Home
Feature Article
Two Big Releases Reveal Trends in Gaming

This week, I want to start out my article with a bit of a trivia game. I want you to guess which video games I am talking about in the following paragraphs.

First off is a game that was a huge hit on the PS2 and XBox. Its latest release garnered tons hoopla and the reviews all came back overwhelmingly positive. However, it did not do anything new or innovative on the gameplay front. In fact, there was a ton of features stripped out of the game, giving consumers a better looking but dumbed down version of a last generation game.

The second game I am thinking of was also a huge hit on the PS2 and XBox. Its release also garnered a ton of hoopla, just like the previous games. Unlike the game in the paragraph above, the reviews were mixed. It too did nothing overwhelmingly new or innovative, as it too stripped out a ton of features from the last generation of the game. In essence, it gave us a better looking but dumbed down version of the last generation game.

Which games am I talking about?

If you answered Grand Theft Auto and Madden respectively, you are correct. Both games had the same premise during development except for one key difference: the core gameplay was largely the same from one generation of consoles to the next, but the focus on the little things led one game to get rave reviews while the other was left with a mixed bag of reactions.

After playing through Grand Theft Auto I was left with a been there done that feeling in terms of the gameplay. The reason was simple, the game was at its core, essentially the same game I had played on the PS2 and XBox. However, some cool features were missing and the game itself was much smaller and less grandiose. Sound familiar?

Both development teams chose to dumb down the entire game experience in order to get the basics of the games onto more powerful consoles. Both games sacrificed cool features for the sake of time and functionality. In the end, both games presented a very similar experience to the one you had with the previous generation of consoles, just with a bit more glitz and glamor this time around

The difference? Grand Theft Auto used the little things to create a more immersive and more sound gameplay experience. This use of the little things resulted in the game's hailing as an innovative title that was possibly the best ever.

I think it's important to note that we have not seen any real innovation with this generation of games, especially in comparison to the previous generations of consoles.

When we went from the SNES to the PS1 for example, you moved from mostly 2D games into 3D. That was a huge leap in terms of games as it changed how we played games and how we interacted with them.

The PS1 to the PS2 was an equally huge leap, taking the 3D experience to a whole new level. The gameplay innovations that were accomplished were just enormous compared to the previous generation. You were simply playing much better and more well rounded games.

The PS2 to the PS3 (Or the XBox to the 360)? I would venture to say this generation of games has been more focused on cinematic quality and more well-rounded graphics -- going for the realism angle; thereby focusing less on making the core gameplay experience more innovative.

In this day and age games are going to improve year to year, not based solely on innovating the gameplay functionality, but by improving the little things to immerse us more.

Think about it: Grand Theft Auto did this and got rave reviews while Madden didn't. Neither game messed with the core "tried and true formula" they had in the previous generations; they both simply tried to evolve.

This year it seems like EA is finally getting with the program -- starting with its '09 lineup of sports titles. Instead of trying to reinvent the wheel, EA is instead choosing to try to improve the overall experience by adding more detail and thus, depth to the experience. This is a trend that is hopefully starting with NCAA and Madden and will hopefully continue with the rest of the titles in the lineup.

There are only so many ways you can tweak the defensive back AI in Madden. Sooner or later you have to start adding other things to continue improving the game. Adding small details to games to create a more immersive experience is an important trend, which I believe you will continue to see in the coming years.

What this means for sports gaming is simple: don't expect brand new experiences within the core gameplay of games any time soon. What you should begin to expect is improvements to the game in ways that may not directly change the gameplay -- minus making it seem more real.

Another aspect of sports games that will benefit from this shift will be the franchise or dynasty modes of games. You will probably see developers try to add more modes to games to add new gameplay experiences as well. Things like improved drafting, better trades and job markets will probably creep into games in the near future.

The days of sports games adding anything new or groundbreaking to the gameplay are probably over. At this point, there is not that much that can be added in terms of features like the Hit Stick, hot routes, etc. that have not already been added. In the end, expect these features to continue to evolve and improve over time. It's the future of gaming.


Member Comments
# 1 thmst30 @ 06/25/08 01:34 PM
Hopefully your right. Its the little details that EA has completely ignored for years, and it makes games like GTA IV and The Show seem miles ahead. They should NEVER stop focusing on gameplay, but they need to start focusing on the immersion level of their games, because right now they are seriously lacking.
 
# 2 texbuk84 @ 06/25/08 03:54 PM
agreed
 
# 3 spankdatazz22 @ 06/25/08 04:20 PM
Nice article but disagree. Now that EA is paying attention to the little things - four years into next gen - it's now a "trend"? Part of what made GTA popular last gen was it's attention to little details. And there have been many sports development houses outside of EA that have long placed focus on "little details" - even when many Madden fans were arguing it wasn't necessary. I wouldn't even say what EA's doing with Madden now is paying attention to detail. Madden's so-so reviews so far next gen are well deserved - if anything it deserved worse because it was a noticeable step down from what the last gen game was. And is. The jury's still out on whether this year's game will play better than it's last gen counterpart - that's ridiculous.

Outside of the graphics - which look great - the game is receiving kudos for simply being competent. While I agree we're unlikely to see the huge gameplay advancements of the PS1-era games to PS2-era, there's innovation to be had. I'm sure the sandbox genre will evolve, and likely evolve at a faster clip simply because competition will dictate that it occur. Madden will continue to evolve, but likely at a much slower pace because it has no such competition.
 
# 4 slickdtc @ 06/25/08 11:37 PM
This article is kind of common sense, which gets lost in all the BS that we get fed. For some reason, the "mainstream" wants all the fluff and gimmicks while the "hardcore" gamers want smart AI and useful features. How this ever became the norm is beyond me, but that's what we've always been told.

I don't know if I'm in the minority here, but I'd be absolutely stoked to play a game that played like the sports we see on TV. AI that had any type of brains and wasn't programmed to do the same thing, over and over.

If I'm not mistaken, Madden 09 claims to be the "first game that reacts to you" or something along those lines. That's a step in the right direction, but we need to see results and not just a tagline. If I'm doing the same thing over and over, I want to see the AI adjust to that. And same for them... if they keep doing the same thing over and over, I adjust to them and I want to see them adjust to my adjustments.

These next generation consoles haven't given us crap except for more and more fluff. We still have piss poor AI because we got all the goodies that the "mainstream" wants. Hopefully, as we get past the oooh'ing and ahhh'ing at the cool new graphics we can get down into the meat and potatoes and get some serious sports games to come out. But only if we as the consumers demand it by not buying into these roster update sports games we get yearly.
 
# 5 acarrero @ 06/26/08 02:26 AM
I believe you're correct about the first part - that this generation games will focus much more on details than revolutionary new gameplay. However, the days of sports games adding nothing new to gameplay are definitely not over, unless you only consider Xbox360/PS3 generation games.

By the 720/PS4 generation, I think we will see significant improvements in the core gameplays. Lets not forget about the innovation of the Wii. Sure, playing something like NCAA on the Wii is a joke now, but down the line more serious systems will improve on what the Wii started.

I can imagine Madden 2030 - it's basically a virtual world where u feel like you are actually on the field, where you literally hear and feel the roar of the crowd, where your brain associates certain motions in the controls with what will feel like running on a field. You will have Brady's arm strength when you control him (classic teams of course), or the strength of The Bus - in fact you will look at your arm and it will look like the Jerome Bettis' arm. Obviously, the possibilities are endless if you look that far down the line.
 
# 6 mercalnd @ 06/26/08 10:17 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by slickdtc
If I'm not mistaken, Madden 09 claims to be the "first game that reacts to you" or something along those lines. That's a step in the right direction, but we need to see results and not just a tagline. If I'm doing the same thing over and over, I want to see the AI adjust to that. And same for them... if they keep doing the same thing over and over, I adjust to them and I want to see them adjust to my adjustments.
NHL 08 did that pretty well so even if Madden has this their tag line of being the first game to adapt to you wouldn't hold true. It would still be a big step in the right direction though.
 
# 7 slickdtc @ 06/26/08 11:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mercalnd
NHL 08 did that pretty well so even if Madden has this their tag line of being the first game to adapt to you wouldn't hold true. It would still be a big step in the right direction though.
Yeah, that tagline from Madden (I saw it it one of the earliest trailers for Madden 09) definitely was false because other games have claimed to have the same thing, like NHL 08. The problem is, did it really work? One constant complaint I've heard is passive defensive AI. Consistently. The AI might adjust to how you play defense, but their defense continues to allow you to walk right into the zone and set up your offense. It's in there, it's just not correct.

Which is why I think we're going in the right direction, and now is the perfect time to see great improvements. We're what, 3 or 4 years into this generation of systems. The first couple were to get all the old stuff into these versions. Now that that's out of the way, what else is there? Roster updates and... gameplay. They have to bear down and make some serious improvements and innovations to the gameplay. It might not be sexy and consumer friendly, but damn it, if you have a good game chances are people are going to be attracted to that! Even the casual gamers want a good playing game, even though they aren't as hardcore with everything as the serious gamers are. Yes, casual gamers are more likely to be attracted to sexy graphics, but all these games are pretty close in their visuals. The first game that finally "gets it" will be the next NFL 2k5, MVP 05... those types of games that people still play today because they were so revolutionary (not for all, obviously, but for a majority of people that was the benchmark of the old generation).

And speaking of those games, check out their year. Right near the end of the PS2/XBOX generation. The developers finally pieced it all together and came out with something that was just right. We might be 2-3 years away from that game coming out, but it'll come and you'll know it it when you play it.
 

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.