probably a Beta guy releasing it to Julian Assange.

[Blazzen]

Tommy Hanson @ 87, tied with Tim Hudson, is overrated. Timmy probably deserves 88-90, and Tommy 85. Jair Jurrjens got snubbed a bit, he was hurt last year led to higher ERA. Think he deserves an 82.

Heyward @ 88 seems a bit overrated. 85ish imo. Martin Prado should've been higher. Chipper at 78 hurts, but its probably about right.

Overall the ratings were pretty good this year. The dynamic ratings will be really cool too. I'm actually excited for the game this year. I just hope they don't find a way to **** it up like they have the last few years.

[anchorsteamer]

What I didn't see listed anywhere was potential, which seems to factor a lot more in 2k11. It's possible, too, that with dynamic ratings, some of these players in franchise and during the regular season will achieve beyond their base rating, which I think accounts for some of the lows. For example, the Phil's rotation has high marks generally, but as we all saw in the NLCS, a hot hitter (Cody Ross) or hot staff (Giants) could still prevail.

[Wavebird99]

The ratings seem ok, but I dont like some of the Yankee ones:

Cano should be higher than a 90, and A-Rod should be lower than a 91. Cano is more of a 92-94 type guy to me.

AJ Burnett should be a little higher than 77, probably around like 79.

Joba shouldnt be higher than Robertson. Robertson should be closer to 80 like he was at one point last year.

Other than that the ratings seem ok. The Red Sox definitely look like the best team in the game. Tons of players rated 80+.

[Freak123]

Ratings seem to be really great this year, very accurate in my opinion. Only a few gripes, and these are all a matter of opinion so here's mine.

Zack Greinke should be upped from 91 to 94 or 95.

Cliff Lee should be about a 97, not a 95.

Roy Halladay should be a 99, best pitcher in baseball no doubt.

Jason Hayward should be an 84 or 85, not an 88.

Alex Rodriguez should be about an 85 or 86, not a 91.

Robinson Cano should be a 92 or 93, not a 90.

Johan Santana should be about an 86 or 87, not a 89.

I can go on but the ratings are pretty much accurate, and if they're off it's just by a couple ratings. Really looking forward to this year's game!

[gigadkc]

Mitre has a higher rating than Burnett? Seriously? That's straight up selfpwning.

[Wavebird99]

Quote: Originally Posted by gigadkc

Mitre has a higher rating than Burnett? Seriously? That's straight up selfpwning.

Yeah I actually just noticed that now.

Not a fan of some of the ratings for sure.