Users Online Now: 3747  |  September 28, 2024
LucianoJJ's Blog
EA Sports: Purchase or 9-Month rental? 
Posted on June 21, 2012 at 12:25 PM.

The publicity surrounding FIFA 13 at E3 was good enough to make me sell my copy of FIFA 12 to Gamestop. If I need a futbol fix, I can always turn to 2010 FIFA World Cup. Along with FIFA I rid myself of NCAA Football 12. In one transaction I let go of my all-time favorite game and my least favorite game for a fraction of their release day value, in exchange for the hope that FIFA 13 will be even better.

EA Sports games are rarely worth keeping beyond a calendar year from their release. They don't hold their value. They seem redundant. For every advance, there is a flaw. To tuck them away, then find a box filled with games that are several years old, is embarrassing. Then you do the math ($59.99 times a bunch of games=too much for a gaming fix). I have a box filled with original Xbox games. Those games were survivors of an earlier purge, for an embarrassingly poor trade-in value.

Maybe some subscription based download model would be a better deal. Retailers would be devastated by this. Gamestop would be doomed, another empty slot in the mall, or shopping center. They would disappear like coin-op arcades. Big box retailers would write gaming off, just as they did with VHS and will soon be doing with DVD.

I don't sell everything every year. I've gone to an every-other-year approach on sports I like but don't love. NBA 2K12 is a keeper, but I won't be getting this fall's installment. I hung onto NHL 11, and I might grab NHL 13, if there are decent Black Friday sales or other deals. GT5 stays since it's not an annual release and gets periodic DLC. Top Spin 4 stays until Top Spin 5 comes out, if ever. NCAA Basketball 10 is a collectors item to me, in spite of flawed gameplay and dated graphics. F1 2011 was on the bubble, since I've hung onto Sony's underrated Formula One Championship Edition. I may never give up PYS 6.

I look forward to the new and improved versions of FIFA and NCAA Football. I hope they justify the hype. If not, the "rental" cycle will repeat, and more money will be lost.





Comments
# 1 SkillzKillz719 @ Jun 22
Good points. I decided to just got with GameFly to solve those problems to me.
I added it up and the 5 or 6 games I was getting for sure were around $230, whereas 10 months of GameFly is about $240. Which I can rent whatever I want. Obviously I know I wont get FIFA 13 RIGHT away or anything. But I'd have so many games I'd want (NHL 13, Far Cry 3, Hitman, 2k13, and NBA Live 13) and Madden. So I dunno. I agree though that they make their previous games obsolete after they release their new game.
 
LucianoJJ
19
LucianoJJ's Blog Categories
LucianoJJ's Screenshots (0)

LucianoJJ does not have any albums to display.
LucianoJJ's Friends
Recent Visitors
The last 10 visitor(s) to this Arena were:

LucianoJJ's Arena has had 52,130 visits