Batter's Box Comparison - Tomba's Blog

Arena Blog Dynasty Scores Sign Up ☰

Tomba's Blog

Batter's Box Comparison

Posted on February 25, 2009 at 12:01 AM.

(12)

Real quick screen capture of both MLB 09 and 2k9. The thing I'd like to get an opinion on is the stadium accuracy when you look far out back.

Tomba

Comments

# 1 smearz @ Feb 25

well, I'm sure they're both pretty accurate, but if you want to get nit-picky....

the color of the outfield wall in 2K9 is way off. It looks like they stole the wall from Pro Player Stadium in Florida. And the 2K9 image looks a bit cartoonish vs. the more photographic look of MLB 09.

# 2 bronco92 @ Feb 25

The effort the Sony team put into lighting in MLB 09 is clearly paying off. Cool side-by-side.

# 3 Tomba @ Feb 25

Yeah my thoughts too
I just see a different type of detail with MLB 09 that is just so impressive. Like I said before you can not beat them texture wise or line wise as the ps3 has a lot going for it in that hardware department.

# 4 bang911 @ Feb 25

Here is a decent real life photo to use as a comparison.

More photos of the stadium.http://guyspillman.net/2007BaseballTrip/phillies

# 5 R9NALD9 @ Feb 25

the difference: MLB 2k9 looks like a game, all cartoony looking and stuff.
MLB 09 The show looks like a photo, you can't even try to compare the graphics between these two, The show wipes the floor with 2k9.

# 6 R9NALD9 @ Feb 25

unfortunately though, after having a second look, why would you want to compare the two games when one pic is day time and the other pic night time, it is pointless.

# 7 SeaNNyT @ Feb 25

Wow never realized how good MLB:the show looks. If it had signature animations, WOW.

# 8 SeaNNyT @ Feb 25

Makes me wish I didn't only own an xbox360.

# 9 smearz @ Feb 25

Actually, most player animations in The Show are more "signature" than those in 2K. They are spot on most of the time.

# 10 Kenny Powers @ Feb 26

ya your right Tomba MLB THE SHOW 09 looks awesome thanks for the comparison holmes

# 11 techhokies @ Feb 27

While it's pretty clear that the show has the more realistic look to it, I like the look of both games. I like how 2k looks more like a videogame, as it's more bright and flashy, so it's not a bad thing for me at all. But if I had to pick only one, I would go with the show.