Home
Feature Article
Review of the NBA Trade Deadline

The NBA Trade Deadline was frenzied, it was furious, and most of all it was interesting with big name players switching teams on several occassions. With several teams in the playoff hunt having changed their fortunes dramatically, we are bringing in Dustin Toms and TD. St-Matthew-Daniel to break down what the moves mean and how they might change your gameplay experience in NBA 2K11.

Which team made the better blockbuster deal for a franchise player: Knicks or Nets?


Dustin - As much as I love Melo, the Nets got the better player. Williams is arguably the best point guard in the NBA, which says a lot considering how many great points are in the league today. The Knicks got who they have wanted ever since LeBron went to South Beach, but Melo is a very offensive-minded player, and the Knicks were already able to put up points. Regardless of who is better, both teams improved by trading for a superstar. However, the Knicks were able to lock up Melo, and the Nets just gave up three first-round picks (Favors is one of them) for what could turn out to be nothing more than a two-year rental.

TD – I can’t comfortably say Deron Williams is a better basketball player than Carmelo Anthony, but if I had to pick one to build a franchise around, D-Will is the way I would go. Yes, D-Will can bolt in the summer of 2012, but for a team in desperate need of a franchise player, it’s a risk worth taking. The Nets now have a marquee player to build around, while the Knicks can only hope Carmelo and Amar’e Stoudemire fit well together.


The Knicks got their man, but did the Nets get a better deal?

Who were the biggest winners and losers at the trade deadline?


TD – My winners are actually two teams that stood pat. The Miami Heat and the Los Angeles Lakers are gleaming with joy after the mind-boggling trade by the Celtics that sent Kendrick Perkins to the OKC Thunder. The Celtics now have to rely on their other two big men with the same last name and same current injury history -- OUT. With Perk no longer a Celtic, and Shaq and Jermaine O’Neal hobbled, the Celtics no longer have the inside presence that bothers their main opposition in the title race -- advantage Heat and Lakers.

My big loser of the trade deadline has to be Baron Davis. One day you’re in Los Angeles having a good time, chilling in a Kia Optima with the top dropped and throwing lobs to Blake Griffin, the next day you’re traded to Cleveland. Ouch.

Dustin - The Zombie Sonics were the big winners of the trade deadline. They finally got a hold of a legit big man to play down low, but now they just need to hope he can come back healthy. Giving up Jeff Green might have stung for the fans, but it just shows that Sam Presti was not planning on re-signing Green, so they got what they could get for him. Just imagine how scary the Thunder front court is now -- Durant, Ibaka, Perkins. I think the Celts were just trying to screw over the Lakers.

My big loser has to be Baron Davis as well, but for the sake of this article, I'll go with something else. The Chicago Bulls might have single-handedly screwed themselves over by not fixing their sweet trio at the two-guard position. Bogans/Brewer/Korver can not get it done, and the Bulls knew that. They could not pry away J.R. Smith or Aaron Afflalo from Denver, so they reportedly panicked and offered Brewer, two first-round picks and a second-round pick to Memphis for O.J. Mayo. That seems like a little too much for someone who is considered an average guard at best. Even Anthony Parker would have been a solid addition. Oh well, Chicago just secured their spot in the second round of the playoffs, and not much more.


The good 'ol days for Baron Davis.


Which moves that didn't happen would you have liked to see?


TD – Tayshuan Prince to Contender X. Dallas apparently pushed to get Tayshaun in the Big D but did not have the necessary assets. I really don’t understand why more teams didn’t try to get this guy. Prince might not light up the scoreboard, but he is a legitimate starter or top-notch role player in this league whose talents have just been wasting away for the past two seasons. I’m starting a Twitter hashtag campaign so I won’t have to write this again next year.

#FREETAYSHAUN

Dustin - Mayo to Indiana. The one trade I believed that was going to happen did not. O.J. Mayo is still in Memphis and nobody knows why. The Grizzlies are better without him; he is young; he has skill; he is a team's ultimate trade chip. I don't know what happened with the Mayo to Indiana trade, but that would have been perfect for both teams. Memphis was getting a pick, and Indiana was about to add another great young player to its already loaded core. But with Xavier Henry and Rudy Gay both out for extended periods of time, the front office might have opted to keep Mayo as a security blanket for a team trying to get into the playoffs.

What new lineup are you most interested in playing with in NBA 2K11?


Dustin - I'm hopping on the Big Apple bandwagon for this one. I love Melo, and Melo loves me. With Anthony and Amar'e running together in NBA 2K11, mad scoring will happen. Not only will those two be there, but so is Chauncey Billups. The guy can knock down 3-pointers left and right. Plus the acquisition of Corey Brewer means a lot more to me than most (although it seems like he may get bought out by Knicks). I love the way he plays in the game. His shot is decent, and his defense is fabulous. He makes the perfect sixth man to spell time for Melo and Landry Fields. I know I'm not the only one here that will start running with the Knicks because I can guarantee they are about to join the Heat and Lakers as everyone's favorite online squad.

TD - Oklahoma City Thunder. Even though I'm a fan of Kevin Durant's scoring prowess, I usually stray away from running with the Thunder in NBA 2K11. But with the addition of Kendrick Perkins and Nate Robinson, that's about to change.

Perkins gives the Thunder an inside force with great defense and rebound ratings, while little-big Nate comes with his usual off-the-bench energy and scoring attributes. With this team, I could either go big with Durant, Serge Ibaka and Perkins on my front line, or play "Nellie ball" with Westbrook and Nate in the backcourt, James Harden at the small-forward position, and Durant and Ibaka as my bigs. With such a versatile lineup, the Thunder are not only poised to make a run at the Western Conference title, but should also become one of the most used NBA 2K11 teams for the rest of the season.


NBA 2K11 Videos
Member Comments
# 1 yuriz09 @ 03/01/11 02:25 PM
Sigh.

Can we get something more then this? How lackluster.
 
# 2 Jay F Kennedy @ 03/01/11 03:24 PM
I say the Knicks got the better deal.. short term and long term. D.Williams isn't guaranteed to resign in NJ/Brooklyn. And the most interesting lineup for me would have to be Boston (with Troy Murphy now).
 
# 3 Jarbeez @ 03/01/11 05:35 PM
I did a game by game sim of a 29 game season last night (controlled all 30 teams and simmed each game individually)... the Knicks actually fared worse than they were before. Not sure how that happened exactly but I found that interesting. They ended up ranked #12 in the Eastern Conference.

A little off topic, but still interesting.
 
# 4 BlackRome @ 03/01/11 05:53 PM
The Melo deal was a steal. They traded three players who will never appear in an All Star game for one for a finals MVP and a top 7 player in the league. I found it laughable when people were saying they gave up to much. Their is a Wilson Chandler on every teams bench right now. Gallinari is one of the main reasons the Knicks were terrible on defense. Felton shoots 33% from 3 while Billups shoots 44%.

That trade was worst than the Barkley trade that sent him to Phoenix.
 
# 5 ChaseB @ 03/01/11 06:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jarbeez
I did a game by game sim of a 29 game season last night (controlled all 30 teams and simmed each game individually)... the Knicks actually fared worse than they were before. Not sure how that happened exactly but I found that interesting. They ended up ranked #12 in the Eastern Conference.

A little off topic, but still interesting.
Dustin, one of the people who wrote this article, said the same thing basically I believe. That, essentially, the Nuggets became way better and the Knicks didn't do as well.
 
# 6 GOBLUE_08 @ 03/01/11 07:15 PM
I hate that my Knicks had to get rid of Gallo, I really feel like he's gonna be a star if he stays healthy. But on the flipside the leadership that Billups brings is gonna help a ton, and once Melo and Stat learn to feed off eachother they are gonna be a MAJOR problem for anybody. The way they played the other night against the heat brought back some fond memories of that rivalry. If they make some smart moves in the off season, I will finally be able to say I'm a Knicks fan with some pride again lol.
 
# 7 mlp111 @ 03/01/11 10:16 PM
have to disagree with this guy, Knicks got the better player and i would build around melo instead, more talented and way better player overall.... this guy must not be watching the nba, because by no means is d-will arguably the best pg in the league ( a couple of years ago, maybe, but now, no way), lets say D-rose, cp3, and rondo, IMO
 
# 8 GOBLUE_08 @ 03/01/11 11:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mlp111
have to disagree with this guy, Knicks got the better player and i would build around melo instead, more talented and way better player overall.... this guy must not be watching the nba, because by no means is d-will arguably the best pg in the league ( a couple of years ago, maybe, but now, no way), lets say D-rose, cp3, and rondo, IMO
Cant forget about Westbrook too in OKC, dude is a beast.
 
# 9 mlp111 @ 03/02/11 12:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GOBLUE_08
Cant forget about Westbrook too in OKC, dude is a beast.
I forgot, and westbrook, guy been killing, can't say same about Williams though this year
 
# 10 MavsFansForLife41 @ 03/02/11 12:51 AM
Terrible write-up...Absolutely no reasoning behind common knowledge and general info.

Anyways...best new team in 2k11 is the Nuggets. You can't stop Lawson, Smith, iLLWiLL, Gallinari, and Nene.
 
# 11 Yeah...THAT Guy @ 03/02/11 01:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BlackRome
The Melo deal was a steal. They traded three players who will never appear in an All Star game for one for a finals MVP and a top 7 player in the league. I found it laughable when people were saying they gave up to much. Their is a Wilson Chandler on every teams bench right now. Gallinari is one of the main reasons the Knicks were terrible on defense. Felton shoots 33% from 3 while Billups shoots 44%.

That trade was worst than the Barkley trade that sent him to Phoenix.
If Gallo was one of the reasons they were so bad defensively, man are they in for a rude awakening when they go through a full season with Carmelo in his place...

And in regards to one of the other posts (not by you), whoever thinks Rondo is seriously better than DWill is on something mega strong. Top PG in the league is really a 2 or 3 PG battle between CP3, DWill, and Rose, and that's really it. Westbrook and Rondo are in the next tier of PGs with Steve Nash and probably someone else that I'm forgetting.
 
# 12 RUFFNREADY @ 03/02/11 03:38 AM
The worst trade at trade deadline was the Blazers / Bobcats giving up 3 bigs and money for 1 slasher. They (Blazers) have one big left that is active, and he's even alittle banged up.
Blazers get:
• F Gerald Wallace

Bobcats get:
• F Dante Cunningham
• C Joel Przybilla
• C Sean Marks
• 2011 first-round pick (from Hornets) and 2013 first-round pick
• Cash considerations
• Official release
What are the Blazers front office thinking? Do they think LaMarcus Aldridge is going to lead them to the playoffs? If you play with them in 2k11, you would know that they are set with a bunch of dunkers and athletic slashers. They fell way short of things on their 'to do list'. They have one big man to combat the rest of the western conference; and opt injured Camby is not the saviour in any sense. I just watched one of my favroite teams trade themselves out of the playoffs!
 
# 13 eye guy @ 03/02/11 04:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by RUFFNREADY
The worst trade at trade deadline was the Blazers / Bobcats giving up 3 bigs and money for 1 slasher. They (Blazers) have one big left that is active, and he's even alittle banged up.
Blazers get:
• F Gerald Wallace

Bobcats get:
• F Dante Cunningham
• C Joel Przybilla
• C Sean Marks
• 2011 first-round pick (from Hornets) and 2013 first-round pick
• Cash considerations
• Official release
What are the Blazers front office thinking? Do they think LaMarcus Aldridge is going to lead them to the playoffs? If you play with them in 2k11, you would know that they are set with a bunch of dunkers and athletic slashers. They fell way short of things on their 'to do list'. They have one big man to combat the rest of the western conference; and opt injured Camby is not the saviour in any sense. I just watched one of my favroite teams trade themselves out of the playoffs!
Actually imo, Cunningham was their biggest loss (which isn't much)., with the picks and Przybilla a close second. Aldridge may not be the lead player they need but an addition to their defense is more than welcome. I agree they are now short of bigs, but Marks is trash and their bet on there existing bigs getting healthy is more of a winner than if they kept the above.

As for 2K11, I traded for G. Wallace in my Blazers assoc at the end of December, I lol'd when this happened. When i'm controlling the game, offensively he sucks (probably me), but defensively he's a beast, lol
 
# 14 Game4fun @ 03/02/11 04:20 AM
Carmelos bringing a Championship Home to MSG like he did for My Home town team... Get that ring Carmelo, You will have a gold medal, National championship and NBA ring, and become a modern day god in NYC, The whole State of New York for that matter, Let these people talk about whos top ten, and better then you, then go sign a new deal with MJ and chill with him Because You guys are in a part of a Group that Kobe, Lebron, Wade, Arent in... haters
 
# 15 jshmoopy @ 03/02/11 11:53 AM
I still don't quite know how I feel about the Knicks/Nuggets trade. The Knicks did get better instantly, but who knows how good Gallo, Chandler, and Felton are going to be. I think getting Billups is very important. He can spread the floor and he will get the ball to Stoudemire and Carmelo better than Felton. I just wish this trade would have happened earlier so we could see this team's full potential before the season is over. I hope they get the chemistry down by playoff time so that they can make a good run and not get eliminated early.

As a Bucks fan, I was upset that nothing was done to improve the roster, but what could be done? Man they suck.
 
# 16 Ike04 @ 03/02/11 12:50 PM
The melo deal was by far the biggest trade. even though the knicks dont have much depth at the momemt they can always pick up a few good players in free agency or draft someone to replace what they lost. But long term, choosing to give up those guys for melo and billups was a very smart move. I'm interested even more in playing with OKC now in 2k11. they are already my favorite team but i always thought that they lacked the presence in the post that would put them over the top. now that they have that i think they are a force to be reckoned with in the west.
 
# 17 Freak123 @ 03/02/11 01:50 PM
Deron Williams was, by far, the biggest trade of this year. There's really no doubt about it. He makes every other person on the roster better, whereas Carmelo, while a superstar, doesn't contribute in all of the ways Deron Williams does.

Williams is going to be the face of that franchise for many years and I honestly do expect Howard to leave the Magic at the end of 2012 for the Nets. Who wouldn't want to go play with Deron Williams? This will only happen if he is willing to give up being the "man" on his team, and I'm not sure if he'd be willing to do that. I think that would be the only thing standing in the way of joining the Nets honestly.

Anyways, I digress. Point is, getting the best point guard in the NBA was a better trade by far.
 
# 18 Yeah...THAT Guy @ 03/02/11 02:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Freak123
Deron Williams was, by far, the biggest trade of this year. There's really no doubt about it. He makes every other person on the roster better, whereas Carmelo, while a superstar, doesn't contribute in all of the ways Deron Williams does.

Williams is going to be the face of that franchise for many years and I honestly do expect Howard to leave the Magic at the end of 2012 for the Nets. Who wouldn't want to go play with Deron Williams? This will only happen if he is willing to give up being the "man" on his team, and I'm not sure if he'd be willing to do that. I think that would be the only thing standing in the way of joining the Nets honestly.

Anyways, I digress. Point is, getting the best point guard in the NBA was a better trade by far.
I think the biggest move was really the combination of the Nets driving up the price for Carmelo and then stealing Deron away from Utah. Mikhail and the rest of the FO did a great job on that one.
 
# 19 dramachild11 @ 03/02/11 02:45 PM
the dwill trade wouldve been the best IF he had been able to sign an extension but he cant, and if the nets struggle early next season i could see him asking for a trade... a previous poster said something about the blazers trade for wallace, he said it was stupid.. my question is whether ur talking about 2k or real life.. maybe in the game is was stupid, but aldridge is balling out of his freaking mind the last month or so and come playoff time if roy cant play they will need a perimeter defender who can guard kobe, manu, etc. the only real problem with the trade that i see is that it might stunt batums growth
 
# 20 Freak123 @ 03/02/11 05:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dramachild11
the dwill trade wouldve been the best IF he had been able to sign an extension but he cant, and if the nets struggle early next season i could see him asking for a trade... a previous poster said something about the blazers trade for wallace, he said it was stupid.. my question is whether ur talking about 2k or real life.. maybe in the game is was stupid, but aldridge is balling out of his freaking mind the last month or so and come playoff time if roy cant play they will need a perimeter defender who can guard kobe, manu, etc. the only real problem with the trade that i see is that it might stunt batums growth
He won't request a trade nor get one. They have already informed him they will go after top-tier free agents the next two seasons and, barring some animosity towards the Nets for some reason, they will get those top-tier free agents. It's pretty simple really. Best point guard in the league who will score, lead a team, and get you involved as well is the team you want to be on. He's staying with the Nets.
 

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.