Home
Feature Article
NBA Live 15: Trailer and Features List Reaction (Roundtable)

NBA Live 15 finally showed itself in real action yesterday, as well as debuting its list of features. With about a month to go until release, the hearts and minds aspect of EA's PR campaign has only saw vieled letters of promises released up to this point, giving gamers little to be excited about with this year's title.

But now? Now we have some concrete info, and here are our thoughts on it.

Robert Kollars: Well, you can count me as one who is impressed with what was shown. I played live last year for months, and while it was extremely rough in areas, one could see the potential. Yes, it's easy to doubt this company after the last 5 or 6 years, but that trailer was full of strong attention to detail, authentic looking basketball, and much improved graphics over last year's title. As with many, I still need to see the game in motion with 5-on-5 action, but for me at least, the wait was worth it. Still not overly impressed with the feature list, but in all honesty, I would rather have them working on fixing the gameplay as opposed to worrying about new modes.

Dustin Toms: This might be the best trailer EA has ever released for the NBA Live franchise. The visuals look pretty good, but it's the consistent movement throughout the entire clip that gives you the maybe-they-got-something-right feeling. I like the added animations and the signature celebrations, especially Westbrook's 3-pointer -- that looked awesome. I wish they kept the camera on player's faces longer rather than switch in and out so quickly. EA is really touting facial reactions, so let's see them and dissect them.

It seems as though they've added in a tutorial mode, which was one of the largest gripes in last year's debacle. Perhaps the tutorial will ease gamers into actually being able to play the game and enjoy all of these "new" features. NBA Live Ultimate Team adds an auction house, which has proven to be a time waster with the Madden version. It's always fun collecting and trading to compete with the team that you want to win with. Other than that, I'm not all that excited for the additions to what was horrid gameplay.

In the end, until we see and play NBA Live 15 and know it is in fact playable, this game is dead in the water.

Matthew Coe: Well I'll tell ya what, EA Sports got this new trailer right. From the music to the action shots, the new NBA Live 15 trailer really showcases the improved visuals and some much needed new animations. I think NBA Live 15 may actually be a credible next-gen title as opposed to last year's effort. It seems that development team heard the fans and critics loud and clear and really did focus on making a game that stands out. I'm surprised and impressed.

Now with all of that said, I'm not impressed with the features that we got information on today. For me, I wanted to see a renewed focus on offline franchise mode somewhere in there and I didn't get that. I understand if EA Sports wants to focus on Ultimate Team and online play ahead of the more traditional "hardcore" features, because they've got to differentiate themselves from the competition. Ultimately though, the gameplay will be what draws me to or away from this title and we need to see some 5-on-5, as has been said.

At the very least, I'm interested in NBA Live 15 again and that's something I didn't anticipate.

Chris Sanner: Yawn. You can make NBA Live 14 look like it's a competent basketball game in a teaser trailer, so I'm not going to make any judgements on the gameplay at this point from a series that deserves none of my trust.

What we do see is that the visuals are definitely much improved, far above last year's effort and more on par with what NBA 2K has managed to do. What we don't see is how the actual 5-on-5 gameplay is going to be, and we likely won't for another week or so. The new paint-physics will help the game, as will the improved transistion game. But at the end of the day, this game is touting features the competition already does much better than it did last year, so any improvements are likely only to bring Live on par with certain aspects of 2K.

However, compared to the dumpster fire that was last year's NBA Live, this year is definitely looking to be a step in the right direction. Live simply needs to get the online human vs. human aspect right and nail something like Ultimate Team -- if it can do that, it'll have a future in EA's upcoming release schedules.


NBA Live 15 Videos
Member Comments
# 1 snc237 @ 09/03/14 12:49 PM
Well it has my interest at least. It doesn't have to be as good as 2k, it just has to be good and do things better in areas where 2k does poorly to set it apart. This does look like a big step compared to last year however gameplay will tell all like it always does.
 
# 2 @marcusjiles @ 09/03/14 12:55 PM
I have quite the sneaky suspicion that this will be the only real video we will get. The Live team has been so tight lipped on anything while I'll point to that early demo in a moment, I dont even know if that's still happening. They probably dont either. BUT, IF that early demo is coming... earlier than normal, I dont think they'd put together a 5v5 gameplay video/trailer/whatever. Even this was 50 seconds.

I have had zero reason to trust that they will give us such video, and I think they'll do gameplay looks in the way of blogs. Isolated dribbling in a practice setting. How two players interact w/ each other. They still have NBA Live 14 on there website, and are playing with that game which is odd. But for as much as they're telling you the gameplay is better, I havent heard "fixed" and if that's the main thing you worked on (no additional features really) then it better great. The fact they've been so tight-lipped would speak to it not being so.
 
# 3 23 @ 09/03/14 01:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by snc237
Well it has my interest at least. It doesn't have to be as good as 2k, it just has to be good and do things better in areas where 2k does poorly to set it apart. This does look like a big step compared to last year however gameplay will tell all like it always does.
Why would you accept this game not being the best it can be?

I don't understand this logic one bit. It's like a cop out. They need to be pushed to raise the standard as well as any other game out there.
 
# 4 NoTiCe_O @ 09/03/14 01:03 PM
Well Sean O'Brien did say the Lag online is Gone, like.. Gone. Non-Existent. So that should be a differentiating Factor that should Lead to More Fun and Competitiveness in the Series.
I'm all for the Online, if the Gameplay is Balanced and Fun, with No Exploits ruining the experience then I See myself playing this Game all Year. Plus, I've never played Ultimate Team but I'm all for some Fantasy Basketball and Card Pulling. Which eventually leads to Taking those Cards/Team online, I'm All for it.
 
# 5 champsbasketball @ 09/03/14 01:05 PM
I really liked what I seen in the trailer, we will be getting that new gen look. The main part that is left is 5on5 gameplay Ps4.
 
# 6 Bowinkle08 @ 09/03/14 01:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NoTiCe_O
Well Sean O'Brien did say the Lag online is Gone, like.. Gone. Non-Existent. So that should be a differentiating Factor that should Lead to More Fun and Competitiveness in the Series.
I'm all for the Online, if the Gameplay is Balanced and Fun, with No Exploits ruining the experience then I See myself playing this Game all Year. Plus, I've never played Ultimate Team but I'm all for some Fantasy Basketball and Card Pulling. Which eventually leads to Taking those Cards/Team online, I'm All for it.
lag can never be gone completely. its probably just very minimal that its not noticed.
the trailer looked good. some dunks and animations looked stiff but that can be tweaked. graphics looked on point.
 
# 7 bestout51683 @ 09/03/14 01:10 PM
Live 14 trailer looked just as good so this trailer means nothing.
 
# 8 clipperfan811 @ 09/03/14 01:29 PM
23 I think what snc237 is getting at is that he understands we can't expect Live to be as good as 2k on all fronts (gameplay, graphics, depth modes etc) but if it gets something like the flow of offense right or a better balance between smooth animation and user control with rock solid online play, the game can create a niche for itself this year and a foundation to build on in the future.
 
# 9 NoTiCe_O @ 09/03/14 01:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bowinkle08
lag can never be gone completely. its probably just very minimal that its not noticed.
the trailer looked good. some dunks and animations looked stiff but that can be tweaked. graphics looked on point.
Well little to none is cool w/ Me. Minimal even.
 
# 10 lakers24 @ 09/03/14 02:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bestout51683
Live 14 trailer looked just as good so this trailer means nothing.
That's straight bull. That 14 trailer was TERRIBLE so please don't spout that crap. This looks like night and day compared to that.
 
# 11 RipCityAndy @ 09/03/14 02:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NoTiCe_O
Well little to none is cool w/ Me. Minimal even.
No kidding... that lag was unbearable. Even if it's pared down to something minimal, I'm OK.
 
# 12 NoTiCe_O @ 09/03/14 02:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by RipCityAndy
No kidding... that lag was unbearable. Even if it's pared down to something minimal, I'm OK.
Be Great. See how the Gameplay actually turns out. Hoping it's Good.
 
# 13 _Fernando @ 09/03/14 02:16 PM
I'm going to ask about Dynasty.

What would you like to see added?
 
# 14 NoTiCe_O @ 09/03/14 02:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NBALIVE_Fernando
I'm going to ask about Dynasty.

What would you like to see added?
An Online Version.. Mainly Skill Training and Development, Rookie Scouting with Skill Training, Weekly Recaps, Pricing, Relocation, 1st Quarter, 2nd Quarter Sim Type thing where you can decide when to Jump in. Trophy Room.

Not Really a Dynasty Player but those are some of the things I've Enjoyed over the Years. Online Capability is biggest for me I Like the Real Competition.
 
# 15 _Fernando @ 09/03/14 02:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NoTiCe_O
An Online Version.. Mainly Skill Training and Development, Rookie Scouting with Skill Training, Weekly Recaps, Pricing, Relocation, 1st Quarter, 2nd Quarter Sim Type thing where you can decide when to Jump in. Trophy Room.

Not Really a Dynasty Player but those are some of the things I've Enjoyed over the Years. Online Capability is biggest for me I Like the Real Competition.
Nice. Definitely see some ideas we've been kicking around here.

What do you mean by 'Rookie Scouting with Skill training'?
 
# 16 lakers24 @ 09/03/14 02:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NBALIVE_Fernando
I'm going to ask about Dynasty.

What would you like to see added?
I really don't like doing this, but it's definitely something I feel could be used by this team as well so I'll just give you the link to my thread:

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...ersion-me.html

The miscellaneous things can mostly be bypassed(though I'd like to see award ceremonies and tickers since this would be essential to FA). Pretty much everything else is what I think could take it to the next level.
 
# 17 asu666 @ 09/03/14 02:29 PM
"For me, I wanted to see a renewed focus on offline franchise mode somewhere in there and I didn't get that."

That's the one area I'd like to see more focus on too. The rest of the game looks great so far.
 
# 18 _Fernando @ 09/03/14 02:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lakers24
I really don't like doing this, but it's definitely something I feel could be used by this team as well so I'll just give you the link to my thread:

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...ersion-me.html

The miscellaneous things can mostly be bypassed(though I'd like to see award ceremonies and tickers since this would be essential to FA). Pretty much everything else is what I think could take it to the next level.
Nice write up!

Definitely a tall order in there and some of things can't currently be done. But, as a fan of basketball gaming, I definitely like the points you're making.
 
# 19 lakers24 @ 09/03/14 02:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NBALIVE_Fernando
Nice write up!

Definitely a tall order in there and some of things can't currently be done. But, as a fan of basketball gaming, I definitely like the points you're making.
I figured some things may be difficult, but we have to always try to push the limits for what can be accomplished. A lot is definitely attainable though, and there's a few things I didn't include that I know should be in like 3-team trades and stretch provisions.
 
# 20 NoTiCe_O @ 09/03/14 02:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NBALIVE_Fernando
Nice. Definitely see some ideas we've been kicking around here.

What do you mean by 'Rookie Scouting with Skill training'?
Hmm How can I explain it...

Basically, just using the Learn Live Drills to analyze Rookie Skill, Athleticism, and mainly get a quick synopsis of what you're trying to add to your team. For instance, I been watchin' a guard from Georgetown and I think he has the Passing Skills Necessary to take us to the Next echelon. I bring him in the Fast Break drill to get a Feel for his skills in passing and then I decide if I want him on my team or not..

Edit: As far as playing.. I like it if it's online, if not I get bored with it and eventually play competitive matches until my thumbs get tired or I get Sick of showing my opponents how it's Done... I Joke.
 

« Previous123Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.