NCAA Football 11 Review

[HokieB]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bumble14

I did not review them for the site-but in retrospect: 07- 6.0 08- 7.5 09- 8.0 (once patched) 10- 6.0

Do you happen to have links to your previous reviews? I'd really like to read your review from last year.

Great review, btw.

[Bumble14]

Quote: Originally Posted by HokieB

Do you happen to have links to your previous reviews? I'd really like to read your review from last year. Great review, btw.

Didn't review them my man. All my previous non NCAA reviews and articles can be found on the staff info page.

[HokieB]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bumble14

Didn't review them my man. All my previous non NCAA reviews and articles can be found on the staff info page.

Oh, my bad.

According to the reviews page, OS scored NCAA 10 an 8.0, and NCAA 09 an 8.5. What review gave NCAA 10 a 6.0? I'd like to read that.

EDIT: Nevermind, I figured out what you were saying

[Bumble14]

Quote: Originally Posted by HokieB

Oh, my bad. According to the reviews page, OS scored NCAA 10 an 8.0, and NCAA 09 an 8.5. What review gave NCAA 10 a 6.0? I'd like to read that. EDIT: Nevermind, I figured out what you were saying

Different guys at OS reviewed past versions. If you read the series of posts you will see that someone asked what I would have scored those past NCAA games. Those were the scores I would have given. There are no formal reviews by me w these scores.

[exboxfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by Crimsontide27

This is the reason why I never take game reviewers seriously. If you go back and look at the previous reviews of " insert sports titles here", they all follow the same train of thought. 08 "Well last year it wasnt good, but this year its amazing" 09 "Last year wasnt a good year, but this year NCAA regains its glory" 10 "NCAA last year wasnt a polished title, but never fear...this year its returning to glory" 11 "NCAA has been terrible this generation, but thats all changed this year!! " Same song and dance every year. Early reviews and people that get the game early proclaim it to be the greatest version ever, and by 3AM after the midnight launches people will be talking patches.

Gotta say I agree. Always hope that they have got it right every year.

End up feeling I blew the money.

Oh well gotta try it anyway.

[PVarck31]

I am sure there will be issues that pop up. But I think the core gameplay is finally where it should be. Or should have been years ago. But, its there now so no use looking back IMO.

[MastaJedi1]

"This is the best football game of this generation, college or otherwise." Okay, I've got a few vacation days left, so I will put this puppy to the test...Cool!

[Guffers]

Fantastic review, a really great read. I ordered my copy yesterday from Play Asia with express shipping but like last year I expect to be waiting a couple of weeks. Enjoy it guys, I'm sitting enviously on the side lines waiting to get into the action! Sometimes it sucks living down here at the bottom of the world.