Madden NFL 09 Quarterbacks Analysis

[ChuckMonts]

depending on the Madden Generated Draft classes and what can be created with NCAA I plan on doing a HUGE madden Rerating.

[X*Cell]

Quote: Originally Posted by allBthere

all are way too high. Why is a rating in the 80s bad all of a sudden. Kitna imo should be 78. Actually the whole thing needs to be ajusted to the GOAT, not relative to who's the best this year and rate everyone esle accordingly etc. imo. there should be 2 ab's in the 90s - peyton and brady - that's it. No one else has shown that they'll be a first ballot HOF. That's what HOF's are= 90s, very very good - great players are high 80s, good players are 70s, average are 60s. Everyone needs to come down almost 10 pts. I saw brady's arm strength 99. LOL! his arm isn't strongest in the league let alone close to the GOAT. It would be nice if we could get the ratings back to this planet and down to reality. - maybe then the game would play a little better.

agreed... the difference from top QB to worst QB is not significant enough to really tell anything. I've seen 88 rated QB's dominate in Madden, while the 83 rated QB's suck tremendously. There should just be a bigger difference so it's EASIER to tell.

[Shadymamba]

Quote: Originally Posted by blackngoldfan

Yeah, but he knew the defensive signals.

ROFLMAO!!!!!

[Crawi]

Delhomme and Leinart both at 85? I don't see that. Leinart seems to really be struggling, he hasn't won a handful of road playoff games like Delhomme. I think Delhomme is fine at 85, but Leinart should be lucky to have 80 IMO.