Home
Feature Article
Fresh Look at an Old Feature: Fantasy Draft

Following the introduction of Franchise Mode by EA Sports in 1998, the line between football game and football simulation quickly became blurred. Was the object of the game to play consecutive seasons and see how successful the individual, as a player, could be? Or was the object to simulate the games themselves in order to see how effective the individual could be at performing the tasks of a general manager?

This article aims to shed light on the forgotten foundation of the Madden Franchise Mode -- playing the game -- by supporting a fresh take on this constantly evolving feature. Read on to gain insight and tips into building your own successful expansion franchise.

 

 

The line between player/coach and general manager continues to be blurred in the present day with users now having control over scouting, the salary cap, and even how much money to extort from their loyal virtual fan base for a lukewarm hot dog. Recently it seems the Franchise Mode has been built for those who wish to try their hand at managing a football team rather than playing as the football team.  

The first step when creating your own expansion franchise is creating the team itself. Through the “Create-A-Team” feature in Madden NFL 08, you truly can create your team from the ground up. You give your team a name, build its stadium, and even detail the jerseys the players will be wearing come game day.

While this gives you a great level of control over your team, it is also largely cosmetic so I will not delve too deeply into it. I will simply say that after about ten minutes of messing around with jersey colors and stadium layouts, my Harrisburg Hawks -- with their open-ended stadium and pea-green jerseys -- were gaining an identity.

With the team itself created, the goal now becomes acquiring players willing to take the field in Gov. Edward G. Rendell’s capital, and this is where the fun begins. Anyone could go ahead and pack their team full of stars, and sure, the temptation is there. After all, who wouldn’t want to see Peyton Manning tossing the ball around at will to Antonio Gates, Marvin Harrison, Steve Smith, and Chad Johnson while handing off to LaDainian Tomlinson in the backfield? That would be a definitive nightmare for defensive coordinators. The defense?  Ed Reed, Troy Polamalu, Champ Bailey, Brian Urlacher, and Shawne Merriman aren’t going to allow too many touchdowns, but wouldn’t that kind of dominance get old rather quickly?

Of course it would, and that type of dominance just doesn’t happen in the NFL; especially, when the team is an expansion team in its first season. These expansion teams generally have 53 man rosters filled with youthful potential and mediocre veteran talent. But once again, who wants to play with a team whose star contributors are players like Jonathan Wells and Billy Miller, right Texans fans?

Therefore, a balance needs to be found in between stacking a team and playing entirely with young or flat-out bad players. Thankfully this balance can be strategically reached by starting a new franchise with your created team, while turning the option to have a fantasy draft on. In order to load your created team, however, you will unfortunately have to replace a current NFL team. I suggest replacing whichever team holds the least significance to you. I replaced the Arizona Cardinals because, well, when is the last time anything good happened in Arizona? They don’t deserve a franchise. Sorry Cards fans.

Now we must establish a few ground rules. First, don’t make Hall of Fame players available in the fantasy draft. It will make your job in creating a stellar team way too easy, as well as present the near-impossible task of stopping Barry Sanders from running freely through the league again. Second, and this is the number one key that strikes that balance between having average-to-good players while maintaining the fun in playing the games: all the players you select must be no older than 24! 

By taking this course of action, your team will have strengths and weaknesses but, given the age of your players, your team will also gradually improve so long as you play the game the right way. Again, I must stress that this is not an endeavor for those who enjoy simulating season after season, but rather a realistically challenging endeavor for those who enjoy playing the game. This foray into a new, relatively unexplored realm will most likely leave your team painfully average at almost every position, forcing you to choose your plays judiciously and have patience in your execution.

If I could offer any tips for a successful fantasy draft as you dive into the fountain of youth in the NFL, it would be, first and foremost, to keep an eye on what the competition is doing. You may see a big-ticket wide receiver you’d love to select, but if it's quarterbacks that are being picked up in rapid succession, that may be an ill-advised move.

Be aware that there are certain positions where skilled, youthful players are difficult to come by. At the center position, for example, Nick Mangold can adequately block along any offensive line, but the options behind him represent steep drop-offs in skill. 

Also realize that there are players who may be listed at a certain position but could very easily prove to be useful at others -- should you choose to change their role once drafted. For example, Haloti Ngata may be an effective defensive end in a 3-4 defense, but in a 4-3 he can also be a stellar DT. 

Lastly, enclosed hereafter to help you draft your star players is my ranking of the top five athletes under the age of 24 at each position, followed by the depth chart of the Harrisburg Hawks so that you may measure your draft up against that of yours truly. I wish you the best of luck in creating your own expansion franchise and hope that, in following the now ancient practice of actually playing franchise games instead of simulating them, success will find you sooner than it has found the Houston Texans.

 Position Player Name Overall
 QB  Philip Rivers  89
   Vince Young  88
   Jay Cutler  85
   Matt Leinart  84
   Alex Smith  83
 HB  Stephen Jackson  96
   Frank Gore  93
   Willis McGahee  92
   Reggie Bush  89
   Maurice Jones-Drew  89
 FB  John Kuhn  82
   Lawrence Vickers  82
   Mike Bell  80
   Oliver Hoyte  79
   David Kirtman  79
 WR  Larry Fitzgerald  95
   Roy Williams  92
   Calvin Johnson  89
   Marques Colston  89
   Braylon Edwards  87
 TE  Kellen Winslow  94
   Vernon Davis  88
   Greg Olsen  88
   Heath Miller  86
   Owen Daniels  83
 LT  Marcus McNeil  94
   D'Brickashaw Ferguson  87
   Joe Thomas  83
   Winston Justice  77
   Tony Ugoh  76
 LG  Ryan Lilja  89
   Todd Herremans  85
   Rob Sims  84
   Jason Brown  82
   Justin Blalock  80
 C  Nick Mangold  89
   Pat Ross  73
   Samson Satele  72
   Ben Wilkerson  72
   Doug Datish  72
 RG  Shawn Andrews  96
   Davin Joseph  87
   Justin Smiley  86
   Jahri Evans  83
   Richie Incognito  82
 RT  Shane Olivea  86
   Alex Barron  85
   Levi Brown  81
   Joe Staley  80
   Jeremy Trueblood  79
 LE  Luis Castillo  92
   Tamba Hali  86
   Robert Geathers  83
   Marcus Spears  82
   Jamaal Anderson  80
 RE  Mario Williams  86
   Mark Anderson  86
   Trent Cole  85
   Haloti Ngata  84
   Elvis Dumervil  83
 DT  Tommie Harris  98
   Dewayne Robertson  86
   Brodrick Bunkley  82
   Adam Carricker  82
   Barry Cofield  82
 LOLB  Derrick Johnson  90
   Thomas Davis  86
   Leroy Hill  85
   Michael Boley  82
   Manny Lawson  81
 MLB  Lofa Tatupu  95
   Demeco Ryans  89
   Patrick Willis  85
   Barrett Ruud  84
   Ahmad Brooks  82
 ROLB  Shawne Merriman  96
   A.J. Hawk  90
   Ernie Sims  88
   Kamerion Wimbley  86
   Channing Crowder  86
 CB  Deangelo Hall  92
   Nathan Vasher  92
   Chris Gamble  88
   Ellis Hobbs  84
   Johnathan Joseph  84
 FS  Sean Taylor  90
   Madieu Williams  88
   Gibril Wilson  86
   Josh Bullocks  84
   Brodney Pool  83
 SS  Dawan Landry  88
   Donte Whitner  88
   Antoine Bethea  86
   Michael Huff  86
   Laron Landry  85
 K  Robbie Gould  92
   Stephen Gostkowskis  82
   Mason Crosby  81
   Dave Rayner  80
   Shaun Suisham  79
 P  Ryan Plackemeier  87
   Jon Ryan  81
   Daniel Sepulveda  81
   Steve Weatherford  80
   Adam Podlesh  79
 Position Player Name  Overall 
 QB  Vince Young  84
   Kevin Kolb  74
   Troy Smith  69
 HB  Reggie Bush  89
   Lendale White  78
   Brian Calhoun  72
 FB  Dominique Byrd  TE-to-FB 85
 WR  Calvin Johnson  89
   Greg Jennings  85
   Maurice Stovall  79
   Matt Jones  77
   Jacoby Jones  73
 TE  Anthony Fasano  79
   Tony Scheffler  74
 LT  D'Brickashaw Ferguson  87
   Mario Henderson  69
 LG  Todd Herremans  85
   Manuel Ramirez  72
   Chris Morris  66
 C  Nick Mangold  89
   Nick Cole  64
 RG  Davin Joseph  87
   Manuel Ramirez  74
   Chris Morris  68
 RT  Eric Winston  78
   Zach Strief  65
 LE  Matt Roth  79
   Jarvis Moss  79
 RE  Mario Williams  86
   Melvin Oliver  74
 DT  Adam Carriker  82
   Barry Cofield  82
   Derek Landri  70
   Jonathan Babineaux  70
 LOLB  Chad Greenway  83
   Brandon Chillar  77
   Stewart Bradley  70
 MLB  Ahmad Brooks  82
   Brandon Siler  70
   Chase Blackburn  60
 ROLB  Shawne Merriman  96
   Brandon Chillar  73
   Stewart Bradley  66
 CB  Deangelo Hall  92
   Johnathan Joseph  84
   Domonique Foxworth  79
   Travis Daniels  79
   Dimitri Patterson  69
 FS  Sean Taylor  90
   Matt Giordano  69
 SS  Antoine Bethea  86
   Matt Giordano  66
 K  Nick Folk  76
 P  Ryan Plackmeier  87