Home
Feature Article
Carraggi's Corner: FIFAmerica

It's no secret that international football is utterly lost on the majority of Americans. Yes, generally speaking, soccer is becoming more popular in the States, but we Yanks still can't even call it by its proper name. It's backwards, inside-out and upside-down. It's closest relative in the the States is hockey, which has far deeper roots in Canada.

EA's FIFA series has nonetheless become the company's cash cow (sorry Madden) in recent years, a position it would be hard-pressed to be in if not for the American dollars being shelled out for it. But FIFA is the only major sports title not primarily geared towards an American audience, even if it admittedly makes some compromises to attract said audience.

What exactly is it that average American soccer fans (like myself) want from soccer games, and how could FIFA better suit them? In rapid-fire style, let's flop -- er, dive in.


Explanations

MLB: The Show included a painfully detailed manifesto that explained everything from how to go about Rule 5 drafts to what to do with players going into arbitration -- and that was for America's pastime! So can FIFA please give us the basic ins and outs of the transfer system or what the positives and negatives of certain formations are?

Rivalries

One of the prominent reasons why the NCAA Football series is so successful is because of the rivalries. How about some information on the historic rivalries that are dripping with passion on the club level? Liverpool and Manchester United, Lazio and Roma, Barcelona and Real Madrid -- these types of rivalries might be lost on the normal fans of the San Jose Earthquakes and the Philadelphia Union. Educate us with some background information on such legendary rivalries by incorporating their importance into game modes.

Scoring

Sorry hooligans, but the elephant in the room had to be pointed out. I'm not expecting FIFA to turn the sport on its head, but it is worth stating that Americans thirst for scoring. Even in hockey there are routinely close to 30 saves per game, so the opportunities are always there, and a goal can come from nearly any point of action (just go watch Patrick Kane's Stanley Cup winning goal for confirmation). This is not so in soccer, where even the strongest offenses put about two percent of their touches on net (statistical analysis not backed up). Opening up the field by having game options like a seven-on-seven option, for instance, may help quench that thirst.

Manager Mode Improvements

Soccer obviously does not possess the statistical measurements -- some would say absurdity -- of baseball and basketball, and there is a lot less to digitally "scout" on the pitch than the gridiron (see: NFL Combine). But even for soccer, this particular mode (now dubbed Career mode) seems rather shallow. For me, this mode is not much more than a string of "Play Now" games.

Final Thoughts

Not all of these off-hand suggestions necessarily add to the sim aspects of the game, and many of the more knowledgeable fans of the game would object, but the majority of these additions would be completely optional to help ease fringe fans into the game.


What do you think? Are people who are just kind of soccer fans better off sticking to FIFA Street, or should EA try to appease casual American fans a bit more?


FIFA Soccer 11 Videos
Member Comments
# 21 KG @ 09/16/10 10:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by slystone
Adding in an extra game mode with 7 on 7 is not "changing the game", if you don't want to play that mode you don't have to. That being said, I don't think a feature like that is necessary, and it wouldn't even be fun - just too many guys on the field.

If you want more scoring, just play on an easier difficulty level - it's really not that hard to score on Amateur and Pro, even a beginner can get a handful of goals after playing a few games.

And completely disagree about the manager mode comment - you have multiple cups you can play for besides winning your League, transfers are fun and not hard to figure out, there's player development and scouting - FIFA's manager mode is intuitive and fun, and the new Career Mode is going to rule.

The only thing I agree with is more explanations, a mini-encyclopedia would be very helpful to the casual American fan (like myself).
Can't you do 7 on 7 in practice mode?
 
# 22 Whitesox @ 09/16/10 04:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMBOO
Honestly, Americans will never take to a game where flopping because some guy ran 2 feet in front of you is the norm.
You're embellishing the embellishment.

I wish some Americans would open their eyes and see that it happens in all sports, not just soccer. But I digress, just had to get that off of my chest.
 
# 23 CeltBhoy33 @ 09/16/10 06:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMBOO
Honestly, Americans will never take to a game where flopping because some guy ran 2 feet in front of you is the norm. Although I do enjoy the "Magic Spray" they have that apparently heals all "injuries" of a player that falls to the ground from not being touched. I do really enjoy the FIFA series though. And, if a game is so good it actually educates you on the nuances of a game you have never played, how is that ever a bad thing?





( must have got hit by the air ya?)




lol....







What I am saying is it happens in almost every sport.
 
# 24 cincy14fan @ 09/17/10 05:18 AM
If you want to get a lot of scoring why not play it on the easiest level. Can easily score double digit goals then without breaking a sweat. Rather make the game more realistic than arcade to attract more gamers. Apparently he hasn't paid attention to Madden this year. Last couple of years people want it to be more realistic and they never improve it to what people want and their sales are dropping. FIFA has done basically the opposite (EA doing something right, that is just crazy) but they are getting it more realistic and try to improve every year on the little things since 98 which was the turning point for FIFA.
 
# 25 CeltBhoy33 @ 09/17/10 11:18 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMBOO
It does happen in every sport, yes, just, it is that soccer is the worst of all for it, and you know that is true. As far as the NBA, flopping did not really start to be popular until the Euros started coming into the league.
Mate don't give me that ****e flopping has been in the NBA long before we even heard of basketball. Reggie Miller ring a bell? I have witnessed many kickers in the NFL fake like they got hit for a flag scobee being one of them.
 
# 26 elprez98 @ 09/17/10 11:56 AM
Water down the gameplay so that its more palatable to the mainstream gamer in America? As a sports gaming community, I'm not understanding why we would want this to happen, ever.
 
# 27 Whitesox @ 09/17/10 07:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMBOO
As far as the NBA, flopping did not really start to be popular until the Euros started coming into the league.
Really now. That's almost laughable.

As for the rest of your post, why don't you watch the defensive line next time you watch a Lions game. Watch the kickers. It happens in every sport, and the hypocrisy is just ridiculous.

You probably think it's the worst in soccer because
A) You've been told so.

or

B) Players fall a lot in soccer. You try running full speed, and having someone step on the back of your foot, or take your legs out from under you.
 
# 28 reo @ 09/20/10 12:10 AM
Play FIFA Street or Pure Futbol instead.
 

« Previous 12Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.