Madden 09: celebration videos (IGN)

[PacMan3000]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheFuture15

Come on man...just think a little deeper. Think about every artist that you've met - the ones that went to art school, or film school, or worked in graphic design, or did animation for Disney films - ones that are really talented and gifted in their craft. Or folks that grew up in Japan or Korea their whole life and are relatively new to the US. You've got to realize that not every single person in a creative field like animation might not know what Green Bay players specifically do whenever they score. That's why there are folks like me around here - and unfortunately I never saw it to sign off on.

Ian,

I completely understand what you mean, but what I don't get is this:

If an artist isn't familiar with the Lambeau Leap--fine. I can buy that he/she isn't from the US...or is a nerd and didn't watch many Packers games.

But, if your job is to create realistic NFL celebrations, don't you have a stack of Packers game tapes on your desk? Don't you do your research on how the Lambeau Leap looks?

That's my confusion, because while I understand that some things in the NFL a given EA artist might not inherently know, isn't it their job to seek it out, research, and learn about it so that they can accurately replicate it in a game?

[Danimal]

Quote: Originally Posted by Eddie1967

I don't see that at all. it seems to have possibly fixed that one celebration. Don't be scared, uh uh don't be scared. lol

You have to be kidding.

Look a mistake was made, not only did he own up to it, he provided proof that they did in fact capture the correct thing. Sure it should have been caught but it wasn't. But it happened and they are trying to fix it.

Instead of seeing that and moving on this thread has gone from talking about the videos to telling the devs of the game they aren't doing their job right, starting the old 2k vs EA thing again, demanding more resources be allocated and in some cases telling them how their dev time should of been spent because they didn't implement exactly what YOU wanted.

The condescending attitude and sense of entitlement some of you demonstrate is nothing short of spectacular. I amazed these guys are sticking it out on these forums.

You don't see how this thread has taken a wrong turn, give me a break. I'm surprised the mods haven't locked it down yet.

[BezO]

Quote: Originally Posted by ODogg

It's really quite simple, the general public likes players to celebrate more than any of the other stuff you described. Once again another OS'er has tunnel vision in thinking with what they want instead of seeing the big picture.

I'd appreciate you laying off the insults.

I'm fully aware some people enjoy celebrations more than those things. My points were: Get it right if you're going to dedicate so much time to it. And there are events that happen much more frequently, that could've been pulled off much easier and looked better.

What % of folks you think would take a good looking coach/QB cut scene over a lay up celebration?

[ODogg]

Quote: Originally Posted by BezO

I'd appreciate you laying off the insults.

It's not an insult, it's an analysis. Stop taking things so personally. See my custom title? WHy sO SeRiOuS??

Quote: Originally Posted by BezO

I'm fully aware some people enjoy celebrations more than those things. My points were: Get it right if you're going to dedicate so much time to it. And there are events that happen much more frequently, that could've been pulled off much easier and looked better. What % of folks you think would take a good looking coach/QB cut scene over a lay up celebration?

Probably 10% at the most. Most of the general public who play these games would prefer to have their players celebrate than see a coach/QB cut scene. Those scenes appeal to people like us here at OS, not the general public near as much.

[Shadymamba]

Quote: Originally Posted by djordan

WOW @ BUTCHING THE LAMBEAU LEAP!

whhhat the hell was that..it looked like when brett tried to do it..was he humping the wall oh man!!!!!..ps. Terry Glenn has no hops lmao!!!

[Shadymamba]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheFuture15

Hey guys - thought I'd respond to this post with a couple of points: 1. Post play is a totally different area from gameplay...so if anyone's concerned about us spending too much time here and not focusing on gameplay issues, that concern is invalid 2. The "dunk" is not a dunk - that's a specific layup animation for players that are too short or don't have a high enough jump rating to actually dunk over the post 3. I am actually pretty upset about the Lambeau Leap animation - that's the first time I've actually seen it in game, and it seems they used one of the wall celebration animations from NFL Tour instead of the real Lambeau animation. I know this because I directed the motion capture of 2 variations of it - see videos: I will check to see if we can sneak a change in for a patch. I know it's not really a big deal in the grand scheme of things, but it's not even close to what we are supposed to be using for the Lambeau Leap - you all are right - it's like Spiderman or something. Just a mistake here by whoever was working on it...we don't have accuracy experts working on every aspect of the game so sometimes things like this can slip through. 4. I am pretty sure the Mile High salute is still in 5. You CAN steal another player's celebration. So if you score against TO, and you hit the steal button (I think it's B / Circle), you have a chance of doing one of TO's celebrations.

Thanks for posting.....its crazy how they put one thing in the green room and the product ships another...you should find him and lambeau leap his *** out of EA office whoever did that lol, but hey i dont even use the packers so as long as the gameplay is better i'll give it a shot and see whats good

[tombrokaw]

EA needs to hire the most anal retentive madden fan to just spot all of these uniform, animation, whatever inaccuracies. What's another 40k to this budget?

[AllenRulz00]

Those look so freaking awesome.