Home
Feature Article
OS Fact or Fiction: College Hoops Edition
1. Releasing a college basketball game in January instead of November would be a positive for a college hoops title.


Dustin Toms: Fact/Fiction. I feel like this is a loaded question. For the hardcore college hoops fan, this would be nothing short of a disappointment. You don't want to start playing halfway through the season, you want to take control once the actual season begins. But on the other hand, for the gaming companies, releasing closer to the tournament would probably make them more money in the long run. When it comes down to it, we all just want a new college hoops game.

Christian McLeod: Fact. I consider myself a college hoops fanatic -- the kicker is that outside of the early season tournaments, my interest level in the sport doesn't peak until mid/late January. Once college football is over and the NFL Playoffs come to an end, college basketball kicks into high gear. Also, by January interest in NBA gaming is beginning to tail off after a four month play period. Why not refine the NBA engine, polish up gameplay quirks, and even add some new features to the college game? In short, use the NBA game as a beta to perfect the college game, and then use the college game to use as a beta to perfect the next year's NBA game? Seems like a win-win for everyone involved to me.

2. There will be a new college basketball game in the next three years.


Dustin Toms: Fact. I honestly believe there will be. I don't neccasarily mean that we will have a full blown retail release, we may see something on XBLA or PSN. The market for college basketball isn't as big as other sports, but it has enough of a fan base to bring in plenty of dough.

Christian McLeod: Fact. I'll go out on a huge limb here, but there is no way a company like 2K that has almost perfected its hoops engine in NBA 2K11 would not attempt to cash in on a college game. Demand for a new college title is at an all-time high, and outside of paying for the NCAA license, I can't see the process being that large of an investment. Hell, 2K could just go ahead and give us NBA 2K11 with college skins, and I think many of us college hoops junkies would be happy.

Regardless, whether it's a DLC March Madness playable bracket, a program builder-like text sim or a full-fledged college hoops title, we will be seeing some form of a college basketball game in the next three years.

3. College Hoops 2K8 is the best college basketball game of all time.

 

Dustin Toms: Fact. Without a doubt. The gameplay for its time was unmatched. The play-calling system was pretty legit, and the graphics were phenomenal. But what seperates this game from others is the depth. In Legacy mode the options were endless. You could build from the ground up at a small school or start big with Duke. Either way you controlled everything about your team, including recruiting. I can't even begin to start counting the hours I spent just recruiting in that game. Still to this day I play it once in awhile.

Christian McLeod: Fact. It may not hold up that well after all these years, especially after playing NBA 2K11, but it is still the GOAT. In-depth recruiting, realistic plays, having to manage personnel, weekly wrap-up highlight shows and a punishing closed legacy all helped to create one of the most memorable sports gaming experiences of my life. I'd also like to show some love to EA's NCAA Basketball 10 for giving us the best broadcast presentation ever in a college basketball game

4. March Madness is the best sporting event of the year in America.


Dustin Toms: Fact. I'm a big basketball junkie. I live, breathe and die by the sport so of course I am going to say this is the best sporting event of the year. There is something about filling out brackets that will never get old, and having the chance to see small teams go on miraculous runs is just another added perk. The only thing that could ever top this is if the Sonics were in the NBA Playoffs, and that won't be happening anytime soon.

Christian McLeod: Fact. Three full weeks of the most competitive basketball you will ever see, coupled with some of the greatest and most improbable storylines in all of sports, makes March Madness the unmatched champion of sporting events. Where else can a small private school in Indiana, which was practically unknown five years ago, be playing in back-to-back National Championship games on a D1 level? College basketball is the only sport where the little guys actually have a shot at being crowned the champion. You can't really say that about any other sport, professional or collegiate.


Member Comments
# 1 blakenation11 @ 04/05/11 04:45 PM
Wolverine Studios is working on DDS: College Basketball 2. The original game was pretty good. Don't know how long it will take to come out but definitely within the next three years.
 
# 2 1WEiRDguy @ 04/05/11 05:40 PM
man i came in looking at the title thinking 2k made an announcement...lol...good discussion...count me in as one of the late people to the party...had i known what i knew back then, I would have gladly supported this game...
 
# 3 the_EDJ @ 04/05/11 06:00 PM
I still receive roster requests every month from indivuals wanting named rosters from EA's NCAA Basketball 2009.

Use this as an opportunity to test selling a $60 retail package of a full game every few years. Then charge for annual DLC to update roster ratings (since they can't give us the names) so that the top schools at the time are always accurately depicted.

I'm an EA homer, so hopefully they can get their act together too.
 
# 4 BenGerman @ 04/05/11 06:04 PM
Great article. I know its unlikely, but I wish someone from 2k would at least give us an answer to whether or not this is a possibility. I hate having this hope that has no base to it. I'd also love to hear an explanation as to why we aren't getting one. I have to believe the NCAA has lowered its prices, as they have no one buying from them now. Maybe it's just me, but no matter how hard I look, I can't find a reason why 2k wouldn't just put out a College version of NBA 2k. They have the Legacy mode in place, that hardly needs working on, and they have the game engine in place (with NBA 2k11 being the best representation of Basketball I've ever seen). It just doesn't make sense to me.
 
# 5 1WEiRDguy @ 04/05/11 06:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BenGerman
Great article. I know its unlikely, but I wish someone from 2k would at least give us an answer to whether or not this is a possibility. I hate having this hope that has no base to it. I'd also love to hear an explanation as to why we aren't getting one. I have to believe the NCAA has lowered its prices, as they have no one buying from them now. Maybe it's just me, but no matter how hard I look, I can't find a reason why 2k wouldn't just put out a College version of NBA 2k. They have the Legacy mode in place, that hardly needs working on, and they have the game engine in place (with NBA 2k11 being the best representation of Basketball I've ever seen). It just doesn't make sense to me.
that alone would most certainly add WAY more to MyPlayer mode...imagine if you really controlled dude all the way from high school...OH MY!!
 
# 6 HustlinOwl @ 04/05/11 06:15 PM
Oh College Hoops 2K & EA how I miss thee
 
# 7 TDenverFan @ 04/05/11 06:17 PM
I really hope CHoops 12 comes out! I'm probably being overly optimistic, but...
 
# 8 kashmir28 @ 04/05/11 09:09 PM
Honestly, why not release right before March Madness. While other sports are eliminating teams out of contention come playoff time, college hoops and March Madness actually adds teams, thus adding interest and want to the sport. Who had VCU, Richmond and other hopeful Cinderella's on there mind before March Madness. The peak interest in college hoops would be the ideal time to drop a game. It may seem late to the diehards, but diehards are going to buy no matter what...Madden...So why not feed the want.
 
# 9 jbrew2411 @ 04/05/11 09:26 PM
I love college basketball. I played college basketball and now coach high school basketball so the sport is my life. I also love playing basketball games. I think releasing in January would help. The fact that other games are not released during this time would help. Also it is after Christmas and people could spend those gift cards on the game. The game would not have to compete with NBA2k or NHL games. It just seems that October a lot of games comes out. Alot of people have to budget money when purchasing games so any college hoops games gets put down the list. I think a later release and maybe a 2 year-cycle would really help. The off year could have a updated roster release for those that have to have current rosters. Also the addition of a recruiting class builder like NBA2k11 has for draft classes would help as well. We could share our classes. Also the ability to edit roster (ie..names) before the release would be great. Don't know if they could load them on something like a team builder type site for the roster makes to get to work so when the game hits the streets we have a roster out. College hoops has way more teams then football so it takes a lot of time. Just some ideas.
 
# 10 ven0m43 @ 04/05/11 09:36 PM
A college basketball game, made by 2k would be good no matter when it is released.
 
# 11 xblake16x @ 04/06/11 12:36 AM
I am now a fan of dustin toms for his Sonic statement!
 
# 12 statum71 @ 04/06/11 01:23 AM
I still wish for the life of me that 2K would implement that weekly highlight show into NBA 2K.

That was so incredibly entertaining.
 
# 13 brza37 @ 04/06/11 07:22 AM
Don't get my hopes up like this... I'd pre-order on the day they announced a new CH2k. Hell, I'd buy DLC for 2k8 if they would bring some out for it.
Although I like to play when the Hoops season starts I've been saying for a while that a late February early March would make a lot more sense. In November alot of people are still busy with the football games. Then College has to compete with 2ks own NBA game. And November-December is usually packed with AAA non-sports titles anyway. Just way too much competition.
In late Feb. through March there's usually a lull in big releases and you've got the hype from conference championships tourneys and March Madness build up.
But I think we're just gonna have to keep dusting off 2k8 year after year when we want to get our fix.
 
# 14 SonOfEd @ 04/06/11 10:58 AM
Or they could package it with NBA 2k12 for a higher price, yet they would still save on distribution costs. Win-win for all!
 
# 15 malachijohn666 @ 04/06/11 02:47 PM
sorry but where is the above image from? I am just curious...
 
# 16 malachijohn666 @ 04/06/11 02:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by malachijohn666
sorry but where is the above image from? I am just curious...
I mean the one on the front page, where it looks like inside a stadium
 
# 17 Gramps91 @ 04/06/11 03:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ven0m43
A college basketball game, made by 2k would be good no matter when it is released.
Exactly my friend. This is what i popped in to say. Doesn't matter when they make one. Just as long as they sometime before I die
 
# 18 BaylorBearBryant @ 04/06/11 06:11 PM
2K might be a better game than EA's NCAA BB, but I can't say no to Gus Johnson and Bill Raftery. I play EA's title a lot more.
 
# 19 Mos1ted @ 04/06/11 08:31 PM
I think that if they do decide to bring back the series, they should release in November like they always have and just make a big marketing push close to March Madness so that those who have yet to get the game will be enticed to do so.

But I haven't enjoyed college basketball as much since the CH series ended. I believe that bringing that series back would also rejuvenate my interest in real life college basketball. On the flip side, my interest in the NBA is almost back to where it was during the 1990's thanks to some stellar NBA titles since 2K8.
 
# 20 ArkHogs @ 04/06/11 08:46 PM
As long as it's made by 2K, it would be good no matter when it was released. However, I think if they released it around March Madness time it would bring in more sales, because people would be hyped up and motivated to purchase it.
 

« Previous12Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.