Madden NFL 11 Video: Jets vs. Patriots (OS @ E3)

[convince]

Quote: Originally Posted by daley7199

You guys complain about Maddens commentary. Tiger Woods has got to be the most lifeless, boring, repetitive, uninspired commentary of any game ever made.

Its clear you don't watch golf. That's is exactly what golf commentary is...boring. So comparing the two is crazy.

Quote: Originally Posted by daley7199

Hey I don't necessarily blame you for giving up on madden. There hasn't been alot of whole sale changes in the game. Basically just a new paint job each year and thats it; But I hope you don't plan on buying NBA2k11 b/c if that were the case you would then be a hypocrite since 2k has been releasing the same basketball game since 2k7.

That is horrible logic. If game "A" has gameplay problems that are never address year in and year, yet the release the same game. You can't compare that to game "B" that has good/great gameplay with a few bugs and keeps that same gameplay yearly.

[oneamongthefence]

If they fixed the flaws of last year and sold it to me this year i would buy it for 60 bucks. i just wish i didn't have to wait for patches to get a finished game.

[Mr_Riddick]

Originally Posted by: daley7199: Hey I don't necessarily blame you for giving up on madden. There hasn't been alot of whole sale changes in the game. Basically just a new paint job each year and thats it; But I hope you don't plan on buying NBA2k11 b/c if that were the case you would then be a hypocrite since 2k has been releasing the same basketball game since 2k7.
Womlee23: If you follow 2k basketball since 07, In my opinion, little has changed because little change was needed as far as gameplay. To me madden has been unplayable since I saw gameplay from apf/2k. So you really can't put madden in the same sentence as nba2k.

[DavonBrown]

Quote: Originally Posted by daley7199

Hey I don't necessarily blame you for giving up on madden. There hasn't been alot of whole sale changes in the game. Basically just a new paint job each year and thats it; But I hope you don't plan on buying NBA2k11 b/c if that were the case you would then be a hypocrite since 2k has been releasing the same basketball game since 2k7.

Terrible logic and false statement! NBA 2K has had 3 great games this generation. Madden, ZERO! NBA 2K9 was not very good. NBA 2K11 is looking very promising because they have Mike Wang(leader of the 2K7 and 2K8 team) back. He is what everyone thought Ian Cummings would be. He knows the sport and he listens to the fans.

[Skyboxer]

Quote: Originally Posted by convince

Its clear you don't watch golf. That's is exactly what golf commentary is...boring. So comparing the two is crazy.

Actually the commentary in golf is usually very informative and at times pretty funny, if you know the sport that is.

[convince]

I never said is wasn't informative, I just said it was boring. Someone speaking in monotone can be quite informative but yet that person would still be boring. And my point was more based on commentary of football vs. golf. So your point is.....shall I say "pointless".

[convince]

Oh and by the way, very few people would call golf commentary funny. I'm not saying it never is but its rare. But again no comparison to other sports.