NCAA Basketball 10 Demo Available Now, Post Your Impressions (PS3/360)

[Flightwhite24]

Quote: Originally Posted by Playmakers

That's the problem in college there way more teams and players to edit. I did all that stuff in March Madness 08 ended up with a sick roster file people were using but in the end EA should be doing this crap not us anymore. I had to spend nearly two months seperating player skills and things to get them to have different skill sets offensively and defensively. I had to manually edit the ratings to seperate All-American(s) from scrubs, lock down defenders from average defenders, atheletic bigs from stiffs/high risers from avg dunkers, 3-PT bombers from avg jump shooters. All that shiiit should be scouted by EA not us anymore and yet they still release a game that feels like every single player has the same duplicate ratings accross the country again. That's the reason why i didn't bother with 09 and the reason why NCAA 10 will be just another game I pass on again.

I really wanted this game but I figured the ratings and the teams/players would need hours upon hours of changes to get it to even resemble the game. Gonna pass I'm sad to say. Countryboy make sure you gives us your thoughts.

[ezio]

Quote: Originally Posted by JkA3

Wow, the game is ok. But in comparison to Live, this game is weak. The player movement is not good at all. In detail, it feels like your gluiding, rather than moving with momentum. Now I say that this is weak compared to Live. But compared to 2k10, this game is not even a factor. Compared to 2k, put it in the same catagory as NBA the Inside and NBA Unrivaled. Ok- of course that's over-stating but you get the point. From the demo, I can be certain that sales will be low. Not hating...just saying.

that is the way I felt too. I am bigger college fan and was looking forward to it but so far I think I will just stick with NBA live for my B-Ball fix. I am going to play the demo a bit more to see if that changes but right now I don't think I will be getting it.

[countryboy]

LOL...in all the times I've played the demo, I just found out that you can manually attempted to bank shots in.

[stevedrumsdw]

Quote: Originally Posted by Playmakers

Yes the game can most likley be edited to improve several aspects of game play but unlike in NBA Live where your dealing with just 30 teams in College your dealing with 100's of teams and a sick of amount of players to research and edit to get them right. If you understand EA's basketball engine and how their ratings work for this game you could tweak it to be somewhat improved from the base version whwn it releases but i'm upset they can't figure this stuff out themselves and don't plan on doing it anymore when i can just enjoy other sports games with better game play after all the edits.

I just don't understand why EA does not just look at ppg/rebound stats and just base ratings off of that, how hard is that? Instead the whole game is filled with generic players save a few of the big school's stars.

[blackngoldfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by countryboy

LOL...in all the times I've played the demo, I just found out that you can manually attempted to bank shots in.

I attempted a few bank shots in the pregame shoot around, but it was very inconsistent. Is it like NBA Live where you have to move the LS in any direction while shooting the ball?

[stevedrumsdw]

Quote: Originally Posted by blackngoldfan

I attempted a few bank shots in the pregame shoot around, but it was very inconsistent. Is it like NBA Live where you have to move the LS in any direction while shooting the ball?

What do we hit for banks shots?

[shindiana]

Even if users make roster to differentiate players's skillset we would still have this problem with incoming freshmen class in Dynasty mode.

[stevedrumsdw]

Quote: Originally Posted by shindiana

Even if users make roster to differentiate players's skillset we would still have this problem with incoming freshmen class in Dynasty mode.

This game last year was a mess with dynasty progression, recruiting, and base rosters. I am waiting to find out how this is improved. I spent hours tying to adjust the rosters last year in my dynasty, not going through that again. I recall one incident in which I recruited the number one player in the country, and Maryland Baltimore county had a junior on their roster that had higher ratings in almost every category, that was the last time I played the game.