Madden NFL 10: All Player Ratings Revealed (Pasta Padre)

[CKW11]

Quote: Originally Posted by Skyboxer

With the revamped ratings system and having players more spread out, I think it will be great. I'm just taking it for what it is. . I'm thinking it's going to allow for true subbing for specific situations. If they are in fact spread out ,each player regardless of overall will have their own areas of strengths. So possibly instead of always just making sure your hightest rated overall player is in the game, you'll have to dig a little deeper. So there may be times you actually have a player rated a little lower overall that simply fits the situation (or team philosophy) better.. That's how how looking at it anyways.. Hope I'm right.

I hope you're right too, that would add alot more strategy to the game which would be great imo.

And i think everyone is focusing too much on the actual number ratings. I cant sit here and criticize the ratings because i dont know how they actually play. Just my 2 cents.

[18manning18]

Quote: Originally Posted by tooldude79

i mustve mixed 07(16) and 08(13)..either way..compare the ratings of the Olines..its not funny how they messed over 1 of the 3 most prolific passing offenses in the NFL now, if you can just explain to me how a 4th rnd rookie LBer has a higher speed rating than every corner( at least 1 of whom ran 4.3) on the roster, and a receiver known for his speed(also 4.3 guy) how is this possible?? and how/why the heck are people defending this nonsene.??? and understand, this is just my team ive looked at .. its probably messed up across the board

Not sure if anybody mentioned this but they did say before that speed is all relative. Pat white at 87 speed i believe it was is going to be slower than a corner who has 87 speed. It's done differently by positions, from what i understand. Some confirmation from Ian would be nice but i swear i've heard them say this. And it would make sense because for example:
Vince young 85 speed, 4.58 40 yard dash http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn_Fu...eature=related

Jared Cook 85 speed 4.5 40 yard dash
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=saxhQG9Smhk

Nick "Why did you cut back" Harper 80 speed 4.58 dash time
LOL damn nick harper doesn't really have any highlights but i'm sure you all remember him in the colts steelers playoff game.

[tooldude79]

Quote: Originally Posted by 18manning18

Not sure if anybody mentioned this but they did say before that speed is all relative. Pat white at 87 speed i believe it was is going to be slower than a corner who has 87 speed. It's done differently by positions, from what i understand. Some confirmation from Ian would be nice but i swear i've heard them say this. And it would make sense because for example: Vince young 85 speed, 4.58 40 yard dash http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn_Fu...eature=related Jared Cook 85 speed 4.5 40 yard dash http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=saxhQG9Smhk Nick "Why did you cut back" Harper 80 speed 4.58 dash time LOL damn nick harper doesn't really have any highlights but i'm sure you all remember him in the colts steelers playoff game.

if youre correct about them being relative to the position then "thank God." i havent heard this, but hope youre right

[DallasAllDay]

I knew comming in to this season that the Cowboys WR's were gonna get no love but geez Patrick Crayton is rated a 73 and Steve Smith of the Giants is Rated a 76.

Steve Smith = 57 reception 574yrd = 10.1 a catch
Patrick Crayton 39 reception 550yrd = 14.1

Not to mention that crayton has put up these kinds of numbers for the past 3 years and this is past year that steve smith has ever done anything.

Ian tell me you will fix this. i dont care if crayton goes up or Smith comes down but this is just wrong.

[cowboyscowboys]

Quote: Originally Posted by DallasAllDay

I knew comming in to this season that the Cowboys WR's were gonna get no love but geez Patrick Crayton is rated a 73 and Steve Smith of the Giants is Rated a 76. Steve Smith = 57 reception 574yrd = 10.1 a catch Patrick Crayton 39 reception 550yrd = 14.1 Not to mention that crayton has put up these kinds of numbers for the past 3 years and this is past year that steve smith has ever done anything. Ian tell me you will fix this. i dont care if crayton goes up or Smith comes down but this is just wrong.

Crayton is slightly underrated rated but he is a punk and I could care less lol. Don't lower Smith this isn't a competition it's about giving players the ratings they deserve. Smith is a 76 IMO.

For Giants fans I haven't heard anybody say anything about Dominique Hixon I mean he is pretty fast and was pretty solid last year, he is only a 70 I think his rating should be higher.

[paytonfan28]

I was thinking the same thing earlier as the post a couple before this when i was looking at the ratings across the board... there has to be some kind of position specific rate. i haven't heard it, but it's the only thing that makes sence when about 70-80% more of the speed corners are faster than the speed receivers in this years game

[DallasAllDay]

Quote: Originally Posted by cowboyscowboys

Crayton is slightly underrated rated but he is a punk and I could care less lol. Don't lower Smith this isn't a competition it's about giving players the ratings they deserve. Smith is a 76 IMO. For Giants fans I haven't heard anybody say anything about Dominique Hixon I mean he is pretty fast and was pretty solid last year, he is only a 70 I think his rating should be higher.

Thats my point how are they comming up with these rating if not by the preformance throught the season all three of these players should be rated pretty much the same, but yet there is quite a bit of difference between there ratings.

I'm shouldn't the guys that have been in the league and produced consistantly for a few years be rated higher initially then a guy that come out put up similar numbers but for only one year.

[statpacker8351]

fo the cards i wonder why wilrey fontenot(a guy who probably wont make the team) is higher than greg toler(who some call the next DRC) and ralph brown who played great down the stretch.

and Leinarts rating just makes me sick. If he started he would be in the 80s.

I also think jerheme urban and early doucet should be a little higher as well. doucet was hurt all year and looks to have excellent potential.