Home
Feature Article
Dynasty League Baseball Online Overview

Sometimes a media experience encourages you to seek out other versions of that specific title. For instance, I powered through the J.R.R. Tolkien novels after seeing the first Lord of the Rings movie. A hit single might entice you to buy the whole album. Even a sports video game might turn you on towards the real-life version of that sport.

So, in just about all cases, this is a good sign: your first experience is a positive one, so you seek out more like it. Dynasty League Baseball Online is a perfect example of this phenomenon.

New and Online

Dynasty League Baseball Online is a new online baseball text-sim, currently in beta, that allows you to re-create single games, series and leagues (eventually) featuring your favorite historical teams. Each team’s performance is based on real-life stats, meaning you’ll get a remarkably accurate and realistic experience each time you log on.

Currently, you are able to play single games and three-, five- and seven-game series against the AI. During gameplay, dice rolls are simulated, their results shown on-screen -- a nice touch -- and the ensuing play is calculated and applied to the situation. It is a relatively smooth and straight-forward process, but you’ll probably want to brush up on the rules of Dynasty League Baseball. To help, a .PDF rulebook is available.

If you are familiar with other baseball text-sims, there are a few tweaks that set Dynasty League apart. First, just about every element of the game is factored into the calculations, including weather, stadium and umpires -- in addition to the standard player statistics. These details show the game's tabletop roots, and I like that these are all shown during gameplay. Too many games, in my opinion, gloss over the die rolls and just assume that you only care about play-by-play. Dynasty League does allow you to adjust how much data you’ll see, so if you do only want to see results, that can be arranged.

Throughout the game, player cards, pie charts and outcome percentages help you manage all of that data. Also unique to this game are coaching decisions, including the odds of success and possible outcomes. These help break up the data-driven play and offer moments of pure strategy.

A few other elements help streamline the experience, but ultimately may frustrate some baseball purists. You only get one chance to steal per at-bat; if your runner is held, you’ve missed your opportunity. There’s no option to manage each pitch, and the process of warming up pitchers without them getting too tired seems unintuitive. Again, this game is based on a pre-existing rule set, so these issues are not exclusive to the online game. However, they probably won’t bother most users looking for a quick and accurate baseball simulation.



I Love the '90s...and Baseball Stadiums

Outside of beautiful stadium pictures that serve as a "playmat," this game is not that pretty to look at. Its layout and graphical flair favors the functional, and the whole page sort of screams 1990s. I don’t think this is a huge issue, but don’t expect an EA level of slick polish. To date, the developers have patched some things to help make it a more appealing experience, so it’s safe to assume a certain amount of continued development. Still, I'll restate that I really like the backgrounds, which are large high-quality images of the home team's ballpark.

Live Tourneys

The most interesting way to play, for now, is not against the computer, but against other humans in the tournament setting. These run daily, and feature a single-elimination format. Some elements, like a closable chat window and CPU takeover for dropouts, make this online experience a pleasant one. The only issue I have with playing another person is that the games can take a lot longer because every action requires confirmation. Add in the fact that if you advance, you may need to wait for other games to finish, and you have a multi-hour experience. A fun experience, especially if you are winning, but a long one for sure.

Final Thoughts

At this point, some features have yet to be implemented, such as leagues and playing another individual in a single game. However, new stuff is being added just about every week. There is a large selection of teams, but don’t expect every team from every year to be there. Also, there is a nice "user score" and ranking system that tracks your progress.

So, if you’ve played other baseball text-sims or board games, especially Dynasty League Baseball, you will definitely want to extend your experience with this online version. It’s free while in beta, so there’s nothing to lose.


Member Comments
# 21 thumstyx @ 11/11/10 08:43 PM
I was able to create the account - Awesome first game against the CPU - Looking forward to joining some tournaments this weekend. Absolutely great product here. Well done. Very enjoyable.
 
# 22 budsticky @ 11/12/10 05:06 PM
I really like the game, and even played the board version way back in the early 90s when it was Pursue the Pennant. I've always been a big tabletop sports gamer from back in the Strat days through all the other products over the years.

That said, this isn't for me at this price point. I like to play single seasons solitaire style and at a more leisurely pace. With a subscription service I'd feel like I would have to be on it too much to get my money's worth.

That said, it's a great game and for the right person I would recommend it. It's just not for me at this time.

I hope it is possible to buy and play single seasons against a good AI opponent in the future and just somehow own the game so you can play whenever you want. I know there is a traditional PC game of this available but I'm not sure of it's future. I do like the "play anywhere" aspect though, and would welcome that if the game ever suited my needs.
 
# 23 davis420 @ 11/13/10 04:31 PM
I just got done playing the 1st game of the 2009 World Series, Yankees vs Phillies. Sabathia just didn't have it going in Game 1. Cliff Lee pitched a Cg, giving up 4 runs and SO 8. It seems like a fun game to play but the price is what might put me off of buying it.
 
# 24 thumstyx @ 11/14/10 04:39 PM
It is a great concept - great gaming experience. The price unfortunately does not justify the content at this point. I would consider joining for a one time fee or under $5.00 a month.
 
# 25 Sportsforever @ 11/14/10 04:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by thumstyx
It is a great concept - great gaming experience. The price unfortunately does not justify the content at this point. I would consider joining for a one time fee or under $5.00 a month.
I have played Dynasty cards & dice since it was released in 1994. I have pretty much every card set they have produced. If you wanted to purchase the 2010 cards that will be available here in November it would cost you $88 ($60 for the cards, $15 for the ballpark sheets, and $13 for shipping). I average purchasing 2 card sets/year (the new one plus a retro set) so I'd say I spend between $150-$200/year on the cards. Viewing it like that makes this seem not so bad, but I admit it's in the eye of the beholder.
 
# 26 Purplepower_NC @ 11/14/10 05:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sportsforever
I have played Dynasty cards & dice since it was released in 1994. I have pretty much every card set they have produced. If you wanted to purchase the 2010 cards that will be available here in November it would cost you $88 ($60 for the cards, $15 for the ballpark sheets, and $13 for shipping). I average purchasing 2 card sets/year (the new one plus a retro set) so I'd say I spend between $150-$200/year on the cards. Viewing it like that makes this seem not so bad, but I admit it's in the eye of the beholder.
So....you are saying that you spend $150-200/year to play baseball, and can only play 1 season for each team you choose. That is very high for me....if I did that my wife would kill me. It cuts into her shoes fund.
 
# 27 Sportsforever @ 11/14/10 05:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Purplepower_NC
So....you are saying that you spend $150-200/year to play baseball, and can only play 1 season for each team you choose. That is very high for me....if I did that my wife would kill me. It cuts into her shoes fund.
I'm not sure what you mean about playing 1 season for each team I choose. With each card set I purchase I have every team from that year. For example, if I wanted to play the 1957 Brooklyn Dodgers season I could, or any other team from that year. Does that explain it better?
 
# 28 Purplepower_NC @ 11/14/10 07:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sportsforever
I'm not sure what you mean about playing 1 season for each team I choose. With each card set I purchase I have every team from that year. For example, if I wanted to play the 1957 Brooklyn Dodgers season I could, or any other team from that year. Does that explain it better?
Yes...that is what I meant. I am more of a dynasty type player....so seems a bit high for me.
 
# 29 Sportsforever @ 11/14/10 08:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Purplepower_NC
Yes...that is what I meant. I am more of a dynasty type player....so seems a bit high for me.
Ah, I see what you mean. You are looking more for something like OOTP. I am more of a replayer type based on actual season stats which is what Dynasty is. I haven't used it, but OOTP sounds like the best game for what you are looking to do.
 
# 30 bkrich83 @ 11/14/10 09:59 PM
My favorite baseball game going back to PTP board game. There is no game with anywhere near the level of detail.

I subscribed yesterday.
 
# 31 Sportsforever @ 11/14/10 11:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bkrich83
My favorite baseball game going back to PTP board game. There is no game with anywhere near the level of detail.

I subscribed yesterday.
Did you do a month to month or the 6 month subscription? It will be nice to have the 2010 cards available right away instead of waiting for them in the mail.
 
# 32 bkrich83 @ 11/15/10 12:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sportsforever
Did you do a month to month or the 6 month subscription? It will be nice to have the 2010 cards available right away instead of waiting for them in the mail.
I did the 6 month. We'll see how it goes. I think i am going to play in some tourneys soon.

I LOVE the online version of the game.
 
# 33 Sportsforever @ 11/15/10 01:30 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bkrich83
I did the 6 month. We'll see how it goes. I think i am going to play in some tourneys soon.

I LOVE the online version of the game.
Yes, they have done an amazing job with it. I've played in some tourney's and it's a blast. They have about 20 new ballpark images for the older parks like Ebbets, Polo Grounds, Shibe Park, etc that they are going to be putting up here soon.

When the GT leagues start it will be a lot of fun to pick a team and manage through a season.
 
# 34 bkrich83 @ 11/15/10 02:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sportsforever
Yes, they have done an amazing job with it. I've played in some tourney's and it's a blast. They have about 20 new ballpark images for the older parks like Ebbets, Polo Grounds, Shibe Park, etc that they are going to be putting up here soon.

When the GT leagues start it will be a lot of fun to pick a team and manage through a season.
Thanks to you, I have been playing it for a while now. They really did a great job in capturing the feel of playing the tabletop game, yet still keeping it streamlined.

I just finished playing the 1998 Playoff series with San Diego vs. Houston. Had a blast...
 
# 35 Sportsforever @ 11/15/10 02:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bkrich83
Thanks to you, I have been playing it for a while now. They really did a great job in capturing the feel of playing the tabletop game, yet still keeping it streamlined.

I just finished playing the 1998 Playoff series with San Diego vs. Houston. Had a blast...
Ya, I've played that 1998 playoffs and it was a good one. Brown beat Johnson in Game 1 (in real life that is still one of the most amazing games I've seen...I think Brown struck 16) and the Padres won in 4.

I played in the Sunday Night Baseball League over the summer as we tested it the game out. I have the San Diego franchise and the team is really poor, but I have a lot of money to spend on free agents and I'm looking forward to next year already.
 
# 36 bkrich83 @ 11/15/10 02:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sportsforever
Ya, I've played that 1998 playoffs and it was a good one. Brown beat Johnson in Game 1 (in real life that is still one of the most amazing games I've seen...I think Brown struck 16) and the Padres won in 4.

I played in the Sunday Night Baseball League over the summer as we tested it the game out. I have the San Diego franchise and the team is really poor, but I have a lot of money to spend on free agents and I'm looking forward to next year already.
Yeah IRL Brown was amazing in that game. Gwynn also took a Randy Johnson slider that no lefty I have ever seen could even foul off, down the left field line for a huge double.

Guess what, he did it in game 1 as well.

Now if they could just get it to work with Safari on the iPad, I would be all set for sure.
 
# 37 Sportsforever @ 11/15/10 02:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bkrich83
Yeah IRL Brown was amazing in that game. Gwynn also took a Randy Johnson slider that no lefty I have ever seen could even foul off, down the left field line for a huge double.

Guess what, he did it in game 1 as well.

Now if they could just get it to work with Safari on the iPad, I would be all set for sure.
Ya, if I could play this game on the go I'd be so unproductive...lol.
 
# 38 bkrich83 @ 11/15/10 02:56 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sportsforever
Ya, if I could play this game on the go I'd be so unproductive...lol.
That's a good point. If I could play this anywhere, I would probably be divorced and unemployed.
 
# 39 Sportsforever @ 11/15/10 12:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bkrich83
That's a good point. If I could play this anywhere, I would probably be divorced and unemployed.
Haha...I know what you mean! I just replayed the 2002 NLDS between Braves/Giants. All 3 games decided by 1 run...check out Game 2:

http://www.dynastyleaguebaseball.com...?SeriesID=3844
 
# 40 StormJH1 @ 11/15/10 02:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Purplepower_NC
Still....for those of us who like to build a dynasty, vs just play in tournaments or 1 season, the price tag is just too high. Like I said, if the $60 was a one time fee...maybe, just maybe I could see this.

I just don't think with this price tag it will appeal to the masses. Even, if you do play a season, not many people play out every game, and I bet most die hard fans can get thur a season in less than a month. The tournaments are good...but for long term plus price...I can't see how someone is gonna put out $14 a month.

Don't get me wrong...the game is just great. I only wish OOTP had some of the tools that this one has. I could see myself playing this for many many years.
Yeah, wow. So, I downloaded the version and played a game for free. I thought that while it lacked some of the polish and options of OOTP, I liked it and would consider playing again. Then I visited today and realized that it's actually a subscription fee: $15 a month, or essentially, $150 for the year. Are you kidding me?

I think the product is pretty good, but when you consider that I can go download OOTP8 off their site right now for absolutely free (and probably find files with roster updates, mods, etc.), how would that not be a better option? Based on the visuals, etc., I had assumed that the whole point of this was some type of free alternative to OOTP (or maybe a small, small subscription) generating money off ad revenues or whatever. OOTP debuts at like $39.99 and frequently goes on sale.

And if you're a 360 or PS3 gamer, you look at the resources that go into something like Call of Duty: Black Ops or any of the sports titles, and that's $60 up front for something you can play by yourself or online for a full year (or even longer) for hundreds of hours. How does a 90's-era text simulator warrant twice as much money? I'm not so much mad as I am frustrated for them b/c they put all this work into it, and their business model is just so backwards that I fell like 10 people are going to actually pay for it.
 


Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.