Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

[steelers1]

Quote: Originally Posted by Eman5805

Nothing against Johnson, btw. Just a lil miffed how he gets so much praise and Colston gets overlooked by almost everyone but people in Saints Nation, opposing defensive coordinators, and John Gruden.

Colston is a great WR, but to get the recognition as one of the top 10/elite WRs, he's going to have to put up more catches and yards. It doesn't matter if the Saints and Brees like to spread the ball around, the perception of an elite WR is a guy who gets lots of catches and yards.

Using your 'proportional' logic, Colston wouldn't even be the best receiver on the Saints: Meachem would be.

Meachem: 61 targets, 45 catches (73.8%) 725 yards (16.1 YPC) 9 TDs.

[buzzguy]

Interesting how no safeties are over 97.

[foocards88]

No love for Newman or Jenkins at CB?

[Dabeeds]

I would take the Jets cb over the raiders one.

But as far as the maddens player ratings go, come on, they've always been a load of bs.

According to them, Urlacher is amazing !! What a joke.

[wemacener]

hahaha this is bs d. jackson...DESEAN JACKSON are you kidding me? Desean Jackson is not better than the only Jackson who should really be up there VINCENT JACKSON. EA are you trying to say Desean Jackson is better? Sure hes fast but Vincent is better he should be the only Jackson who is rated that high. Please fix this.

[postochr]

OH YEAH BABY!...Cincinnati's finally getting some love. My favorite defensive player in the league Rey Maualuga and the (if not first) second best Cornerback tandem in Jonathan Joseph and Leon Hall 93 and 92 respectively.

[JMD]

We Chiefs fans have a special place in our hearts for Carl Peterson, thanks so much for letting J.Allen and T. Gonzalez go.

[Cowboys-SB-Champ-'10]

Quote: Originally Posted by G-Men_in_Mass

D.Williams is not evevn the best RB in Carolina!

Have you not watched Carolina play? Go watch the highlights again, DeAngelo Williams is the best back in Carolina, hands down