In my opinion the Madden physics (at this point) don't look very good. I'm actually liking what I see from NCAA in the animation department. First time in a while. I found myself, while watching the Oregon vs. USC footage, thinking to myself, wow, that animation actually looked pretty good.

I would rather have solid gameplay and let Madden test out the physics first, then add them in 14. Here's hoping for solid gameplay.

You know, thats a very very solid point. While I feel like they really should have added it into 13', you could make an argument that NCAA has a solid gameplay engine. It'll be like a very glorified NCAA 11.
Which is not hating. They've basically been tweaking it for 3 years now and the product should be a very well polished.

It's like would you rather have Colt McCoy in year 3, or Cam Newton in year 1?
Both have their strengths and weaknesses.
Great point.

To me this years madden will be an unfinished product as the physics wont be fully finished, but NCAA will have more time to polish it and finish it for next year. I can see a lot of people complaining about the physics in this years Madden.

@Ven0m43 I agree people are going to bitch about Madden because its not good enough!

I do think NCAA will be fine and the gameplay and recruiting will be just fine!

Ill take Cam in year 1...