Madden NFL 10 Review

[stlstudios189]

only 16 hours to go for kickoff baby!!!!

[Da_Czar]

Nice Review Big Steve !

[Manbearpig]

Quote: Originally Posted by Exonerated

If this game's a 9. NFL 2k5 is an 8. . . .

agreed, or even a 7

[rudyjuly2]

Here's a second link for the guys at work that can't read the main link at osatwork: http://www.osatwork.com/review.php?id=495

Edit: Very nice review Steve! I haven't played the retail version yet although I know I won't be playing on the slow setting. Just too slow for me when playing the demo.

[ANDROMADA 1]

This game is Easily a 9 if your into scores...For me its off the charts in the "fun" dept.I recommend this Madden to "any" fan of Football.Great job.I been playin it till my thumbs bleed...lol

[mauro78]

Quote: Originally Posted by Exonerated

If this game's a 9. NFL 2k5 is an 8. . . .

I wish that someone argumentate about why Madden deserves a 9; I think that OS review is great becouse He highlight weakness of the game; from that POV the review is great as usual. What really bothers me is the score 9. I mean after reading the review I was expecting a 8.1 - 8.5 score, becouse there are no excuse about some lazyness of EA. 9 is for great games and M10 is not.
It's fun? Maybe....

IMHO EA just put crap games on the market and the worst part is that their producer (and some part of the community) are hyped (reading their blog on twitter) by those review rates. Are we seriuous?

http://www.gametrailers.com/user-mov...st-part/100198

I just wish that EA/NFL let 2K develop their own game so we can have an alternate take on football gaming.
Now EA think that they passed NFL 2k5??? So let them develop NFL 2k11 and we'll have a decent competitor...Oh I guess I know who'll be the winner ^_^

Regards

Quote: Originally Posted by Millennium

Could just be me, but I think some people are WAY too hung up on the score, and didn't read the review. READ first, then look at the score.

Exactly.

Although I'd go so far as to say people are too hung up on REVIEWS, period.

Either way, this one was very well written and very fair. So good job to Steve!

[Smokez4DAyz]

Every year more people critique madden nfl. A lot of people want a lot of different improvments. Because of this, many downgrade or overlook what has been improved. The 9 grade is not for perfection, its for improvments. The online franchise, signature qb throws, real line play, slower gameplay, better animation. I agree with 9 score. Another 300 games to play this year.