Home
Feature Article
Noob Guide to Transactions in MLB '09: The Show

For baseball purists, one of the biggest additions to MLB 09: The Show has been the inclusion of authentic professional transactions within the franchise mode. No longer are virtual owners stuck with the limited options of trades and free agency -- now the full spectrum of rosters moves are available to budding Billy Beanes.

However, within this new framework there is a slight problem. Since video games have ignored realistic roster handling for a long time (outside of Acclaim’s All-Star Baseball), many users do not know what all of the new moves mean. The developers of The Show have tried to help by including a handbook on the disc, but for those interested in reading a less "textbook" approach, here is a primer for getting a grip on your roster.

Free Agency


Once a player has accumulated at least six years of Major League experience, he is eligible for free agency after his current contract ends. After that amount of time, any player can sign with any team. This six-year term is important because you may not feel the need to sign young prospects to long contracts until they approach eligible free agency.

Also, it is worth mentioning the supplemental picks you get or give up as a result of signing players via free agency.

If you sign a player who ranks in the top 20 percent at his position (called a Type A free agent), you give your first-round draft pick to his original team. That team also gets a supplemental "free pick" between the first and second rounds.

Should you sign a player who ranks in the 21-to-40 percent at his position (Type B), his original team simply gets one of those "free" or supplemental picks.

Salary Arbitration


While you may not want to dish out big money to lock up a young player before you have to, that player may expect more money than you are willing to give him. If you cannot come to terms with this player, and he has at least three years of experience, you may need to enter arbitration at the end of his contract.

Essentially, the player and the team submit contract offers; an independent arbiter (here, the A.I.) picks the one that is deemed most fair. Whichever one is chosen -- that is what you pay.

"Super Two" Exception: A young player who has not played for three years may be eligible for arbitration if he has seen significant playing time. Basically, the player has to have played at least two years and must be among the top 17 percent of players that have accumulated playing time.

25/40-Man Roster Issues


Normally, you will have 25 spots to fill on your active roster. These will be the players who you can use on the field on a daily basis.

The additional 15 spots on your 40-man roster are primarily for players who may bounce back and forth between the Majors and minors. Starting on September 1, you can dress and play anyone from your 40-man roster.

Options: So let us say that you have a fringe player who has seen time on both your Major League and Triple-A squads for three years. In the past, most video games allowed you to move him up and down between the clubs as much as you wanted. However, in the real MLB, any player who has been on the 40-man roster, but not on the active 25-man roster for any part of three seasons, is said to be "out of options" once his fourth year as a pro starts. In other words, you cannot move him back down to the minors without risk at that point.

When this happens, that player has to go through the waiver process before going down to the minors.

Waivers: Think of waivers as a grab-bag of discarded players. If a team waives a player, any other team can claim him, that is, grab him and place him on a new team. If two teams claim the same player, the team lower in the standings gets preference.

In real life, there are other resolutions to a waived player, but MLB 09: The Show simplifies the process for the sake of our sanity. If you waive a player and he is claimed, he is gone. If no one claims him, he is now on your minor-league team.

Rule 5 Draft: This draft occurs in December. Instead of drafting young players out of college, you are essentially drafting young players from other teams. If a player has played for a team for three years (four if he was 18 or younger when signed), but is not on the 40-man roster, he can be drafted by another team.

However, there is a risk factor when you grab this young talent. Once selected, the player has to play the entire upcoming season on the 25-man roster or else he goes back to his original team. Plus, there is a monetary fee that has to be paid to the former team if the player does not cut it on your 25-man roster.

After one year of being a Rule 5 draftee, the player reverts back to being a "normal" player.

For the record, some recent notable Rule 5 draftees include Shane Victorino, Johan Santana and Dan Uggla.

Running Your Franchise


With that information out of the way, here are three quick tips that should help you effectively run your franchise.

Avoid Rule 5 temptations: It might be very enticing to scoop up a lot of cheap, young talent in the Rule 5 Draft, but remember, these players must play on your active team. If your picks turn into busts, you are stuck with them.

Use the minors sparingly: With the inclusion of "options," you cannot use the minors as a "practice squad" where you move players up and down at will. Be judicious when it comes to deciding when and who you should send down to the minors.

Have a plan: You can dig yourself into long-term trouble if you aimlessly grab every attractive free agent, waived player or touted young star who has crossed your desk. Finances aside, you can easily lock yourself into a tough spot with an inflexible active roster loaded with Rule 5 draftees and long-term contracts. Only pick up players that "fit your system."


Have fun enjoying a new baseball season, moving players around, shopping for "hidden" talent, and playing a pretty good baseball game in MLB 09: The Show. And, take a look at the built-in Transaction Handbook within the game for more information.


MLB '09: The Show Videos
Member Comments
# 1 HustlinOwl @ 04/07/09 11:47 AM
Great tips, I will be using these tools as soon as Knight's rosters are finished and I start my franchise.
 
# 2 Invictus375 @ 04/07/09 12:32 PM
Great thread!

My question revolves around this:

Quote:
If you sign a player who ranks in the top 20 percent at his position (called a Type A free agent), you give your first-round draft pick to his original team. That team also gets a supplemental "free pick" between the first and second rounds.
How is the top 20 percent determined? You should know this BEFORE you decide not to re-sign someone right? How do you figure out the top 20 at a given position?
 
# 3 Imnus @ 04/07/09 01:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Invictus375
Great thread!

My question revolves around this:



How is the top 20 percent determined? You should know this BEFORE you decide not to re-sign someone right? How do you figure out the top 20 at a given position?
The FA Type of the player it's said on his Player Card.
 
# 4 Imnus @ 04/07/09 01:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Maynard
good topic as i am no expert in these rules of baseball.

let me ask about this
so if my player has not been on the 40 man roster, then Options dont matter because i cant move him up to the MLB level unless he is on the 40 man, right??

my next question applies to this

im confused on this. what if he was on the 40 man, and on the 25 man active roster, does this mean he doesnt have options and can be moved as much as i want? Or is that bolded line above just talking about a guy that is out of options because he was never added to the 15 man roster?

does every player have options if they are on the 40 man and/or 25 man roster?

do the options renew every year, or on a timeline of some kind?

this stuff is a great addition to the game, but im confused by alot of it and want to know how it works. i may have to research mlb rules to understand better
Options allow you to move a player from MLB to minors, every time you send down a player to Minors, you used an Option of that player, that Option last a whole season, meaning you cand send him down to the minors as much as you want that year.

Every player have 3 Options (even if he's neither on the 25-Man Roster nor on the 40-Man Roster), and no, they never reset.
 
# 5 SHO @ 04/07/09 02:50 PM
Can someone explain to me why I never get extra draft picks when my Type A and B free agents are signed by someone else? I offer them arbitration like I'm supposed to, they decline it and are picked by someone else. Then come June 3rd, I don't even get a supplemental pick.
 
# 6 SHO @ 04/07/09 05:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NOBLE
Can someone explain to me why I never get extra draft picks when my Type A and B free agents are signed by someone else? I offer them arbitration like I'm supposed to, they decline it and are picked by someone else. Then come June 3rd, I don't even get a supplemental pick.
Bump. I'm honestly confused with what I'm not doing to get draft picks.
 
# 7 Imnus @ 04/07/09 06:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NOBLE
Bump. I'm honestly confused with what I'm not doing to get draft picks.
Sorry, can't help you with that. But I play the Yanks and the draft picks have been taking from me.
 
# 8 asu666 @ 04/07/09 10:34 PM
Wow, great post. I thought I knew a lot about the systems; however you taught me a few new things. Thanks
 
# 9 KingV2k3 @ 04/08/09 02:39 PM
Thanks for the tips...

I used to juggle middle relievers between my MLB and AAA squads alot until I found out that this year, they'd possibly have to clear waivers...
 
# 10 Tonsoffun @ 04/08/09 04:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NOBLE
Can someone explain to me why I never get extra draft picks when my Type A and B free agents are signed by someone else? I offer them arbitration like I'm supposed to, they decline it and are picked by someone else. Then come June 3rd, I don't even get a supplemental pick.
you should automatically get the Sandwich pick (supplemental) regardless of A/B status. However, for Type A, if say, the Yankees do what they did this winter, in signing Sabathia, Teixeira, and Burnett... there's only 1 1st round pick available, so only one of those teams is getting that pick (the angels did). so perhaps this is happening in your franchise?
 
# 11 JT30 @ 04/08/09 04:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Imnus
Every player have 3 Options (even if he's neither on the 25-Man Roster nor on the 40-Man Roster), and no, they never reset.
Sorry but its very possible to get a fourth option. Delmon Young is a recent example.

You may want to be more familiar with the rules before you start giving out false info
 
# 12 Imnus @ 04/08/09 05:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JT30
Sorry but its very possible to get a fourth option. Delmon Young is a recent example.

You may want to be more familiar with the rules before you start giving out false info
OK, but that's an extra Option. Options do not reset. This special case only applies when a player has used all three options already and does not have five full seasons of professional experience.
 
# 13 JT30 @ 04/08/09 05:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Imnus
OK, but that's an extra Option. Options do not reset. This special case only applies when a player has used all three options already and does not have five full seasons of professional experience.
I didnt say options reset.

1. A player who is currently entering his fourth or fifth pro season and already has been optioned in three separate years gets a fourth option.

2. A player who has missed one or more seasons to injury - meaning an entire season, or enough time to accrue fewer than 90 days on an active roster - may get a fourth option if, exclusive of those injury-shortened years, he has fewer than five full seasons in pro ball. A season in which he's on an active roster for 60 days or more and then gets hurt still counts as a full season, but a season in which he's hurt and then comes back and gets 60-89 days of service after the injury does not.

3. Seasons spent in short season leagues
 
# 14 Imnus @ 04/08/09 05:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JT30
I didnt say options reset.

1. A player who is currently entering his fourth or fifth pro season and already has been optioned in three separate years gets a fourth option.

2. A player who has missed one or more seasons to injury - meaning an entire season, or enough time to accrue fewer than 90 days on an active roster - may get a fourth option if, exclusive of those injury-shortened years, he has fewer than five full seasons in pro ball. A season in which he's on an active roster for 60 days or more and then gets hurt still counts as a full season, but a season in which he's hurt and then comes back and gets 60-89 days of service after the injury does not.

3. Seasons spent in short season leagues
Well, he was asking if Options reset every few years or something like that, I just said they don't.
 
# 15 JT30 @ 04/08/09 05:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Imnus
Well, he was asking if Options reset every few years or something like that, I just said they don't.
Oh I thought you told him players will only get 3 options. No big deal. But I dont think this game considers the 4th option possibility. And I doubt the game knows to turn rev. waivers into irrev. waivers after the player was pulled back for the 2nd time on a claim
 
# 16 Invictus375 @ 04/08/09 05:44 PM
Is there any way to see what transactions have taken place in RTTS? I see at the beginning of year 3 (I'm in ST) that one of the Rangers up and coming young CP's and their #1 draft pick 1B from 2008 are both no longer on the team.

Any way to see how this happened?
 
# 17 Imnus @ 04/08/09 06:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JT30
Oh I thought you told him players will only get 3 options. No big deal. But I dont think this game considers the 4th option possibility. And I doubt the game knows to turn rev. waivers into irrev. waivers after the player was pulled back for the 2nd time on a claim
He asked if only players that were on the 40-Man Roster had Options or something like that, what he wrote was too confusing. And I'm pretty sure Revocable Waivers aren't in the game.
 
# 18 Invictus375 @ 04/08/09 06:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Imnus
He asked if only players that were on the 40-Man Roster had Options or something like that, what he wrote was too confusing. And I'm pretty sure Revocable Waivers aren't in the game.

Sweet Jesus...are you two married?

let's focus on the important part here, like my question!!

Quote:
Is there any way to see what transactions have taken place in RTTS? I see at the beginning of year 3 (I'm in ST) that one of the Rangers up and coming young CP's and their #1 draft pick 1B from 2008 are both no longer on the team.
 
# 19 Antkowiak @ 04/09/09 04:49 AM
I love how all these new management features are in the game, but it is still impossible to simply drop players to FA in the roster manager.
 
# 20 SHO @ 04/09/09 11:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tonsoffun
you should automatically get the Sandwich pick (supplemental) regardless of A/B status. However, for Type A, if say, the Yankees do what they did this winter, in signing Sabathia, Teixeira, and Burnett... there's only 1 1st round pick available, so only one of those teams is getting that pick (the angels did). so perhaps this is happening in your franchise?
I guess so, but I'm still confused when the 2009 first-year draft comes up and the Angels have about two picks each in the first and supp. rounds.

Here is what went down in my Oakland franchise. I offered all three arbitration before the deadline.

Matt Holliday - Type A (signed with Minnesota)
Orlando Cabrerra - Type A (signed with Boston)
Nomar - Type B (signed with Kansas City)

I should have gotten three picks correct?

Did the signing of Carl Crawford (Type A) completely throw off my chances at getting those picks?

Trying to run the Moneyball model is useless if I get these picks to work right for me.
 

« Previous12Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.