Dynasty Musings: The Show is Still King

[greenieblue]

I disagree. The show isn't even the franchise king in it's own sport-- MLB 2k10 is. To each his own, I guess.

[greenieblue]

2k(whatever it was this year), I mean.

[Rwings832]

Is this guy serious?

[EnigmaNemesis]

Quote: Originally Posted by Rwings832

Is this guy serious?

Nothing to see here. Look at the registration date. It will be picking up steam soon around here like that post. Just hit the triangular ! and move on!

[greenieblue]

Why is that opinion incredible? I can make an incredibly detailed argument supporting this opinion, but we both know that ends with you calling me names.
NCAA has a better franchise.
Madden has a better franchise.
MLB 2k has a better franchise.
And, finally, NBA 2k11 is probably three years ahead on their franchise.

[greenieblue]

A side note:
MLB 2k was severely underrated this year. I understand the love of the show. I think it's quite a good game. I preferred the show 09 to mlb 2k, but 2k won out for me this year. Gameplay-wise the king is up for debate-- either game makes a good case. Franchise-wise, 2k is better. Despite some pretty hideous flaws. The shows franchise is two years old, and two years ago it wasn't that impressive.

[Knight165]

Quote: Originally Posted by greenieblue

Why is that opinion incredible? I can make an incredibly detailed argument supporting this opinion, but we both know that ends with you calling me names. NCAA has a better franchise. Madden has a better franchise. MLB 2k has a better franchise. And, finally, NBA 2k11 is probably three years ahead on their franchise.

I should have stopped at NCAA has a better franchise....
I REALLY should have stopped at Madden has a better franchise
My wife had to finish typing this after I read that MLB2K(you know...the one you don't even know if it's '10 or '11) has a better franchise.
Either you haven't played any of those games for very long with their franchise modes...or you've never played the The Show at all.
Certainly The Show has it's warts in franchise mode...but it definitely trumps any of the one's you've listed.
NBA2K11 is nice....but still bested by the Show.

...and look...no name calling!

M.K.
Knight165

[greenieblue]

Hello Knight,

Two years ago there was a very vocal critic of the show with a sabermetric leaning. He was subsequently jettisoned from the community. He felt as though maybe he has made his point (i.e. that they devs had heard him) despite being obnoxious at times. Said critic decided to purchase the current iteration of the Show and discovered that no one had in fact heard a word he said and that, all the innumerable opponents of his opinion had, in fact encouraged SCEA to leave the exact same franchise in place.
I know this guy, and he doesn't care much about the war. He purchased and played the show, but did not enjoy playing a stale, limited franchise mode. Instead he chose MLB 2k for the first time in his life and enjoyed the realism and depth of the franchise (of course, he needed to overlook some serious errors) and gameplay.
As far as NBA 2k11 being bested, I think the world will have to wait at least a year for that to happen-- 2k12. Probably longer. It's not even close. I really can't say that enough.
Respect. Sorry if I'm as obnoxious as him.