Madden NFL 11 Rookie Ratings

[cdk10]

Thanks for the breakdown Palo, but I mean full descriptions of all ratings.

On a side note (sorry to keep harping and call me a homer if you will), but how in the world do the 5 1st round CBs in this years draft have a higher tackle rating than arguably the top S prospect??? I think Donny has a hell of a job rating all these players but come on.....really?

[Palo20]

Quote: Originally Posted by cdk10

Thanks for the breakdown Palo, but I mean full descriptions of all ratings. On a side note (sorry to keep harping and call me a homer if you will), but how in the world do the 5 1st round CBs in this years draft have a higher tackle rating than arguably the top S prospect??? I think Donny has a hell of a job rating all these players but come on.....really?

I hear ya, I want a good explanation on all the ratings too.

No homerism, Berry was basically an extra linebacker for the Vols last year, he can tackle.

[ImReady77]

Some of these players strength rating is too high especially those WR's.

[kcarr]

Quote: Originally Posted by ImReady77

Some of these players strength rating is too high especially those WR's.

If madden would do the right thing and actually use their entire scale then I would agree with you. However, they basically have 2 very strong WRs rated about halfway up the scale considering the lowest they really have anyone is around 50. I would not say that is that crazy considering who those 2 receivers are and the fact that they probably should be at the top end of wideouts. They have dez at a 66 less than a 3rd of the way up the chart. If they were actually going off of a 100 point scale this would be the same as rating thomas and benn around a 50 and dez around a 30. One thing I really hope they allow is player editing ratings within a franchise so I can actually run a franchise with spread out ratings.

[kcarr]

so much for the thought that claussen might be the first player whose fan average rating may be lower than donny's. he is currently +2

[Palo20]

Why does Taylor Mays have 95 speed? He ran a low 4.4. That 4.2 unofficial stuff was just that, unofficial.

Shouldn't 95 be the special speed guys?

[I Peench]

Gerhart 85 speed? Please, Donny...thats a jok. 88-90 for sure

[Reggie16]

idk if i like this thing it seems like everyone is just boosting players attributes