Madden NFL 09 Quarterbacks Analysis

[AC IS ART]

Campbells rating is upsetting. His speed is always underated and his throw power should be higher. Im not saying he should be an 87 or above, but he's better than Matt Leinart..

[N51_rob]

Quote: Originally Posted by AC IS ART

Campbells rating is upsetting. His speed is always underated and his throw power should be higher. Im not saying he should be an 87 or above, but he's better than Matt Leinart..

Should he be rated higher than Leinhart I don't know. But he should easily be the highest rated QB on the Redskins, and he is not. I am really having a hard time justifying how Collins is higher rated than Campbell. Especially given that this is a new offense for him and it is one that Jason has been in before as far as the basic scheme.

[blackngoldfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by jertwa

I read that they gave Dennis Dixon a 60 speed rating. I know he tore his ACL, but come on! That's absolutely rediculous! I don't expect his ratings to be amazing, but that should have been one of the good ones.

I guess that's punishment for the way he cheesed in the NCAA games.

[BledsoeHoF]

Kitna should be around 78-80..

Delhomme should be 78-80 ( Never thrown for 3000 yards )

Alex Smith at 80 is pretty generous and should be no higher than a 75.

Jason Campbell seems about right.

How Leinart got rated at 85 I do not know. Should be no higher than 70.

Rogers at 83 is definately generous as he has done nothing.

Matt Ryan hasnt even thrown a pass yet and it rated 83? Please.

I think Manning is pretty close at 93 but for me 90 seems about right.

Conclusion... Noone at EA knows anything about football.

[Chavez21]

Quote: Originally Posted by BledsoeHoF

Kitna should be around 78-80.. Delhomme should be 78-80 ( Never thrown for 3000 yards ) Alex Smith at 80 is pretty generous and should be no higher than a 75. Jason Campbell seems about right. How Leinart got rated at 85 I do not know. Should be no higher than 70. Rogers at 83 is definately generous as he has done nothing. Matt Ryan hasnt even thrown a pass yet and it rated 83? Please. I think Manning is pretty close at 93 but for me 90 seems about right. Conclusion... Noone at EA knows anything about football.

Jake Delhomme threw for 3000 yards in 03,04, and 05. He also threw for 2800 yards in 13 games in 2006. He was on pace for 3000 yards last year before he got hurt.

[Shadymamba]

Eli's a 93 i dont know how high you want him yes he won a super bowl but so did trent dilfer lol 93 is fne if he was 80-something then i'll be like wtf and as for the rookies..every year same ol, thats why if you do a fantasy draft just take rookies lol...you'll have a dynasty for years and a real good team madden always does this

[sqeg]

Quote: Originally Posted by ghettoshark

Kitna should be lower than 80 IMO. He's the beneficiary of a pass-happy Mike Martz offense. His numbers should go way down this year. Remember, he also threw more INTs than TDs, led the league in INTs, and ranked 19th in the QB Rating (despite playing in a Martz offense). That's pitiful production.

I couldn't have said this any better & I totally agree w/this on Kitna. He's a decent QB but cmon.... stop trying to compare his stats to Peyton, Ben, & Rivers, especially when Ben & Rivers play in a run first scheme & as for Peyton, did the Lions have a record even close to what the Colts did or did the Lions even make the playoffs for that matter last season?..... Didn't think so.

[crques]

Quote: Originally Posted by Ceothachosen1

no way leinart deserves to be a 85 and how is rodgers rated the same as campbell another thing how is matt ryan rated higher then russell who was the first pick in the draft and a much better prospect

Actually, I think that Ryan should be rated higher than Russell. Watching them both play in college, Ryan was far more advanced in mechanics and decision making in my opinion. Russell was the best of a mediocre bunch of QB's in last year's group. I think he would have probably been the 3rd of 4th QB taken in this year's draft. Just my thoughts though.