MLB '10: The Show - Top 5 Right Fielders

[ATLNYankee]

Quote: Originally Posted by JermaineDye05

Idk if this adds to a players rating but one thing that could be benefiting Cruz is the fact that he was an allstar last year so that could boost his game rating. Also, Swish's rating probably wasn't too respectable last year considering his .219 BA the year before. I'd say both factored ultimately in the decision for this rating.

And Nelson Cruz was a part time scrub in 2006 and 2007 while hitting .230 combined. They cant put a 1 year player into the top 5 over someone like Nick Markakis. Just cant do it.

[JermaineDye05]

Quote: Originally Posted by econoodle

I was wonderin Dye, willl u be signing Jermaine in your franny? or will u let his FA flag fly?

The latter.

I'm not big in Franchise. I may get into it, but if I do I'll probably just stick with the current White Sox roster and do what I usually do which is find a way to assemble the greatest pitching staff known to mankind. The funny thing is that the first move I always make is trade for Jake Peavy, looks like I won't need to be doing that this year

[JoeCoolMan24]

So let me get this straight.....

Josh Hamilton has a great 2008, and an awful injury ridden 2009. Get's rated the 2nd best LF.

Carlos Quentin has a great 2008, and a decent injury ridden 2009. Not even in the top 9 for RF.


So, no Beckham, and no Quentin? And Dye is even rated higher than Quentin?

Looks like I am going to have to edit some stuff......

PS: Nick Markakis not being at least top 5 is a crime.

[aces01]

Not a bad list IMO. I think Phillies fans will be disappointed with Werth's stance though, it's pretty far off. His hands are more like Rowand's hands now.

[denniscvd]

It is a descent list but what the is Magglio doing up there!!??! He belong in top 10 but not so high

[econoodle]

Quote: Originally Posted by JermaineDye05

The latter. I'm not big in Franchise. I may get into it, but if I do I'll probably just stick with the current White Sox roster and do what I usually do which is find a way to assemble the greatest pitching staff known to mankind. The funny thing is that the first move I always make is trade for Jake Peavy, looks like I won't need to be doing that this year

Sounds good.

[MukaMuka]

Looks like the same old outdated stance for Ichiro....

Will we EVER have an accurate, up-to-date batting stance for Ichiro??

[tazbk]

Quote: Originally Posted by jcabler24

I thought Justin Upton was faster than that?

Yeah so did I. And according to him (he stated on MLB Network), he can beat B.J. in a footrace. I dont know how true that is, but he is indeed faster than 76 I believe. I would have given him low 80's