Home
Feature Article
Why Sports Gamers Need Nintendo

As a child of the '80s and early '90s, the majority of my earliest sports-gaming memories were forged on the Nintendo Entertainment System. I can remember countless hours spent with games like Pro Wrestling, Punch-Out!!, Excitebike, Baseball, Ice Hockey and many more first-party, non-licensed, titles for Nintendo's first home console.

When the Genesis was released, followed by the Super Nintendo, the days of first-party Nintendo sports titles seemed to be scaled back drastically. Starting with EA's NHLPA and Madden series, licensed sports games became more of a necessity in a market clamoring for realism in the sports-gaming sector.

This trend was the beginning of the end for unique sports titles on the Nintendo consoles, and also served as the end of the fictional players and teams of yesteryear. One of the more disturbing results of this shift in sports gaming was that Nintendo, in many ways, even abandoned its own first-party sports titles -- I would argue that there has not been a relevant sports game on a Nintendo system since the N64 days.

With the Wii's launch in 2006, Nintendo was able to once again summon its first-party sports magic, releasing the incredibly popular and fun Wii Sports. While a few of the games included on the disc could be categorized more as sports mini-games, one truly stood out as a full-featured sports experience that will go down in sports-gaming history as a true classic: Wii Bowling.

I fall in love with Nintendo as a sports developer each and every time I play Wii Bowling, just because of how awesome the game plays -- I even wonder how much money bowling alleys have lost since the game's release. More importantly, the nostalgia for the glory days of sports games on the NES is put into full effect whenever I play Wii Bowling.

In today's license-heavy sports-gaming market, I often find myself looking for something more. Sometimes I am unsure as to how I can keep myself excited for sports titles that release on a yearly basis, contain minimal upgrades, run off the same engine and will inevitably find themselves on my dreaded "dusty gaming shelf" within weeks of purchase. I find myself yearning for the NES sports games of the '80s -- games that I still find myself playing on a regular basis thanks to the Wii's Virtual Console and my own personal collection of Nintendo consoles.

The more I think about it, the more I wonder what the sports-gaming landscape would look like if Nintendo were still thoroughly committed to providing both licensed and unlicensed first-party sports titles. In this hardcore sports gamer's humble opinion, we would all be a lot better off than we are now.

Nintendo Can Still Create Sports Games That Sell

The first question that really has to be explored before moving on in this discussion is, can an unlicensed sports title even survive in the market today? This is a tricky question to answer, especially after looking at recent commercial flops like All-Pro Football 2K8 and Tecmo Bowl: Kickoff. In addition, my answer to this question is a bit unique because I feel the only developer that can actually pull off a million-selling non-licensed sports game today is Nintendo.

Perhaps it is my nostalgia speaking again, but if I was given a Wii title with the overall quality of an Ice Hockey, Excitebike or Pro Wrestling, then it would not matter if there was a sports license and real player names.There was something so addictive about the aforementioned games that I almost would rather play hockey as a generic Team USA or wrestle as The Amazon. If you think about it, hockey players like the skinny, medium and fat guy, and wrestlers like Starman have become just as popular as the Ovechkin's and Triple H's of the world.

Nintendo has always been able to create its own recognizable sports characters that have a place in pop-culture history, and this is the the main reason why Nintendo could be wildly successful if it created more unlicensed sports titles. Nintendo has to understand that there is a serious opportunity to make non-licensed sports games as relevant as they were in the '80s and '90s -- along with cashing in on some strong remakes of existing licensed franchises like Ken Griffey Baseball and the Kobe Bryant Courtside series.


Nintendo Creates Quality Games

Aside from creating memorable sports franchises and characters, Nintendo already has a leg up on much of the current competition when it comes to quality and polish. I say that because there is no denying the fact that many sports games today can be summed up with two simple words: declining quality.

I know I am not alone when I say that I have had enough of the half-hearted sports releases that require multiple patches post-release to even become playable. Nintendo is a company that has extremely high quality standards (at least when it comes to its own games) -- a fact that makes me believe any internally developed sports game will be solid.

No one develops games with more love and attention to detail than Nintendo, and I believe Nintendo could make sports titles that sports junkies have been dreaming of since the Wii's motion controls were announced. I am talking about full one-to-one movement in a baseball game, life-like free-throw shooting, glove saves in a hockey game -- everything we only dreamed would be possible when we were kids watching Back to the Future II (I still cannot believe the Cubs won the World Series in that movie, how unrealistic).

Nintendo could essentially change the entire sporting landscape by rebranding its "N Sports" line, last seen in the N64 days, and provide high-quality triple-A sports games once again.

Renewed Interest

The biggest test for Nintendo will come later this year when Punch-Out!! Wii releases a little before Fight Night Round 4. Only time will tell how well Nintendo does against a more "simulation" licensed title, but I have a feeling that Punch-Out!! will outsell FNR4 by a pretty large margin.

I know this will have a lot to do with the Wii having a larger install base than both 360 and PS3 -- and many will claim it is because Punch-Out!! is more "kiddie friendly" or arcade -- but it can not be denied that this could be a solid barometer for how successful Nintendo could be competing against other sports developers. As an avid Fight Night fan and a complete Punch-Out!! geek, I will be picking both games up, but I can almost guarantee that Punch-Out!! will be getting playtime long after my copy of Fight Night hits the dreaded dust-filled shelf.

It may be a long shot to see Nintendo completely re-enter the mainstream sports-gaming market in the near future, but I for one would welcome the company with open arms. The current state of sports gaming is getting stale, but if Nintendo got involved, it would help me get over the sports-gaming blahs.


Member Comments
# 1 SBartlett @ 03/26/09 04:51 PM
kool
 
# 2 smokeyvol @ 03/27/09 09:35 AM
I'm 50/50 on this.... Next gen sports games are taking over.

IMO kids will still enjoy the Wii sports/"N Sports" line games but true hardcore sports gamers want next gen and killer graphics!
 
# 3 DC @ 03/27/09 09:40 AM
No real sports gamer gives a damn about Nintendo.
 
# 4 WatchdogXC @ 03/27/09 09:59 AM
I would be interested to see Nintendo bring back the Nintendo Pennant Chase MLB game that was canceled on the GameCube. I'd love to see a MLB sim with wii controls done right.
 
# 5 Peninc @ 03/27/09 10:23 AM
couldnt have said it better
 
# 6 The Gird @ 03/27/09 11:28 AM
The Nentendo sports games are fun to bust out every once and while, but honestly, they really don't compare to what is going on with sports gaming these days. Solid article though. Just don't really think any of those games would garner much attention from our sports gaming community on a regular basis. IMO.
 
# 7 Bumble14 @ 03/27/09 03:27 PM
I think that is a very shortsighted statement DC. In fact, I couldn't disagree with you more on it.

Anyone who is a diehard, "real", sportsgamer shows a lot of respect to Nintendo for what they've contributed to the genre as a whole. Without Nintendo there wouldn't be any console gaming. Have a little respect to the elder consoles that started this whole sports gaming trend we enjoy today.

I'm also not really understanding the notion that people would not be interested in a solid Nintendo Wii sports title because "Next Gen games are taking over". Why does it matter?

A solid sports title is a solid sports title. It shouldn't matter how good the graphics of a game are, or how realistic the sweat beads off a players forehead- the only thing that should matter is rock solid gameplay. That's what the article is all about- because Nintendo is all about solid gameplay- and maybe all of us serious sports gamers should stop being so enamored with the aesthetics mentioned above, and start focusing back on core gameplay.
 
# 8 zzyzx @ 03/30/09 01:53 AM
I think the point of the article was that, as a developer rather than a console manufacturer, Nintendo's record for quality control absolutely shames that of certain other devs *cough* 2k *cough*.

The GC wasn't a generation behind the PS2. Next time around, if Nintendo is competing on anything close to a level playing field w/ Sony and M$, it would be nice to see Ninty make a serious effort at a non-cartoon sports title.

I would agree, but there are a lot of "if"s in that short paragraph. It's too soon to bother thinking about, IMO.
 
# 9 punkologist @ 03/30/09 06:50 PM
I have never played a better Cricket game since super international cricket on the snes and Aussie Rules on the nes is still the best ever Aussie rules football game.
 
# 10 SouthernBrick @ 03/31/09 02:59 AM
Nintendo sucks all around now... I would get a wii but the only games i would get for it would be mario(classic) and that tennis game That looks like it would take some energy. but overall the nintendo sucks gamers don't need it.

Maybe children need it but they don't know better they just want something colorful, fun, and easy to play. Anyone at least 14 and up would agree that the wii blows.

If mario was on the xbox or ps3 there would be hardly no one playing the wii that would know a good game when they seen one.
 
# 11 allBthere @ 03/31/09 11:03 AM
I actually really want a nintendo DS. I hope it stays relevant for another couple of years because I'm picking one up soon.
 
# 12 DC @ 04/01/09 07:10 AM
Put it this way, I haven't bought a Sports game for a Nintendo system since SNES. Except for Wrestling, but that is something of its own.

When I think of Nintendo, I do not think of sports. Me saying that is not disrespecting the history of Nintendo, it is just saying that they aren't up to date when it comes to producing sports games. They know they can't compete so they go down the fun route.

Again, any real sports game isn't thinking about buying sports games for a Nintendo system
 
# 13 ab2c4 @ 04/06/09 11:21 AM
Nintendo is perfectly fine with/for kids. I know when my son gets old enough to play video games the Wii is the firt system he will be playing on. For somebody like myself who is 38, no, simply no to Nintendo sports and consoles.
 
# 14 maryandy111 @ 04/07/09 01:58 AM
I would like to see a Major League Baseball Games are to do the control. I hope the coming quickly!
 

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.