Madden NFL 10 Gameplay Video

[Perfect Zero]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

Your right, I misread about what you said about EA reading off the boards. Are you privy that they read the OS boards, though? Ian was the first one that posted over here. Before that, I didn't recognize anyone from EA over here. Maybe you should lay off the hard stuff as well and try reading comprehension. My point is, the 8 people that went to CD were hard core Madden critics. They let EA know what didn't look right, and sent feedback to Ian even 1-2 weeks after CD. Is that clearer for you?

They have before, but I admit not in the same fashion as they do today. I take it as a positive sign, but then again I look at their track record.

And thank you for clearing up that second paragraph. Now that I can read it, I'm not disputing that at all. What I'm saying is what you put in writing doesn't always get interpreted correctly.

[fourthreemafia]

Quote: Originally Posted by Perfect Zero

Or maybe I can't dumb down my English to understand what he wrote. I'm guessing he's saying that I have never played Madden in the next- gen series. That would be a lie, considering I own Madden 07 and have rented the past two versions. I still play 2k5 on a regular basis though. Of course, I can't understand seventh- grade English, so maybe he wasn't saying that. If so, my apologies.

Dont worry...one day, youll be able to read at a seventh grade level.

Only person who doesnt understand it is you. You shouldnt toss insults around when the issue is clearly on your end.

[PackersFan127]

[quote=fourthreemafia;2039479406]Dont worry...one day, youll be able to read at a seventh grade level.

[Perfect Zero]

Quote: Originally Posted by PackersFan127

Umm, we have heard people that have PLAYED THE GAME that have said that allpro/allmadden are very sim, and we heard it from Ian as well, GET A GRIP

I have heard it from EA too. I've also heard that we will play the game in a whole new light in Madden 10, just like in Madden 09, just like in Madden 08, and so on. I don't believe a word of it until I see it.

[Perfect Zero]

Quote: Originally Posted by fourthreemafia

Dont worry...one day, youll be able to read at a seventh grade level. Only person who doesnt understand it is you. You shouldnt toss insults around when the issue is clearly on your end.

I don't read at a seventh- grade level because I constantly read research papers by my peers. That is at the college level. I would hope you could understand that, but then again, it might be above your head.

[Bgamer90]

Quote: Originally Posted by Perfect Zero

He sorta did make the game like that in the past, considering he was on the team. Ian saying he wants to keep rookie and pro modes the same is a great excuse to base failures off of. Again, "it's only rookie mode" give him the room to put out gameplay that is sub- par. And again, I should take your word on all- pro and all- Madden being tuned up, considering you have the game.

Ian worked on the team yes, but he didn't have any say as to what actually got in the game and what didn't.

lol you are funny.

All I'm doing is saying what has been said by the testers and the blogs. I don't have the game and neither have I played it (since if that was the case I wouldn't even talk about the game as much as I am now due to the various agreements the testers have to make lol).

Ian himself said the game was tuned the most on all-pro and all-madden and so have the testers. So who should I believe?
You (a person who hasn't played the game at all) or Ian and the testers who were critical of madden (people who have worked on the game and have played it)?

[PackersFan127]

Quote: Originally Posted by Perfect Zero

I don't read at a seventh- grade level because I constantly read research papers by my peers. That is at the college level. I would hope you could understand that, but then again, it might be above your head.

based on your responses, I seriously doubt that you are succeeding in college. What that person wrote that you didn't understand was written in plain English that any college student should understand.

[alliance4g63]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bgamer90

Ian is the new head of the team... so he wasn't the one that made the game like that in the past... Ian has basically said that he wanted to keep rookie and pro modes the same in terms of play since casuals enjoy playing the game that way. All-pro and all-madden got the most tuning and like I said before, this year the difference in rookie/pro and all-pro/all-madden will be the biggest they ever were in a madden game due to this.

But you know what man, it's the same pig with lipstick on. Look I'm pretty sure Ian has a very high approval rating with the community. I would assume that 99% of the people here want to see him succeed. The problem is Ian is not really the problem the core engine of the Madden game is the problem. This includes the game engine as well as all the suits signing the checks. Madden is so huge that they are almost obligated to keep it as it has been in the past which is evident from the recent videos.

Maybe we are speaking different languages. You say it's because it is on rookie, I say well then rookie should be eliminated. We just want different thing from a simulation video game. We have had the same debates on teamxbox and I don't think it will change.

I really hope they do good and I will eat my humble pie if August comes around and all my points are off base. But from the videos so far, it is just looking like the Madden hype train all over again. All aboard!