MLB '10 The Show Rosters: OS Full Minors v4 (Opening Day Only)

[RAZRr1275]

Quote: Originally Posted by ThirdDegree5803

I got R.A. Dickey's stamina at least up to 68 but we'll go w/ 65...sorry I missed changing him fellas I guess the brain got a little fried there late...I also noticed that Daniel Cabrera's stamina w/ BAL was a little low...I'd have it at least at a 54 but idk...are there anymore catchers that need their blocking adjusted? you said Castro's needs to be a 70 Ja?

You can go 68 if you want too. Leave Cabrera as he is. He'll get changed when you guys do the full overhaul

Quote: Originally Posted by Dean3790

I am doing some more testing and figured I'd report it. Yovani Gallardo averages 110.38 pitches per start. In the game, his energy bar empties at 105. This isn't necessarily that bad. But should he have no energy left at the end of every start? Will he recover in time for the next start? I am doing these in exhibition mode so I don't know. I feel like a guy who averages 110 pitches should not be depleted entirely of energy until about 120 or 125 pitches.

Durability is the recovery rating not stamina

[RAZRr1275]

Quote: Originally Posted by abcabc

he does... Pitchtype1 is a sinker... 2, slurve, 3 splitter, 4 curveball, none for 5.

Oh okay that's right then. He must have meant 4sfb or 2sfb

[Bondsfan]

I didn't play with V3, so I'm making the jump from V2 to V4. My first impression when looking over the rosters is that I love the hitting ratings. My second impression was holy crap, the pitchers pitches have really been changed around. I don't think anyone throws a 4-seam FB anymore. Barry Zito now has 2 curve balls. The pitch selection seems kind of nuts to me. No doubt whoever did them did their research though, its just radically different than what I'm used to.

[slim420]

Quote: Originally Posted by RAZRr1275

Oh okay that's right then. He must have meant 4sfb or 2sfb

shouldnt he have a 4SFB or 2SFB?
I know he throws sinkers with splitters here and there, but does he really throw slurves or CBs?

[abcabc]

bondsfan, if you played last yr w/ these edited rosters it sounds like you didnt... it does change radically... as of v3 for this yr, all the pitch edits set for real life pitch movement, so the straight 4seamer is pretty much nonexistent in real life mlb, so it's near extinct as of v3, and carryover into v4 of course.

[RAZRr1275]

Quote: Originally Posted by slim420

shouldnt he have a 4SFB or 2SFB? I know he throws sinkers with splitters here and there, but does he really throw slurves or CBs?

Nope. Pelfrey uses almost exclusively a sinker and he has a slider/curve hybrid pitch hence the slurve.

Quote: Originally Posted by Bondsfan

I didn't play with V3, so I'm making the jump from V2 to V4. My first impression when looking over the rosters is that I love the hitting ratings. My second impression was holy crap, the pitchers pitches have really been changed around. I don't think anyone throws a 4-seam FB anymore. Barry Zito now has 2 curve balls. The pitch selection seems kind of nuts to me. No doubt whoever did them did their research though, its just radically different than what I'm used to.

Yeah it's supposed to be a massive change but you'll also notice a difference in gameplay as with the edits you will see that it's harder to control pitches and at the same time slightly easier to get ks and is also harder to hit.

[Bondsfan]

Yep, this is my first year with a PS3, so first year with the rosters.

The odd thing is, if noone in the MLB actually throws a 4seam FB, why the heck to SCEA give that pitch as the primary pitch to every single pitcher in the game? I just don't understand why the don't include accurate pitches in the official rosters.

[Dean3790]

If v4.1 is just fixing stamina, do we really need it? Can we just up the starter stamina slider?