Home
Feature Article
Breaking It Down: Who Will Bring College Sports Back?
 
It has been eight months. How much longer do we have to wait?

The sad and unfortunate truth is that nobody knows. College sports have left the video game world and shut the door behind them. When EA Sports announced that they would be discontinuing the NCAA Football series, a significant portion of sports gaming disappeared – just like that. The real question becomes: how much longer are we going to have to wait, and who is going to be the one to bring college sports gaming back?

At first, the list of candidates seems thin. Over the course of sports’ gaming history, there have only been a handful of publishers to put out a college sports title. More recently, it has been even worse. A single publisher (EA Sports) has released a college sports title in the last six years. That said, I have a strange belief that we won’t have to wait that much longer. After looking into putting together a viable list of candidates to bring college sports back to video games, the results were much more profound than you may expect.
 
 
Candidate Number One: The Big Name Publisher

This is the first thing that comes to mind when talking about the revival of gaming in college sports. In fact, the first thing you probably heard after EA announced the cancellation of NCAA was that it opened the door for other publishers to make a game. Sadly, it is not that easy. The lawsuit that EA was roped into was like a big, flashing warning sign to other publishers to stay away from the NCAA.

Oddly, EA Sports themselves are probably the most likely candidate to return to college sports. The NCAA series made EA a significant amount of money, so much so that most assumed EA would take whatever hit they had to in the lawsuit just to keep the series alive. Obviously, that didn’t turn out to be the case. That said, it would be very surprising if EA were not the first one back in line if and when the NCAA is on its way out. With talk of the major conferences separating themselves from the NCAA altogether, it could be sooner rather than later.

Candidate Number Two: The Little Guy

The Little Guy has had a lot of success recently. With games like Minecraft, Flappy Bird, and State of Decay, independent developers have made millions on top of millions of dollars. Consoles and handhelds are becoming increasingly easy to develop games for, and micro-transactions (however controversial) have proven to be a viable form of revenue. Recently, sports titles like Powerstar Golf and the freshly announced return of R.B.I. Baseball have received a chunk of positive reception. Who is to say someone won’t take a shot at a college football or basketball game?

It is important to keep in mind, however, that even if we do see the return of sports gaming by the hands of an independent developer, it would not be a fully-fledged title. With the increasing price of the NCAA license, there’s no way “The Little Guy” could afford a licensing fee. But maybe that would not be such a terrible thing. Consumers, especially here at Operation Sports, have been asking for a fully customizable sports title. An independent developer might be the most likely candidate to give us one.
 

College Lacrosse 2012
 
Candidate Number Three: The Start Up

The video game industry is huge. In fact, it is so huge that according to Forbes, it actually surpassed the film industry way back in 2009. Since then, it has only gotten bigger. More and more often, we are seeing games being built from the ground up. The weird part is that they are starting with no money. That wouldn’t have been possible ten years ago. But now, with websites like Kickstarter, the mere idea of a game is enough to get people to support you with donations. The call for a college sports title is high, and will only get higher the closer we get back to college football season. It might not be so unlikely that someone takes the initiative and puts together a team of developers to make a college sports game.

Candidate Number Four: The Big(ger) Name Publisher

Perhaps the best sign of how things are going in the video game industry was when the sales numbers were released for Microsoft’s Xbox One, and Sony’s Playstation 4. Both sold millions of copies over the course of a month or two, and neither is giving any indication that sales will slow down. That said, the competition between two of the biggest names in gaming is bound to help create new and exciting things. Games like MLB: The Show are stone cold system sellers that can help sway a ton of console purchases one way or the other. When will we see either Microsoft or Sony (or perhaps Nintendo or Valve?) put faith into a new sports title to help them sell their console? It isn’t likely their first sports game would be a college one, but it is very possible that one would emerge eventually. With the increasing size of hard drives, it is possible we could even see a single game with two different sports attached (ala Wii Sports).

At first glance, it may not seem too likely. But if you put together a timeline of possibilities, it almost seems inevitable. Assuming that new rules eventually provide clearer guidelines for what games (and other forms of media) can and can’t include, there would be less fear of a lawsuit. It may not take much longer after that for college sports to make their return to gaming.

It has been eight months. Let’s hope we don’t have to wait much longer.

Member Comments
# 1 Gramps91 @ 02/25/14 12:44 PM
The things I would do for a new college basketball game.
 
# 2 bigdoc85 @ 02/25/14 12:59 PM
I don't think we'll see anything soon. Demand among sports gamers for college sports games is high, but demand is not that significant when the entire gaming community (and the types of games purchased) is considered. It's just not worth the risk for someone to dive into this space.
 
# 3 TreyzAllDayz @ 02/25/14 01:32 PM
PLEASE EA or 2K, bring us college hoops back! And college football.
 
# 4 Junior Moe @ 02/25/14 01:54 PM
The most likely candidate is EA sports, for obvious reasons. NCAA football is the most profitable college license so if there is a way to get back in that market EA is in.

College Basketball has a smaller market that I don't think could support 2 games enough to be profitable. A better route would probably be to release a Hoops game every 2 or 3 years. Add a MyPlayer mode and offer a nice sized patch at a small price (20$) each year with gameplay updates and updated rosters (if its allowed), if not update fictional rosters to mimic the real life teams a little more. Allow us to purchase and play with some historic college squads online. After a few years the game could turn a profit.
 
# 5 RandallB21 @ 02/25/14 02:08 PM
Fully custom sports games are my dream. Open sourced so modders can go crazy. If I ever hit the lottery...
 
# 6 brent3419 @ 02/25/14 02:35 PM
our best bet would be ea to bring back their college series with a new ncaa football game some where down the line and it sucks we were one year away from having atleast one college football game on next gen consoles, but more people play football and it has a fan base made in it
 
# 7 thomguy123 @ 02/25/14 03:40 PM
LongShot games were looking to build a new college football game and it looked real promising. They didn't get enough Kickstarter funds and temporarily discontinued production about a year ago. Hopefully more people will look into it.
 
# 8 Dazraz @ 02/25/14 04:29 PM
I don't think we'll see anything in the next 5 years.
 
# 9 SVCbearcat10 @ 02/25/14 04:37 PM
I don't think we will ever see one again, or one that people will want to buy. With all the money and politics involved in college athletics now, it's only a matter of time before the power conferences do something. I think we will eventually see a minor league system like the MLB and NHL have (NFL will throw millions around to prevent this because they basically have a free development system). These programs have the means and funds to pay players that mid-majors and smaller schools do not. If there is a minor league system, no one would buy the college game because the best players would no longer go to college. If power conferences split, there's a chance of a game but I feel as though not as many would buy because only power schools would be playable. This is going to take years and I expect no one to risk a lawsuit making a barely profitable game at best.
 
# 10 TheJokester117 @ 02/25/14 06:12 PM
Unforunantely, due to O'Bannon vs. NCAA, I doubt you'll se another NCAA game again. Maybe if he wasn't such a scrub in the NBA, this lawsuit never would've happened.
 
# 11 malky @ 02/25/14 07:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheJokester117
Unforunantely, due to O'Bannon vs. NCAA, I doubt you'll se another NCAA game again. Maybe if he wasn't such a scrub in the NBA, this lawsuit never would've happened.
Then it would have been another scrub doing the same thing. It was bound to happen.

Ncaa football will be back, too much money to make with the new playoffs about to kick off. Plus the NBA is about to set the age minimum to 20, so that makes College Basketball more appealing. All of which says Money talks and these knuckleheads will sit down eventually to decide how to slice the pie and BAM, we have another college football and basketball game.
 
# 12 ericromain @ 02/25/14 07:38 PM
I like the completely customizable sports title idea. I remember playing a lot of Super Play Action Football for SNES where it had the NFL, but you could also play College or High School, and you entered your own custom name and picked your team's helmet/jersey/pant colors. Kind of crude by today's standards, but i thought it was amazing to play as my future high school back in 1993. Pro games today are all about licenses, but they never give us the option to create our own separate league, at least not well.
 
# 13 superjames1992 @ 02/25/14 08:27 PM
Never say never, but I don't see one within the next five years.
 
# 14 ggsimmonds @ 02/25/14 10:56 PM
"viable list of candidates to bring college sports back to video games, the results were much more profound than you may expect.
Candidate Number One: The Big Name Publisher"

Not exactly what I expected from a 'list ofcandidates'

Also, "The NCAA series made EA a significant amount of money"
Source? Do you have any actual figures?
 
# 15 Cardot @ 02/26/14 09:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ericromain
I remember playing a lot of Super Play Action Football for SNES where it had the NFL, but you could also play College or High School, and you entered your own custom name and picked your team's helmet/jersey/pant colors. Kind of crude by today's standards
Yeah, I would like to see EA or 2K at least take a shot of doing this again. With all the online sharing tools that are now available, it seems like a viable option.

And with all the money they would be saving on licensing, seems like a low risk. Not to mention they wouldn't have to invest the money and time into naming and ranking all the players.
 
# 16 Kentucky_Wildcat23 @ 02/26/14 09:20 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cardot
Yeah, I would like to see EA or 2K at least take a shot of doing this again. With all the online sharing tools that are now available, it seems like a viable option.

And with all the money they would be saving on licensing, seems like a low risk. Not to mention they wouldn't have to invest the money and time into naming and ranking all the players.
I think the best option would be someone publishing the game with current uniforms, stadiums/arenas, and ESPN features, but giving the buyers full control to customize rosters/coaches and the easy ability to share them to avoid the company being sued for players claiming to be used in the game.
 
# 17 jwtucker710 @ 02/26/14 12:00 PM
Here's a neat trick you can do with 2K14: go to Create Player. Create a list of players that you want to incorporate from the college season (or upload from 2K share). Then go to Create Teams. It's not the exact jerseys, but you can create college teams with those players. Lastly, go to your Offline Association and start a new season, and you can add in your created players on those teams, as well as put only those teams in either the Eastern or Western conference. It's not quite 2K College Hoops, but still kind of fun.
 
# 18 jwtucker710 @ 02/26/14 12:04 PM
I still play EA's NCAA 10 BB from time to time. Played 2K 8 College Hoops, but cannot handle those player models and dated graphics. Game engine is fine, but man, those graphics are horrible now days. NCAA 10 bb is much better if you want to play a college bb game. I wish 2K would go back and just update the graphics and patch 2K8. I don't see how that would violated the NCAA.
 
# 19 TheJokester117 @ 02/26/14 12:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by malky
Then it would have been another scrub doing the same thing. It was bound to happen.

Ncaa football will be back, too much money to make with the new playoffs about to kick off. Plus the NBA is about to set the age minimum to 20, so that makes College Basketball more appealing. All of which says Money talks and these knuckleheads will sit down eventually to decide how to slice the pie and BAM, we have another college football and basketball game.
True, I'll give you that one. And you're right, it absolutely is about money.

But now, the issue becomes how much EA/2k is willing to share with the university, and how much the university is gonna give the players. Realistically, I can't see EA/2k wanting to fork over more money to universities, and I can't see universities wanting to fork over the money they receive to their student athletes. Simply put, there's plenty of money to go around and make this thing work, but neither side seems like they're willing to give any of it up.
 
# 20 Cardot @ 02/26/14 01:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheJokester117
Simply put, there's plenty of money to go around and make this thing work, but neither side seems like they're willing to give any of it up.
As much as I enjoyed college basketball games and would love to seem them make a comeback, I don't think they were ever a cash cow.
 

« Previous12Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.