Home
Feature Article
Despite Flaws, NCAA 09 a Great Experience

Sometimes, you play a game and it just feels right. While there may be a few annoying bugs and a few quirks about a game, it still doesn't diminish your overall opinion of that game.

I felt this once already this year with MLB '08: The Show. I have seen more strange little bugs and have had a few fairly "out of this world" experiences with that game. But I also truly believe it is this year’s best sports game to date.

As a writer and reviewer of some titles, I cannot take the promise of a future patch into consideration when issuing a score on a game, just like the NFL could not hand the Patriots the Lombardi trophy just because they were favored to win. However, I can say that when the time comes for the end of the year awards, a patched NCAA Football 09 on my little PS3 could be in the running for the Game of the Year.

Most of the issues out of the box can be band-aided with a right set of slider settings, but it's hard to discount the game favors the offense heavily right out of the box.


As it stands right now, NCAA Football 09 is a game which is extremely fun to play and as such warrants a high review score. While there is just enough wrong with the gameplay out of the box to hold it back from receiving a 9 or higher, I would give it a score some where just below that mark if I were the one reviewing the game.

Most of the issues out of the box can be band-aided with a right set of slider settings, but it's hard to discount the game favors the offense heavily right out of the box.

I am already almost finished with year two of my dynasty, and I have only had the game for two days. Even though I am getting older (in my early 20s), I cannot remember playing that much NCAA just after its release.

Overall, the Playstation 3 version of the game runs similar to its counterpart on the 360 and looks very similar as well. I would bet both versions with an HDMI output into my 42" TV would look rather similar if they were running side by side. As with most sports games, the choice on which console you want to play on simply rests on which online service you prefer.

 


Playing in the ACC for the first time has been very rewarding thus far.


Speaking of online play, I have logged just two games in thus far and both were score-fests to the highest order. Both games were frustrating, yet fun experiences. Frustrating because my defense couldn't manage a stop minus a turnover, but also fun because the games were close and you just knew the next play could be "it." EA was touting this to be the main goal for this year's title and I would have to say they accomplished their mission.

In single player Dynasty mode, with some slider tweaks to the kicking power and accuracy as well as to some other variables, I have managed to get an NCAA which I am getting very realistic scores and very realistic results. So far, losing just means I made the wrong calls at the wrong time. I have never felt cheated and my losses have never felt cheap.

This doesn't sound huge but it is, and I feel it encompasses what NCAA Football 09 is all about, the little things


Dynasty mode itself has not been improved drastically like last year, but it has been given a facelift making it very accessible to all players. Instead of having to tediously do all of the recruiting yourself or blindly let the computer take a whack at recruiting, you can set a strategy and let the computer follow it. This doesn't sound huge but it is, and I feel it encompasses what NCAA Football 09 is all about, the little things.

The one big complaint I have about the gameplay is the AI does not stretch the field with deep passes. A patch will most likely change this down the road, but right now this issue is the single biggest thing keeping NCAA from being so much better.

Stretching the field is something that should be done rarely, but also enough to keep you honest as a defensive coach. If a team can't stretch the field, they should get shut down by good defenses. The action in the trenches is another thing that needs to be tweaked. Right now, AI controlled linemen seem to have a bit of an advantage over their human controlled counterparts.

NCAA Football is a fun and dynamic game which is just a small step away from being a historically great game.


Many would argue that if all of these issues are in the game, NCAA doesn't deserve a high score, but they could not be any more wrong. NCAA Football 09 is not a revolutionary title. EA did not reinvent the wheel with the game. Instead, EA went back to the basics, got the tackling engine down and also managed to throw in a lot of new little things to make the game as a whole a much better experience over last year's game.

Last week, I said that if you wanted to sacrifice some realism for some fun you should buy NCAA. I still agree with that after playing nearly 30 games. NCAA Football is a fun and dynamic game which is just a small step away from being a historically great game.

This article is also featured on Bleacher Report. Bleacher Report is where the sports bar meets the press box, the place for fan-journalists to create and critique high-quality sports analysis. Visit Bleacher Report for more video games news.


NCAA Football 09 Videos
Member Comments
# 1 gsugators @ 07/19/08 04:11 PM
You could not have said it any better, I absolutely love this game.
 
# 2 CAJUN COMMISH @ 07/19/08 04:14 PM
I love the game. Just wish you could have the option to NOT use HFA in an online game and that passing was a little harder (lower QB comp %)
 
# 3 duffman @ 07/19/08 04:23 PM
agreed. the game certainly has its flaws (every game does, at least when it comes to sports), but i've found a slider set that seems to work so far to tweak some of the on field problems. wish the cpu deep ball was more of a threat, but i really cant remember the last game where it was. anyway, all i know is i'm having fun playing, and i don't find myself looking at the game clock thinking "it's only the 1st quarter still?" and just wanting it to end asap like i have in previous years of ncaa/madden.
 
# 4 PaperLantern @ 07/19/08 04:28 PM
Definitely one of the best football games I've played.
 
# 5 Sabin @ 07/19/08 05:56 PM
This game is great if you like playing offence and scoring a lot of points.

However to anyone that likes playing defence, or a sim style game its a slap in the face.

And I think saying this game is a few small things away from greatness is a huge overstatement.
 
# 6 debella @ 07/19/08 06:52 PM
I absolutely love this game, especially online play. Me and brother battle constantly, and have been for years. I agree with everything you said in your article. One other note you really need to understand how to run a defense to stop the offense this year. Im 30 yrs old and a former div 2 safety, and it took me a couple of games to understand it, but i'll make the computer punt at least 5 or 6 times in a 6 min game on heisman using penn st.
 
# 7 Tengo Juego @ 07/19/08 06:59 PM
Its getting better. I don't think the game is a 9. The issues hold it back. And I cant believe how they say defense is fun in all the trailers and interviews. Yeah, I guess if you enjoy giving up every 10 yard out/in route or quick slant and then having to hope your defender isn't a victim of a highlight stick murdering then sure, Its fun. I also don't like the idea of every pass my DB can get to being an int. Thats not fun nor realistic.

It seems too wide open in the sense that things like picks, or picks for 6, big runs, and deep routes going for a score are too possible and too frequent. But like you said slider settings can help improve that problem. Overall I enjoy NCAA...offline.
 
# 8 g2thecore @ 07/19/08 07:02 PM
The game is fun but far from a "great" football experience. I'm hoping that Madden 09 can provide a better football fix. I can honestly say that the defensive issues are a big issue with me when it comes to appreciating the game. I'm really starting to get tired of my db's and linebackers just giving up big plays up the middle. Whether you control the linebackers are not, whether you play zone or man....the middle of the field is virtually automatic. I can deal with the other issues the game has, but as a defensive player, I'm not loving this at all.
 
# 9 Tengo Juego @ 07/19/08 07:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sabin
This game is great if you like playing offence and scoring a lot of points.

However to anyone that likes playing defence, or a sim style game its a slap in the face.

And I think saying this game is a few small things away from greatness is a huge overstatement.
I REALLY enjoy defense. But like you say, this year I am slapped in the face.
 
# 10 TheDutchDad @ 07/19/08 07:15 PM
[quote=dbrandon;2038519048

PS: the guy at the gamestop where I got the game said they have had more of this years game returned then any year he could remember over the last few year so at least it's not just me.[/QUOTE]

Jeez...If I had a dollar for everytime I heard that on these forums for any given game, I'd be rich. Somehow every game is "returned at a greater rate than any other year," according to every ones local gamestop.
 
# 11 sportyguyfl31 @ 07/19/08 07:23 PM
Is there some law that reviewers cannot just come out and say : "This game just flat out aint that good people" ??

I mean really, is it that hard?
 
# 12 LingeringRegime @ 07/19/08 07:27 PM
Chirs, which sliders are you using to yield your "realistic results?" Just wondering because I am still looking to find a set that does this.
 
# 13 Hey_Rebby @ 07/19/08 07:27 PM
If EA wants to make an Arcade, offensive shoot-out game, I'm fine with that. All I'm asking is they make the sliders work, so people like me can have a realistic game.
 
# 14 Mhancock @ 07/19/08 07:49 PM
Deep pass withstanding, this is the best college game I've played!!! I am a true Madden-head and have never bought a college game when it was released until now(I miss football/hate baseball). I don't have a problem playing good defense, and the dynasty mode IS better just from the recruiting facial. I've never had more fun prepping for Madden than this year!!!
 
# 15 FORMULA316 @ 07/19/08 08:35 PM
Quote:
Most of the issues out of the box can be band-aided with a right set of slider settings, but it's hard to discount the game favors the offense heavily right out of the box.
- Chris Sanner

Thanks Chris - please post your slider set

Not sure how this game is getting better with all the flaws now coming
up via online dynasties. When will EA Sports patch these problems?
 
# 16 RAZRr1275 @ 07/19/08 08:39 PM
I like this game too. I would like to see your sliders too. Also which team are you running with?
 
# 17 bkrich83 @ 07/19/08 08:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mercurial23
Jeez...If I had a dollar for everytime I heard that on these forums for any given game, I'd be rich. Somehow every game is "returned at a greater rate than any other year," according to every ones local gamestop.
LOL, you beat me to it. I was just going to say that we hear how Game X is the most returned game ever at EBGames/Gametstop.
 
# 18 mgoblue678 @ 07/19/08 09:12 PM
Sure if you enjoy no defense and offensive football the game is great but since I prefer a sim style of football this game is useless to me at the current moment. I have adjusted sliders all I can but no sliders can fix some of the holes in this game. For example this video was with pass blocking at 0 and human break block at 100
http://www.easportsworld.com/en_US/video/39643

Yep that's realistic.

I guess EA wants to catar to people who prefer arcade style football this year therefore screwing over the people who prefer a sim style. What will they do next year to neuter the defense even more, make the defense play with one less player.
 
# 19 bigjigger @ 07/19/08 09:57 PM
...my only 2 problems with this game are the roster bug, and the sliders being all sorts of messed up... fix these two things and i can make it work
 
# 20 MizzouRah @ 07/19/08 10:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgoblue678
Sure if you enjoy no defense and offensive football the game is great but since I prefer a sim style of football this game is useless to me at the current moment. I have adjusted sliders all I can but no sliders can fix some of the holes in this game. For example this video was with pass blocking at 0 and human break block at 100
http://www.easportsworld.com/en_US/video/39643

Yep that's realistic.

I guess EA wants to catar to people who prefer arcade style football this year therefore screwing over the people who prefer a sim style. What will they do next year to neuter the defense even more, make the defense play with one less player.
That's brutal...
 

« Previous1234567Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.