Madden 12 or Fifa 12?

[pntdj]

Alright so I have the gamestop powerup rewards pro membership card, and I just renewed my membership. Since I renewed it they gave me a Buy 2 Get One Free coupon, and I need help deciding on how to use it. So I want to sell Madden 12, but I don't want to regret my decision and end up wanting to buy it again later on. So should I sell Madden 12? What I'm planning to do is sell madden, buy Fifa 12, along with nba 2k12, and get either Call of duty MW3 for free, or Battlefield 3. So any suggestions on what to do?

[TNT713]

Sell Madden? Absolute heresy! It's still football season. Of course, this is coming from someone that still has a copy of Madden from every year except 2000 (still need to get it). Madden is the only reason I have a gaming console.

Later

[tKlausEffect]

NBA 2K12 and MW3

[CRMosier_LM]

I have read all the FIFA hype and while it may be a good game I just don't understand the appeal. The game is simplistic to the point of extreme redundancy. People can say "its way better than Madden" well there is nothing to the game, it has (in my opinion) probably half the amount of coding required to.produce Madden. That's the game of American football is so much more complex. Yeah the commentary is better but it should be, they have so much room left on the disc to fill up after gameplay lol.

[rmb]

Fifa is an amazing game so you should pick that up either way.

As far as getting rid of Madden, i would advise against it since i can promise you that you will wanna play it again