NCAA Football 10 Review

[cepwin]

I wasn't as bothered by the presentation as was Chris. However, I thought it was an excellent and balanced review. Chris obviously put in a fair amount of time looking at all the features and evaluating them. I agree that the gameplay is improved from 09 and I personally thought the animations were as well. I like the new strategy selection although I have to learn more about it. Thanks again Chris for your review!

[RamzaLugria]

Nice Review. I'm still on the fence about this game.
I'm getting the feeling NCAA could use an overhaul, like NHL and FIFA have done in recent years.

[boydra]

I agree with the reviewer but the score is too generous. The game is still too much the same with the presentation and commentary growing stale after several years. I would have given it a score of 7.0. Very disappointing. I sure hope Madden gives us a much more exciting realistic game.

[JAYMO76]

Quote: Originally Posted by fistofrage

Thats MMChris's logic though. He stated that he took last years score into consideration. And because I believe that OS inflated scores in the past, he had to give it a good score because its marginally better than 2009. Had they rated 2008 4.5 and 2009 a 5 like it deserved, they would have had the ability to rate this a 6 or 6.5 where it belongs. So unless this series gets worse and lord we all hope it doesn't, it will have at minimum an 8 going forward based on the stated criteria.

Faulty logic... when a game only makes marginal gains over a four year period at some point the numbers have to come down. You can only play the same game so many times before the appeal is lost.

[tbach]

Good review, but I don't feel that your ratings matched the review well enough. should be lower IMO.

[True Blue Titan]

Best Gameplay of this gen? thats scary

[wisecav]

Quote: Originally Posted by True Blue Titan

Best Gameplay of this gen? thats scary

It's the best college football game out right now.

[$NevaBroke$]

Not the best, but is the only college football out to date. It's almost like the developers who make this game don't test the game and have meetings on the pros and cons before releasing it. Too much patching and promises of what we should get out of a $60 game out the box. This is the first year I am actually looking forward to Madden release.