NHL 10 Trailer: E3 09 Debut

[RealmK]

Quote: Originally Posted by Redshirt_EA

Thanks Don King. I'd rather you arrange a bout for me with some of the guys in the "Comeback AI" thread.

I'd love to be your corner man in that bout

[wildthing2022000]

Quote: Originally Posted by sharks

Why are fans without towels doing the towel waving motion? Sticks still go through other players. The player trying to trip Crosby was not even holding his stick, and it went through the ice. The Crosby shot looked so unrealistic. The puck floated off his stick before he even did his unrealistic-looking shot animation. Kipper also missed trying to turn around and swat the puck, so I hope he did not end up magically hitting it away.

What trip of Crosby? There was no one there. The Crosby shot looked like practice mode since no one was around him. The Ovie trip looked fine since the d-man was wacking at Ovie's leg so I'm not going to expect someone to hold on to their stick 100% of the time if they're hitting someone with the shaft of the stick. How long do you think the puck stays on the stick on a shot? It was a quick backhand shot. As for Kipper, kind of hard to magically hit it away when the entire swing is done and the puck is still falling.

[RealmK]

Quote: Originally Posted by sharks

Why are fans without towels doing the towel waving motion? Sticks still go through other players. The player trying to trip Crosby was not even holding his stick, and it went through the ice. The Crosby shot looked so unrealistic. The puck floated off his stick before he even did his unrealistic-looking shot animation. Kipper also missed trying to turn around and swat the puck, so I hope he did not end up magically hitting it away.

Are you even watching the same trailer as everyone else? Reaching man is reaching.

[Redshirt_EA]

Quote: Originally Posted by sharks

Why are fans without towels doing the towel waving motion? Sticks still go through other players. The player trying to trip Crosby was not even holding his stick, and it went through the ice. The Crosby shot looked so unrealistic. The puck floated off his stick before he even did his unrealistic-looking shot animation. Kipper also missed trying to turn around and swat the puck, so I hope he did not end up magically hitting it away.

What does any of that have to do with whether the Chicago fans are waving Hawks or Bruins towels?

[RealmK]

Quote: Originally Posted by Redshirt_EA

What does any of that have to do with whether the Chicago fans are waving Hawks or Bruins towels?

Eh I chaulk shark up to a troll, viewing his post history and the barb he tossed at the Madden team, Ian in particular pretty much tipped it off.

[sharks]

Quote: Originally Posted by Redshirt_EA

What does any of that have to do with whether the Chicago fans are waving Hawks or Bruins towels?

Huh? I was not the one who brought that up. Fans who do not have towels should not be doing the towel waving motion. The collision detection was very poor as well and can hopefully be fixed. I am trying to help. The trailer looked great aside from those glaring issues.

[sharks]

Quote: Originally Posted by wildthing2022000

What trip of Crosby? There was no one there. The Crosby shot looked like practice mode since no one was around him. The Ovie trip looked fine since the d-man was wacking at Ovie's leg so I'm not going to expect someone to hold on to their stick 100% of the time if they're hitting someone with the shaft of the stick. How long do you think the puck stays on the stick on a shot? It was a quick backhand shot. As for Kipper, kind of hard to magically hit it away when the entire swing is done and the puck is still falling.

When the player tried to trip Ovechkin, he let go of his stick. This is not really much of an issue. The issue is that when he let go of his stick, the blade sunk into the ice. Also, they cut the Kipper save short, so hopefully the puck did not end up flying ten feet even though he missed. As for the Crosby shot, it looked like the puck floated off his stick before he even shot. I may be wrong about some of these, but that is just what I saw after watching the trailer a few times. I just don't want NHL 10 to have all of these great improvements just to have poor collision detection and funky animations spoil it. I am not trying to be rude. I just want NHL 10 to be great.

[sharks]

Quote: Originally Posted by RealmK

Are you even watching the same trailer as everyone else? Reaching man is reaching.

Why yes I am. Did you see any of the flaws I saw? You had to see the poor collison detection. Other than that, it looked great. I would love to say it was absolutely perfect, but it was not quite there.