NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

[FSU93]

Quote: Originally Posted by GigemAGGIES13

It's not surprising when you acknowledge the corporate implications. Even if it is broken, it will be published, even if Tiburon are opposed to that decision. This might have been a mishap by the developers and testers, but they have no authority over the decision to delay the game for qualities sake. All that business comes from the top.

Broken? Inaccurate maybe, but not broken. Broken means that the game doesn't work. I'm just surprised they haven't gone the "they aren't real players" route/cop-out.

[ebarws6]

You know, even with all this uproar and call for the sacking of every single person associated with '10, I will give some credit to the team if they manage to find a good solution. Yes, there still is a long way to go, but if they manage to get out of this mess then I will give them some respect.

[tyler289]

I'm amazed at how it seems like every next-gen NCAA game has had some roster-related major error. The NCAA team hasn't made roster-managing or the shipped rosters workable in what seems like four years.

[Bigdmo9999]

Quote: Originally Posted by ebarws6

You know, even with all this uproar and call for the sacking of every single person associated with '10, I will give some credit to the team if they manage to find a good solution. Yes, there still is a long way to go, but if they manage to get out of this mess then I will give them some respect.

So you'd give respect to someone who lets say pushed you into water to where you were drowning, but they figured out a way to save you? That makes no sense. They ruined it in the first place, big deal if they fix it.

[ebarws6]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bigdmo9999

So you'd give respect to someone who lets say pushed you into water to where you were drowning, but they figured out a way to save you? That makes no sense. They ruined it in the first place, big deal if they fix it.

Completely different situation. That's life and death. This is just a video game.

[stevedrumsdw]

Quote: Originally Posted by tyler741

I didn't think it was possible for a bigger screw-up than last year's roster debacle, but I forgot this was EA with a development team that was clearly not prepared/qualified to start working on the game.

There is clearly a problem within this company that needs addressing. I find it inconceivable that nobody noticed this before finalization.


THE GREAT ROSTER BLUNDER OF 2009

[ehovUOfan]

If they fix it, I'll be glad but I won't congratulate them since they didn't do their job in the first place. I say that EA should take a look at how it runs game development and try to find ways to make sure mistakes like this don't happen again. Also, I think they should fire the game testers for NCAA since they should have at least caught some of the roster mistakes, unless they all played the same teams that were correct and not the lower-rung NCAA teams that seem to be the ones the are completely wrong.

[sportzbro]

Quote: Originally Posted by ebarws6

Completely different situation. That's life and death. This is just a video game.

Its called an analogy..