NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

[coogrfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by ActLikeYouCrow

one of the videos posted has miami with a rt #65, but there's no such player on the tb site and they also dont even have a rt1 on the site, just a rt2. looks to me like there were going to be bugs anyway from tb vs the disc.

Umm...what?

[IvyLeagueQB]

Besides graduated players, transferred players, dismissed players, and lack of freshman has anybody seen very unusual ratings?

I don't mean the trivial my 78 ovr SS should be a 88, or this speed should be 97 not 92. Like having a 40 or 50 something overall player on the roster.

I haven't heard NCAA is using the new madden rating system so I was shocked when Notre Dame had like a 43 ovr rated DE. Anybody else seeing crap like that?

[tswiatkowski]

well idk if you consider this to be trivial, but Michigan States roster is badly messed up. Especially on defense. Greg Jones, the MLB, is ranked as one of the top ten Big Ten players, and is a 78 overall. Eric Gordon, who is considered to be almost as good, is a 72. Not one of the cornerbacks, who played well last season, are rated above a 75. The starting safeties are both under 65.

[stevedrumsdw]

Quote: Originally Posted by tswiatkowski

well idk if you consider this to be trivial, but Michigan States roster is badly messed up. Especially on defense. Greg Jones, the MLB, is ranked as one of the top ten Big Ten players, and is a 78 overall. Eric Gordon, who is considered to be almost as good, is a 72. Not one of the cornerbacks, who played well last season, are rated above a 75. The starting safeties are both under 65.

The ratings throughout many of rosters apperar to have been designed with no thought or semblance what so ever.

[ActLikeYouCrow]

my bad, one rt wont show up from the view all screen but it does if you go to offense or click on offense/rt.

[prowler]

Quote: Originally Posted by stevedrumsdw

The ratings throughout many of rosters apperar to have been designed with no thought or semblance what so ever.

That being the case, EA should just rename all the incomplete rosters into templates and add the completed rosters to the game and run with two sets of rosters. That's basically what they did anyway to a lesser extent, the Option Attack roster is the Georgia Tech roster.

Incomplete USC, Texas, Florida, Oklahoma, etc would be Powerhouse 2, Powerhouse 3, Powerhouse 4, etc.

Incomplete Texas Tech would be Spread Offense 2

Incomplete Washington State, Idaho, etc would be Cupcake 2, Cupcake 3, etc.

This way everybody wins, the diehard crowd gets the real rosters and EA doesn't piss off the TB crowd by deleting thousands of teams.

[BBkobe87]

Quote: Originally Posted by tswiatkowski

well idk if you consider this to be trivial, but Michigan States roster is badly messed up. Especially on defense. Greg Jones, the MLB, is ranked as one of the top ten Big Ten players, and is a 78 overall. Eric Gordon, who is considered to be almost as good, is a 72. Not one of the cornerbacks, who played well last season, are rated above a 75. The starting safeties are both under 65.

THANK YOU. Mich st has to have the worst rated defense on this game compared to what they should be in real life. Really got the shaft if these rosters are not fixed. Half of the MAC teams will be better to use online!!

[Herky]

Please read EA. These are not all hardcore gamers even.

http://iowa.rivals.com/showmsg.asp?f...id=940&style=2

http://mbd.scout.com/mb.aspx?s=8&f=1376&t=4392083&p=1