Home
Feature Article
Are Console-Like Gaming PCs A Good Choice for Sports Gamers?

Like it or not, the "next" generation of consoles are now the "current" generation as the PS4 and Xbox One have become the new standard. Most, if not all, of the coverage from E3 will be focused on games for those two consoles -- as well as personal computers.

Console-like gaming PCs are become popular, and cheaper, ahead of Valve's official Steam machine. But are these machines, like the Alienware Alpha, a good fit for sports gamers? Here are a few pros and cons to ponder if you are considering purchasing this type of machine for your sports action.

Price

I recently bought the base model Alienware Alpha for just above $300, thanks to a nice rebate/sale combination I found online. This does not offer a significant savings over buying an Xbox One ($350) or PS4 ($400), at least on the surface. However, what's included in that price does increase the value a bit.

First, in addition to a decent performing game machine, I do have the added benefit of a full-featured Windows 8 machine. Now, I don't plan on doing my taxes or sending emails from my couch, but it is an option. It also provides a great alternative to web-browsing, at least compared to the built-in browsers found on most consoles.

Further savings can be factored in when you look at the games. My Steam library is pretty big, mostly filled with games I bought during sales or through programs like Humble Bundle. So, upon firing up the PC, I already had a library of over 100 titles, along with the knowledge of an ongoing Steam Summer Sale. Face it, even with the best PS Flash Sales or Xbox Gold prices, it's hard to beat a Steam sale for deep discounts.

Games

When the Xbox 360 was announced, I was very happy to read about backwards compatibility, an option that never fully materialized. I actually ended up re-buying an original Xbox, just to play gems like MVP 2005.

This is not really an issue with a PC unless you run across a title that simply is not compatible with anything post-Windows 95. And, thanks to sites like GOG.com, buying vintages titles is easier and cheaper than ever.

Plus, many of my favorite games, like the Civilization series, never seem to find their way onto consoles (Civ Revolution does not count). The wealth of PC games, outside the sports genre, is a huge benefit.

However, if we are exclusively looking at sports games, the picture is a little dimmer. Outside of text sims and racing games, the PC sports landscape is rather barren. 2K does solid work here porting its major sports games to PC, but FIFA is EA's only routine PC title. In other words, it's still not a given we will see things like Madden or NHL on PCs.

Performance

There's something to owning a console that's easy, in the literal sense of "plug and play." I know that when I put in a game it will (or at least should) work without any effort on my part. Games are optimized for the system. Online gameplay varies only in connection speed. Generally speaking, things are neat and uniform.

PCs, on the other hand, are a bit more messy. As great as Steam is in the grand scheme of things, I've still experienced more crashes in a month of using a gaming PC than in an entire year on a PS4. These are not debilitating or even that annoying; I just usually have to check a setting, adjust and I'm good.

These tweaks are part of the process of using a computer, and for me it's a part I enjoy. I like fiddling and trying to get the best performance out of games. However, I realize that many users want the simple experience, and for that I can't blame them.

That said, I know that many users swear by PCs for their AAA games because they often look better and are able to be modified, which extends their virtual shelf-life. Look at the aforementioned MVP series for an example of what can be done on a PC long after the console version is gone.

Final Thoughts

If you are considering an Alienware, Syber or even the long-awaited Steam Machine then consider the above issues. Do you already have a large Steam library? Do you primarily play Madden, The Show or other titles that aren't regularly available on PC? Will you be happy with a user experience that may require some tweaking?

For me, the console-like PC has been a great companion to, not a replacement for, my PS4 and/or Xbox One. It allows me to play the non-sports games I like on a TV from the comfort of my couch, and it has opened up a vast library of games I might ordinary overlook.

However, until the major titles are available on PC, a true console still needs to be in the sports gamer's living room.


Member Comments
# 1 jpollack34 @ 06/14/15 03:21 PM
Nice article. It’s a great question you guys bring up.

I have personally made the move to PC Gaming last couple of years. And though I have a PS4 (and was predominantly a console gamer last generation 360/PS3/Wii), I find myself turning it on less and less.

The reason: Editing and modding. I honestly don’t think I can go back to consoles and their closed platform. The PC can be frustrating at times, but that comes with any open platform. A platform that allows editing/modding and other such tinkerings will necessarily come with complications because customization is at its core. They go hand in hand.

Does it suck that I can’t play some of the great sports games? Of course. However, I have come to the realization that if modding is not part of the experience, I’m simply not interested.

Thankfully I have been able to quench my sports thirst (I purchased PES and NBA2K on Steam). I also have a heavily modded version of MVP Baseball 2005 for the baseball fix; although Super Mega Baseball is coming to Steam, so I’m looking forward to that. If the modding community gets a hold of that one it could launch that game into legendary status.

I honestly don’t think that a lot of AAA studios in the sports genre are prepared for what’s about to come. I have been saying for a couple of years now that they are ill prepared. They seem to want to hang on to an old model; hoping and praying that things won’t change. Change is inevitable. When Steam hits the living room, with it’s already 100+ million active users (and an estimated 900 million pc gamers), the studios that are ill prepared are going to get a rude awakening. There is going to be an avalanche of independent games hitting the market that will now take advantage of the couch setting (sports being one of the underutilized genres). And now that that Unreal Engine 4 (and other top class engines) is free to use up-front (5% royalty only), the quality over the next 3-5 years of those independent games is going to skyrocket.

The old way of doing things (exclusive licensing deals and using high costs as barrier to entry) are going to go the way of the dodo bird (to be replaced by modding). Listen to bell it tolls for thee.
 
# 2 bxphenom7 @ 06/14/15 03:32 PM
If I get one, which I'm deciding between an Xbox One, it won't be because of sports games, but just for AAA games that will look better.
 
# 3 jmmontoro @ 06/14/15 06:43 PM
The price argument changes dramatically outside the US where consoles most of the times are twice as expensive if not more.
 
# 4 sooperb @ 06/14/15 09:11 PM
Does he mvp series actually look better and better with upgrades?
 
# 5 Sheba2011 @ 06/15/15 01:24 AM
I have both a custom built gaming rig (built by me ) and an Xbox One. Most days I find myself reaching for the Xbox One. As I get older I find its no longer fun to sit crunched in front of a keyboard an mouse and its a lot easier to just sit back with a controller and relax while playing. PC games will always look better and offer the chance at some truly great mods from the community, especially games like Skyrim which with mods is playable forever. But consoles have the better selection of games, especially sports games.
 
# 6 boomhauertjs @ 06/15/15 08:39 AM
I haven't made the jump to PS4/XBONE yet. We also need a new computer, so I'm seriously considering making the move to PC gaming permanently. However, I'd like to be able to play games on my basement TV rather than my PC monitor, so I'm torn whether to get a laptop.
 
# 7 PAPERNUT @ 06/15/15 09:26 AM
Also an Alpha owner since Jan. Wonderful machine for all it does, but does have its pros and cons. Wrote a blog on all those for it. I wanted a compliment to the consoles to get those PC only titles, but once I got into Steam and seen all the sales they have on games, I rarely buy games for the consoles now.
 
# 8 tbennett54 @ 06/15/15 01:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by boomhauertjs
I haven't made the jump to PS4/XBONE yet. We also need a new computer, so I'm seriously considering making the move to PC gaming permanently. However, I'd like to be able to play games on my basement TV rather than my PC monitor, so I'm torn whether to get a laptop.
You can try the Steam Link.
http://store.steampowered.com/universe/link
 
# 9 boomhauertjs @ 06/16/15 09:14 AM
That's interesting. Thanks.

And thanks for this thread. I investigated Alienware and I'm seriously considering picking one up, but probably not until the holiday season:
1) to hopefully find a good deal on one; and
2) for Star Wars Battlefront.

It seems like the Alienware is so small, it wouldn't be too hard to move it between our office and the basement TV. But the Steam Link would save that trouble.
 
# 10 Weisszach @ 06/16/15 09:43 AM
Don't know why but sports games seem to feel more at home on consoles than PCs. Sports games are a major factor of what I play so it will be PS4 for me all day long. The ability of gameplay recording using the PS4 and editing software that comes with it is another draw. True it is never going to be as good as a PC for editing but it is if, like me, you want a simple and quick option then this can't be beat.
 
# 11 CamDMC @ 06/16/15 01:46 PM
I'm thinking about getting one

Sent from my SCH-I435 using Tapatalk
 
# 12 GOBLUE_08 @ 06/20/15 02:19 AM
Currently, no. NBA 2k and Fifa are really your only options at this point as far as sports games. Mlb 2k12 is kinda hard to find and it's expensive if you do find it (Not worth it). MVP 05 is even more expensive and it's honestly long past stale imo. Mods make it tolerable for a while until the nostalgia wears off. And if you've spent any time with the show in recent years then MVP is pretty much unplayable. But if baseball is what your looking for then you may as well just get a PS4. If Ea ever starts to release Madden, NBA Live and NHL on pc again, then I think it becomes worth it IF your looking to buy just for sports. If your just looking for a console alternative then yes it's worth it. Especially if your leaning towards buying an Xbox one. I got my Xbox one for christmas and if it wasn't for my kids it would never see any action. Pc gets pretty much the same games as Xbox minus a few exclusives and the huge Steam sales and library make up for that.

Sent from my VS985 4G using Tapatalk
 

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.