Everybody's a Critic: The Show '08 Edition

[RaychelSnr]

We've posted our review for the PlayStation 3 version of MLB '08: The Show, but what did some other critics have to say about the game? Click on to read more...

[Skyboxer]

Looks good everyone except G4(Which I stopped watching them a year or so ago when I found out they caused brain damage) basically came to around the same feelings I have. G4 simply has no idea and it's obvious they played maybe an inning or 2 just from the statement "If you purchased last year’s title, this game is not worth forking over another 60 bucks for the same experience" It's a totally different experience from graphics to tons more animations. Thier not happy unless they are reviewing We "heart" Katamari...

[jim416]

The game is the pretty much the same as last year, but with a more updated roster. If you purchased last year’s title, this game is not worth forking over another 60 bucks for the same experience.

Now THAT'S funny.

[jsg]

gotta love g4 and their great reviews, lol

[Behindshadows]

G4 doesn't know a thing about sports games. The only episode I ever liked from them. Was when Morgan and whats his name, clowned EA Sports for copy stuff from ESPN 2k5 and putting it in Madden 08. That episode has me cracking up!

Other than that, they suck when it comes to rating sports games. They are too bias and unknowledgeable at times.

[coffeeholic]

I don't watch that junkola for the simple reasons they:
A.Don't like a game unless Super mario is in it or doesn't have a Wiimote control or whatever it's called.
B.Think every game review should include a comedy sketch rather than in-depth facts or opinions.
C.They could very well be biased against sports games,this option is very likely and a strong one.
Conclusion: I could give a flying hoot as to whether a game show likes a certain game or not. The only thing that bothers me,is that we really don't have a decent show on tv that I know of that caters to real gamers. Thank God for websites like this.