Home
Feature Article
The Top Five 8-Bit NES Baseball Games

It's no secret that I am the resident old man on staff here at Operation Sports. Sure, I take quite a beating from the young whipper snappers on staff, but growing up in the '80s and early '90s did have its perks, specifically some great 8-bit baseball gaming on the NES.

The Nintendo Entertainment System was synonymous with great sports titles, and baseball was no exception. To this day, many of the NES' baseball titles still play great, with a select few defining the genre.

Being the classic gaming aficionado that I am, I could not resist taking a trip down baseball gaming memory lane. With my NES ready to go, a few cold beverages, and a complete disregard for my "honey do" list, I dove into my massive NES baseball collection in an attempt to identify the five greatest hardball titles to be released for the system.

The competition was fierce, the hours of testing long, the MIDI soundtracks piercing, but in the end only five could make the cut. So which games stood the test of time and are worthy of being in my top five list of the best NES baseball games of all time? The answers may surprise you.

5. Baseball (1985)


Probably the most underrated 8-bit baseball game ever, Nintendo's Baseball is an absolute classic. The gameplay is about as simple as it gets, but batting, pitching and fielding have an old-school sense of strategy to them that many modern baseball games fail to re-create.

In the batter's box it is important to time your swing to ensure a great hit; on the mound you have to watch how many fastballs you throw as to not fatigue your pitcher; and while in the field proper angles to the ball are required to avoid giving up extra base hits.

Yes, the game only included six teams, and did not include either the MLB of MLBPA licenses, but it really does not matter. Baseball is a phenomenal blast from the past, and it is a must play for anyone who enjoys classic baseball gaming.

4. Bases Loaded (1988)


Bases Loaded's fixed camera angle behind the pitcher turned many off, which is a shame because it was one of the best simulation-style games of baseball to grace the NES. While the game sparked several sequels, I still believe the first Bases Loaded was the greatest in Jaleco's long-winded franchise.

But what makes the game so great? To me, it's the team balance. Every team has distinct strengths and weaknesses, making Season mode a baseball version of rock, paper, scissors as you feverishly search out your team's strong suit against the opposing team's weakness.

It also does not not hurt that the game plays like a dream in the field. The ball travels at just the right clip, and player speed is tuned accordingly -- a major flaw in many NES baseball games, like LJN's Major League Baseball. If you were too young at the time to have enjoyed everything this game has to offer, I suggest you pick it up on the Wii's Virtual Console. Also, watch out for Utah's Agua -- he's the game's version of Albert Pujols.

3. Baseball Stars (1989)


Here's a little nugget of info for all you youngsters out there. In addition to superb fighting games, SNK also used to make one of the best baseball gaming franchises ever.

Baseball Stars has what can be best described as the first console baseball franchise mode. A team can be created in the game, with the user being given a sum of virtual money to purchase players. Once the team is chosen, each subsequent win earns money that can be spent on free agents or to upgrade player attributes.

Add in phenomenal on-field gameplay and deep stat tracking (that is dynamic as a season progresses), and you have an NES baseball game equivalent to Final Fantasy.

2. Baseball Simulator 1.000 (1989)


Long before the days of MLB Slugfest and The Bigs, baseball gamers had Culture Brain's Baseball Simulator 1.000. The game featured an extremely deep and customizable Season mode and some of the best on-field gameplay in the business. While I enjoyed BS 1.000's in-depth simulation style, the reason it lands in the second spot on this list is because of the Ultra mode.

Ultra mode took everything that was outstanding about the game's on-field play, and gave pitchers and hitters special powers that could be activated before the ball was delivered. Batters were able to hit missiles or cause earthquakes with balls put in play, and pitchers could literally throw fireballs or super-weighted cannon balls.

The best part about Ultra mode in BS 1.000 was that it felt like the perfect mix of arcade and simulation baseball. While over the top, Culture Brain struck a balance between these two elements that has not been seen since.

1. RBI Baseball (1988)


Honestly, how could this game not be number one on this list? RBI Baseball is a gem, and it deserves to be mentioned in any list discussing the greatest baseball games of all time (not just 8-bit).

With the MLBPA license in hand, gamers were finally able to control their favorite players of the era, provided they were included on the game's eight teams, or All-Star teams. Even better was that the players had specific attributes that separated them from others in the game.

For the first time ever in a baseball video game, it actually meant something to play as a team like the Red Sox and use Roger Clemens. The era of "banned teams" and "house rules" officially began when RBI Baseball was released.

RBI Baseball is the Tecmo Bowl of hardball, and it deserves to be re-released with updated MLB rosters and the full MLB license on XBLA/PSN.


Christian McLeod is a senior (citizen) staff writer here at Operation Sports. With his wife and him expecting their first child in July, he can only hope to raise the child on a steady diet of classic NES and SNES sports games. Make sure to follow him on Twitter @Bumble14_OS, talk to him here on our forums via Bumble14, and challenge him on XBL/PSN via Bumble14.


Member Comments
# 1 Doormat @ 02/21/11 04:15 PM
Nice pic for the #1 spot, can't agree any more than that.
 
# 2 Joey @ 02/21/11 04:33 PM
We have a modified Dreamcast at work that can play all the old Nintendo and Sega games...I've played all of these but Nintendo Baseball within the last 3 weeks or so. I'm 35 now so I got plenty of gameplay out of all these growing up. I replaced the Baseball Stars' teams with my own creation of current all stars and kept stats in a scorebook. The other 2 guys I work with refuse to play that game with me!

The one Ultra team on BS 1.000 is insane. Something like a .460 AVG and 70+ homeruns or something like that. Nice article!
 
# 3 superbus @ 02/21/11 04:36 PM
No Little League Baseball: Championship Series?
 
# 4 TLasorda @ 02/21/11 05:10 PM
Bases loaded Is the only baseball video game that included a bench clearing brawl when you hit a batter. I liked Baseball Simulator too because you could make your own players.
 
# 5 davis420 @ 02/21/11 05:11 PM
I forgot all about Baseball Simulater 1.000! Baseball Stars was also GREAT!
 
# 6 areobee401 @ 02/21/11 05:14 PM
Bases Loaded 2 or Baseball Stars would have been my top pick. WIth that said you can't go wrong with any of the games on this list.
 
# 7 nomo17k @ 02/21/11 05:14 PM
Wasted many hours nibbling the outside corner on Nintendo's Baseball & RBI Baseball. My personal best is Best Play Pro Yakyuu. Not sure it was ever released in USA but it was a great sim if you enjoy the managing/stats aspect of baseball.
 
# 8 tazbk @ 02/21/11 05:24 PM
That is an awesome list. I owned all of those with the exception of baseball simulator. RBI baseball, Baseball Stars and Bases Loaded Part 2 were my favorites of that generation. That brings back a lot of memories of elementary school and my first NES right there. Makes me feel proud to be "older" than most around here.
 
# 9 ChaseB @ 02/21/11 05:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by legend88
what about basewars? Was a bit over the top but was kind of a mix between baseball and a fighting game.
That would have been on my list.
 
# 10 The Bimmer @ 02/21/11 05:48 PM
Bases Loaded is my all time favorite. Who can forget the " you bum your out", when striking out with the bases loaded.
 
# 11 RynoAid @ 02/21/11 06:05 PM
you got all my favs... nothing to add here. Good job.
 
# 12 hope4bob @ 02/21/11 06:08 PM
The one I most fondly remember is Earl Weaver Baseball on the Amiga. I never went the Nintendo route. Started gaming on a Matel Intellevision, then Amiga, then Playstation 1, 2, & 3.
 
# 13 SeerMagicX @ 02/21/11 06:15 PM
boo, you missed roger clemens baseball.
 
# 14 Facts @ 02/21/11 06:26 PM
Basewars was the bomb back in the day.
 
# 15 pietasterp @ 02/21/11 06:27 PM
I remember I first saw/played RBI baseball on one of those flat-top games in a Pizza Hut when I was a kid...and after striking out the side with Jack Morris and having a huge innning capped by a multi-run extra base hit (by the mysteriously white "Sweet" Lou Whittaker), I was hooked for life...I pestered my parents to get me that game for the better part of the rest of the year, and when I finally got it that XMas, I played that thing into a flashing purple-and-white NES screen of death a few months later....the most fun I've ever had w/ a baseball game to this day.
 
# 16 jeffy777 @ 02/21/11 07:08 PM
Bases Loaded was amazing.

I loved RBI as well, but I remember it being too easy to exploit the pitching mechanic
 
# 17 woodjer @ 02/21/11 07:15 PM
Never played BS 1.000 but each of the other four had some great things going for them. I have to say that Bases Loaded is number one for me simply because I remember it being the first Nintendo game that I had (ok, TECHNICALLY, it was second but I traded in Castlevania without even opening it) and the nights that I would play with my dad and the fun that we both had trying to outguess each other. Sentimental feelings aside, I can't argue too much with RBI getting the top spot.
 
# 18 tke281 @ 02/21/11 07:15 PM
How bout Bad News Baseball? I loved that game! I liked when there would be a close play and they would show the cut scene that determined if you were out or safe. Roger Clemens Baseball was a close 2nd favorite of mine as well.
 
# 19 BobSacamano @ 02/21/11 07:20 PM
I don't know the history of Baseball Simulator 1.000 but I always felt that it was identical to RBI Baseball, but with more stats and a season mode. It was so identical that it felt like a direct rip-off. A little Googling hasn't given me any answers, but were they developed by the same team or using the same code or something? I mean, the fielding is 100% identical.

My favorite NES baseball game other than RBI Baseball was Bo Jackson Baseball. The graphics were ridiculously good for "back in the day" and the umpires actually had voices! Also, Bo Jackson was absurdly good in the game. He was a guaranteed home run at least once a game. It doesn't seem like anyone really remembers the game though, perhaps because the SNES had been released by the time Bo Jackson Baseball came out.

I'll also submit Tecmo's Baseball as a pretty darn good baseball game. That one seems to be overshadowed by Tecmo's other sports offering, but it's a great game in its own right.

I only have one disagreement with your list: I hate NES Baseball. Maybe it's because I only played the game years after the fact, years after I'd fallen in love with RBI Baseball, but I thought it was incredibly slow and boring. It's not really fair that I'm comparing it to games really some five to eight years later, though. It's no Ice Hockey or Play Action Football, IMO.
 
# 20 green94 @ 02/21/11 07:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr5000
Baseball Stars should have been number one. And that NES Baseball game shouldn't have been anywhere near this list.
Baseball Stars >>>>>>>> everything else.

And it's not even close - franchise mode was top notch and leveling up by beating the Lovely Ladies was simply awesome.
 

« Previous12345Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.