Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Washington Redskins and Dallas Cowboys

[kcarr]

Quote: Originally Posted by DGuinta1

I think DWare should be rated highter then Jared Allen.

Comparing the overall rating of those 2 is like comparing apples and oranges. The overall ratings for defensive ends and for outside linebackers are developed using completely different formulas. If you were to move dware to DE or jared allen to OLB then ware probably would be equal or higher in terms of overall rating. This is a big problem with how madden rates players, every player is rated based ona prototypical version of what they think a player should be for a position rather than what they should do which is use head coaches positional philosophy system. Heck, even the original head coach had a better system in place than what madden currently uses as they had different ratings based on systems but there you couldn't choose the philosophy to customize your system.

[CaliDude916]

McNabb deserves better than an 89. He should be like a 91 or 92.

[gscherer21]

once again to clear things up, when the top quarterback ratings were leaked, mcnabb was still on the eagles. his rating was a 91 or something. and then his rating drops when he gets traded to washington. this happens all the time...

[endersdragon]

A couple Cowboys seem to be a bit underranked to me. First Sean Lee should be way higher then a 70. Is he an injury risk, yea. Is he a huge talent and great leader, yes. 70 seems a bit low for what he is, even with that injury risk.

All 3 potential left ends are a bit unrated. Spears may not be great, but he can stop the run quite well, even if he isn't that great at getting around the tackle, but then again, thats not how the Cowboys use him. Then Bowen and Hatcher should both be a bit higher ranked, even if they are largely unknown a lot of Cowboys fans see them challenging Spears this preseason.

Ball and Hamlin both in the 60s? Sorry but when Ball was playing last year, he did what he needed to do, that should at least land him in the mid 70s. Hamlin also looks quite good, though I will grant you he is an unknown.

Choice might be the only back in the league that can average more then 5 YPC and still not land in the 80s. It seems to me they almost rank the RBs based on how many carries they get not how they do with those carries.

Outside that pretty good .

[twitscape]

Quote: Originally Posted by SubZero97

Harrison plays the run better, and the SB sealed the deal for Harrison getting it. You did see the Super Bowl right? We had the better record, all those factors played into it. And we had the #1 Defense, that was smashin on fools.

The deal was sealed as far as the award going out before the SB, remember that right? Also note that defense struggles and sucks w/o troy polamalu. 20 sacks stoopid.